4 ms·
The fundamental flaw with Chaumian token systems is that the trustworthiness of the currency is completely concentrated in the identity of the exchange. The kin
by mindslight 14y ago
The fundamental flaw with Chaumian token systems is that the trustworthiness of the currency is completely concentrated in the identity of the exchange. The kind of institutions which build up and delegate trustworthy identities (eg governments, banks) are inherently predisposed against anonymous transactions.
- rdl 14y agoThe point of a decentralized system would be to have large numbers of issuers, each of which might have independent ways to become trusted. The exchange itself doesn't need to be particularly trusted; you could do a transaction either instantaneous and of low value, or some more complex protocol. There's also no inherent monopoly for the exchange, although there's a natural monopoly for any given pair of currencies. Assuming everything is automated and low friction, you could be in and out of a given currency to make a transaction pretty fast, so arbitrarily short risk. You could split transactions up into smaller transactions so arbitrarily low financial risk per transaction.
- mindslight 14y agoIf you can't be confident that an exchange (blind token signing key) will hold value for the long term, the exchanges are really only functioning as short-term mixes for some 'real' currency (as you describe), and the problem remains creating a currency issuer that won't eventually work to prevent anonymous transactions. In your described system, the issuers still face the fundamental problem of having to have a good reputation, but being unable to obtain this reputation in the standard way (real-world identity in a powerful "rule of law" jurisdiction), lest the delegator 'discourage' them from facilitating anonymous transactions. Multiple competing issuers do not help the situation due to the catastrophic failure mode of each - bank run and worthless currency. Creating a widespread reputation that isn't derived from real-world identity is the problem that bitcoin is attempting to solve, which is why the novel part of it is solving a coordination problem and not a problem from cryptography.