4 ms·
Out of curiosity, what's your honest preference in the situation? Where do you come down?
by angersock 14y ago
Out of curiosity, what's your honest preference in the situation? Where do you come down?
- tptacek 14y agoI have a hard time believing that transparency and documentation requirements pose a real threat to our national security and, while I believe that there probably is a good-faith concern that new documentation requirements could further slow down a system that is already hugely overtaxed, I generally say "fuck 'em, figure it out". Oversight good. Transparency good. On the other hand, the message board response to FISA appears to be a blanket call for an end to spying period. I'd love to live in a world where nobody needed espionage or intelligence services, but I'm not interested in litigating whether we actually live in that world now. As long as FISA isn't perverted into a tool for bringing drug charges against Americans, I'm not very concerned about the underlying mechanism. I think Rand Paul is just showboating. I wish Leahy's amendment requiring warrants for domestic electronic mail older than 180 days had succeeded.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- angersock 14y agoAh, fair enough. I suspected your position might be a bit more nuanced than a casual reading of posts would've suggested. As long as FISA isn't perverted into a tool for bringing drug charges against Americans You and I do both realize what will probably happen here, right?
- tptacek 14y agoNo, I don't think that's at all likely.
- angersock 14y agoEither your sarcasm is a great deal drier than I'm used to, or you're serious. Mind providing your reasoning?
- tptacek 14y agoI do not believe the US Government is a giant conspiracy to evade the constitution for the purpose of apprehending drug users. I believe that when the government seeks a warrant to surveil foreign targets for counterterrorism, their interests are actually in disrupting terrorism. That doesn't mean I think we have effective counterterrorism (for instance, there's widespread evidence that CIA uses, or at least for a long time used, torture to attempt to obtain information in counterterrorism cases; torture is morally repellent and, equally importantly, demonstrably counterproductive), or that I think terrorism is legitimately the key federal goal that DHS and CIA claim that it is. But I don't subscribe to the slippery slope argument that suggests that the government will inevitably use every power we give it for any purpose to, I don't know, enforce the Comics Code Authority.
- Flemlord 14y agoThe US government has a long history of using laws for much broader purposes than originally intended. The PATRIOT Act has many great examples: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversial_invocations_of_the_USA_PATRIOT_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversial_invocations_of_th... I don't see why warrantless wiretaps would be held to a higher standard than similar prior laws.
- philwelch 14y agoAside from what tptacek has to say, there's generally a strong distinction between intelligence and law enforcement that's more or less enforced by the exclusionary rule. Ironically, there might actually be benefits to outright warrantless wiretapping as opposed to use of the FISA court to obtain warrants, namely that any such wiretaps could only be used for intelligence purposes, never for law enforcement.
- justinschuh 14y agoGiven the scope and focus of FISA legislation that's extremely unlikely. It would be far easier to use some other legislative vehicle than try to shoehorn something into FISA that is already explicitly outside its scope.