9 ms·
What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids?
- larrys 14y agoWould like to point out something here that might not be obvious to those discussing the pros and con's of having kids. Some people are really into kids and have made that choice and couldn't do without kids. They enjoy kids like some of us enjoy computers. They want as many kids as they can and don't think of any of it as a burden or "work". It's just pure joy to them. Just like some of us like to program and "play" with computers and find it fun. Then there are as you know people who don't derive any enjoyment from kids and would rather just work and do what they want. Just like there are people who find no enjoyment in doing the things that some of us do for fun. Nothing wrong with that. Don't be pressured into having kids just because it's what society seems to tell you is the best thing to do. It definitely doesn't float the boat of everyone just as everyone is not all into computers, cars, skiing, knitting or pets. Everyone is different.
- xsmasher 14y agoThe answer seems to be "depends who you are." Some people have an overriding and insatiable drive to have children, and would be miserable without them. Others have no such drive, or an aversion to children, and are perfectly happy without them. The trick to to make sure you and your partner are on the same page about this, and I mean long before getting hitched or moving in together. Like third-date long before.
- shawnphoffman 14y agoIn an age of heavy social norms and pressure from peers to get married ASAP, the same could be said for topics like religion, financials, and less-importantly politics. Not discussing these things early on are a recipe for disaster.
- hndude 14y agoWhere do you see pressure from peers to get married ASAP? Maybe its because I'm still in college, but almost everyone I've spoken to (in my age group) wants to wait until their late 20s, if not 30s to settle down and get married.
- dclusin 14y agoThis is a tricky issue to sort out because opinions and desires aren't set in stone. I've known more than a few friends who have had relationships deteriorate because initially they were on the same page but one party ended up changing their minds. As with all relationships whether they be personal or professional the most important part of the relationship is to maintain open lines of communication with the other party.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoThis is where I'm at now. My wife and I were married when I was 25 and she was 23. I just turned 30, and while back then I was all about having children, I'd like to put it off as I still have a lot of places to visit, things to do, etc. She, on the other hand, is ready to have children. Now. Since she's 28, she has a plan to have X kids, spaced X years apart. The next 6-12 months of our relationship will be interesting.
- Tichy 14y agoCan't you visit those places together with your kids? I was 38 when we had our son and I already regret being so old. There is the worry of staying fit and healthy as long as possible to be there for him. Also, his grandparents enjoy him very much. Should my son wait as long as I did to have children, I would already be 76 - so probably much less joy with grandchildren. And lots more issues like that. If you have a kid, being fit and healthy suddenly becomes so much more important. Sure, I wanted to live before I had a kid, too. But the reality is that dieing would bother me much more now than before having a kid (yes I know it wouldn't bother me anymore once I'm dead...). Also, pregnancy becomes more difficult and risky for older women. And if you have a kid and decide you actually like it, might be nice to have some spare years to create more. Just saying...
- toomuchtodo 14y agoAntartica. Working for the DPW (Dept of Public Works) at Burning Man one year. Zero-gravity flights. Wing-suit skydiving. Living in Amsterdam for a year. This is just a short chunk of things copied from my bucket list. Kids don't mix well with the above activities.
- stmartin 14y agoIf you have an aversion to children, you must get your head checked immediately because of any unresolved childhood trauma you might be at the effect of. If it's not trauma related, then maybe start looking toward God for answers on why one would have an 'aversion' toward children.
- supercanuck 14y agoIs there ever a question in life that doesn't seem to start with,"depends"?
- dromidas 14y agoHurray :) 31 and no kids here, don't plan on having any. My habits and personality would make me a freakin awful parent and I would hate it more than the kids would after they grew up having me a parent. So no thanks, no kids for me.
- Tichy 14y agoI know this sounds tired, but 31 isn't really the typical age when people start having regrets. At 31 I was still going to dance clubs. Even then it was weird because most people there were in their twenties. Now it would feel even weirder, although I think I might go again now and then... Just saying that the things that seem like fun when you are 31 might not always be fun when you are older. One example might be dating. Of course not necessarily.
- Evbn 14y agoUnless you are a sugar daddy/mommy, dating transitions from drunken hot hookups to desperate mating search over time.
- dromidas 14y agoWow just read the answer from the guy on there: "And then it dawns on you, your purpose in life: It's love. A life without love is a life without purpose and completely meaningless. And I'm not talking about the kind of love you feel for your soul mate. That love is not invincible. I'm talking about unconditional love. The kind of love only children have to give and would die inside without it." What a prick. If your life is meaningless without kids go move to the midwest and shack up with some girl out of highschool desperate to get kids. My life certainly isn't meaningless. I get a lot of enjoyment and meaning out of my life, but perhaps I'm different than most since I actually consider intellectual challenges meaningful.
- shawnphoffman 14y ago"...move to the midwest and shack up with some girl out of highschool desperate to get kids." This is more accurate than I care to admit.
- bdcravens 14y agoI think it depends on the why. I have Cystic Fibrosis, which has a 98% infertility rate among males (edit: not so much infertile as much as CF gives you a built-in vasectomy). IVF is an option, but my wife's age (36) means the clock is ticking and nothing is guaranteed. I can't speak for her, but I'd like them, but have put myself in a place where my life's outlook isn't defined by whether or not I'm ever a parent.
- robodale 14y ago39. Married for 11+ years. No kids. We go on vacations, work out, visit friends and family, and I build websites and applications on the side. We both complain we have no time. I could not imagine our lives with kids.
- duck 14y agoI'm a couple years younger than you and have four kids (6yo to a newborn). We do all the things you do except for one thing: complain we have no time (but I do remember doing that before I had any kids!). I think kids give you a new outlook on time and the fact you just have to enjoy what time you do have.
- lukev 14y agoI can't speak to the sentiments expressed by the article, as I have not yet reached that point of life. But as the father of a toddler (and probably another in the relatively near future), I can say that it isn't all reward, at least in the short term. It's exhausting. I have a massive list of ideas and half-started projects that I feel too burned out to work on productively by the time the kid's in bed, and weekends (which used to by my personal project time) are pretty much gone. If any parent/hackers out there have any tips on how to stay motivated and productive with kids, I'd love to hear it. Or is it just a matter of waiting until they're a bit older? This isn't just about "personal and financial success", by the way... I am happy to put my kid ahead of personal career and finance (although I actually find that to be fairly compatible, as long as I can get in a standard work week, which my wife graciously allows me). What suffers is my own personal motivations and fulfillment, my own hobbies, education and art.
- corresation 14y agoI am happy to put my kid ahead of personal career and finance (although I actually find that to be fairly compatible While children are often held as the opposite choice to personal and financial success, as a parent with four young children let me say that in certain spheres exactly the opposite is often true -- there is something fundamentally motivating when you have children if you have the tools to optimize the situation. For years I idled in various positions, but the moment kids entered the scene all pistons started firing.
- jaysonlane 14y agoI'd agree with this completely, also having a child has given me patience with myself. If I can learn how to keep a little person alive and well, I can conquer any bug or feature request that comes my way :D
- jaysonlane 14y agoI have a 9 month old and just released the first app I've done completely on my own (design, develop, market) since his birth. My wife and I both work full-time so we are constantly on the go. I woke up earlier than everyone else. I stayed at my computer during lunch. I went to bed later than everyone else. It was tough but it was worth it and I'll do it again soon.
- drivingmenuts 14y ago45. No kids. No wife. Just me and a cat. I choose whom I consider my family from among my friends. Beyond that, I doubt I'm in a stable enough situation to have more than that.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoNice thing when I hit the end of my 30s, people stopped asking me when I was going to get married and have kids. Just never had the urge for kids and figured if I didn't feel the desire it wouldn't be a good idea. Came close to marriage once or twice and I might again, but kids no. I like kids. I like my brother's kids. I like my friends' kids. Just don't want my own.
- ChrisBanner 14y agoI admire someone who can conclude that their lifestyle would not be conducive to raising a child as much as I admire a great parent. Ultimately, the worst scenario would be to have a child you were unfit to care for. That said, I think a lot of couples wrestling with this question are rather tough on themselves. More are fit for this sort of thing than they might realize.
- wallywax 14y agoIt's amazing. If that's what you want. If you want kids, have them. That's great, I'll be genuinely happy for you, and I'll come to their birthdays, graduations, and weddings. We don't want kids of our own, and are very satisfied and fulfilled with our lives. So please, try to understand that, and be happy for us in return.
- freehunter 14y agoMy grandparents make me feel so bad for not having kids. I thought the pressure would go away after my niece was born, but nope. The older people in my life like huge families and a constant stream of babies. The last thing I need in my life is more responsibility and less time, and my SO feels the same way.
- chrisbennet 14y agoMy wife and I have no kids but I tell people we're a one child family - I'm the child. ;-) Children make me smile when I see them but I have no desire to reproduce. Natural selection has selected for parents that experience great joy in having children. Those that didn't have this response probably ate their young. <g>
- stmartin 14y agoHeavens forbid if you said God instead of "natural selection" on a uber-geek site....
- supercanuck 14y agoI'm convinced children are one of those things that one is never "ready" for. I was an only child with very limited access to young children even into my 20's. I always was averse growing up to other people's kids, never wanted to touch or hold them and was convinced I didn't want them either. It wasn't until I obliged my wife that we had them. There are plenty of times it is a struggle but I echo the sentiment that until you've experienced that unconditional love, you haven't fully lived. That isn't a judgement on those who choose not too, because, I too was one of those people looking at the crying kid on the airplane with disdain, but, no question, kids changes your whole outlook of the world.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nobodysfool 14y agoNah, I was ready for children 3 years ago, just hadn't found the right woman until two years ago. Now I'm the proud parent of a 1 year old. I never wanted to have kids until about 3 years ago. I knew I wasn't ready then. Our kid wasn't an accident, she was planned, and I am glad that our plan worked out. She's a delight, and I love every minute that I spend with her. The decision to have a child isn't about vanity, or narcissism. You have to put up with being kicked, vomited on, abused and hated when you become a father / mother. That comes with the territory. You have to put someone above yourself, and it really is a humbling experience.
- AndrewDucker 14y agoI wasn't ready for a kid until I spent some time around my nephew when he was born. Acclimatisation is a wonderful thing.
- mattdeboard 14y agoI'm a single dad, like really single. Mom isn't really in the picture and besides from my wonderful girlfriend don't have much help at all. It's getting easier as my daughter gets older (almost 9 now) but wow I really don't want any more kids. I like the idea of it but I think I'm done. I don't begrudge anyone if they love having kids and think it's the best, nor if they never want any kids ever because they're terrible little monsters. On most days I feel both ways. I'll be in my early 40s when I lock my kid out of the house for the last time after I shoo her off to college (or whatever). I don't want to be parenting into my 50s or 60s. I'm done.
- rayiner 14y agoAs a new parent who is unexpectedly a parent earlier than I thought I would be... I can see why people choose not to have kids. They're expensive, they're noisy, and they really limit your ability to be spontaneous. That being said, it seems to have become fairly popular to rag on having kids, and I think at least some of the angst is derived from buying into certain cultural expectations about having kids despite rejecting the general cultural expectation to have kids. American culture makes parenting out to be a lot harder than it is. If you're a mom who doesn't stay at home with her kids, bake cookies for the PTA, send them to a dozen after school activities, etc, you're a bad parent and your kids will grow up to be unsuccessful degenerates. I think that's overstated. Right now, I'm in New York working while my wife is with my parents in DC taking care of our newborn while she finishes final exams for law school. Out of 5 weeks of the baby's life, I've missed half. And you know what? She'll never remember it. American culture creates this huge conflict between careers and raising young children that doesn't need to be so big. We say "these are the best years, you shouldn't miss them" but that's for us, not the kids. I miss my daughter terribly. She has no idea that I (or anything else) continue to exist when she can't see me. My dad travelled internationally 50% of the time while my brother and I were small children. How was it affected us? Not at all--I don't even remember anything before 5 or 6 or so. The same thing is true for activities when the child is older. Suburban parents spend enormous amounts of time just driving around, from ballet class to soccer practice, etc. But nobody on their death bed has ever lamented they didn't do ballet as a child instead of just running around in the back yard with friends. Suburbia itself creates huge artificial roadblocks. Commutes that suck away time, big houses that get filled with toys, etc. All that is unnecessary. Entire generations of kids grew up in the city where they could be ditched with the neighbor on short notice if necessary. Those cities still exist. It's still possible to walk from work to your apartment, picking up the kid and some dinner on the way. All this is not to say that having kids doesn't create real challenges. Infancy is going to be a rough deal for you if you're not good at sleeping in 3 hour blocks. When you go to work, you have to find somewhere to put them for 8-10 hours a day, preferably somewhere they won't get killed. But there is a middle ground between not having kids and having kids then abandoning your career, hobbies, etc, and moving to the sururbs and joining the PTA.
- dbrannan 14y ago
- michaelkscott 14y agoProtip: have or not have kids.
- rsingel 14y agoWait, now Quora is now syndicating answers as blog posts to publications? Do users know this? Does Quora ask permission? Do users get a rev share? Looks exactly like what Instagram was trying to do. Update: Answered my own question. Looks like Quora does ask permission. At least that's what the announcement of the partnership said: http://www.quora.com/blog/Quora-Partners-with-Slate http://www.quora.com/blog/Quora-Partners-with-Slate
- danso 14y agoWhat's strange (sad?) is that I am most definitely adult age but, being someone who lives in NYC and works at a startup, my mindset was "I wonder what I'll do when I'm at that age?"...I guess I'm qualified to answered: for me, not having kids now is not different than not having kids in college. Not enough philosophically about my life (marital status ir probably the key one) has changed since then. Very few of my friends, the same age or older in NYC, have children either. And my guess is that this state of affairs could exist for years to come until suddenly I'm thinking, "I wonder if I should've tried to have children?"
- superk 14y agoI'm 35, been together with my wife for about 8 years and we're finally expecting our first kid in about 1 month. We were both always firmly in the "no kids" camp, the cost/benefit ratio just never seemed to add up. So what changed our minds? Partly it was peer pressure: everyone I know by this time has had kids, people who I respect, smarter people than myself. But mostly it was two slow realizations I've had: 1. It is part of the lifecycle, it is part of being an adult. The link at the top is mislabeled, you can't be an "adult" and not have kids. Yes it's grueling and miserable, but discomfort grounds you and gives you perspective. People that never leave their comfort zone never grow... they don't "grow up". 2. I personally believe it is the key to immortality. I'm not talking reincarnation or ancestor worship. Just a mental image I have every being that lived and died since the beginning of time to create me (or you), like threads in a fabric, and then you don't procreate and it's like "snip" and that thread ends.
- xsmasher 14y ago> The link at the top is mislabeled, you can't be an "adult" and not have kids. I don't know what drive you to that conclusion, or what makes you equate not having children with never leaving your comfort zone. I know parents who are not "adults" in the grounded/perspective sense, and childless couples with more perspective than I can conceive.
- superk 14y agoI agree with you - absolutely. The potential for growth and perspective as a human being is innate - some people have more of it than others. Though those people with greater potential - an awareness that our experiences can change us - are exactly the kind of people who leave their comfort zone more - versus the author of the linked story who writes: "But when I thought about what it took to get there, the diapers, the soccer games, the braces, the tantrums, the whole enchilada, I knew that it wasn't for me." That was the kind of person I had in mind.
- blazingfrog2 14y agoI couldn't agree more. That's pretty much my stock answer when, after complaining about how much my kids eat out of me, I get the "you-chose-to-have-them" look. Having kids forces you out of you comfort zone, forces you to constantly adapt, evolve, go with the flow of life. As painful as it may seem sometimes, I believe it's all worth it. You also hit the nail on the head with your second point. Without going to the extreme of living vicariously through another being which can never be healthy for either party, looking at your child grow up and go through the fascinating steps of learning life (steps I've long forgotten), I can't help but feel a little bit of myself feel that amazement myself.
- malachismith 14y agoEvery day I say a little prayer of thanks for getting to where I am without having kids. Every time I spend time with my (many) friends who have kids (and now grandkids in some cases), I understand why they've made this choice and yet feel even more validated in my own choice. And every time someone says, "how do you look so young for your age" or "how can you possibly afford to live the way you live and go the places you go and have the experiences you have" - I just smile and say, "no kids."
- jdietrich 14y agoThe second author is a narcissist and a fool. People have chosen not to have children for at least as long as people have been writing down their thoughts. Most cultures throughout history have a monastic class of some sort, who renounce many aspects of conventional life to pursue other aims. There are myriad ways to live a significant, meaningful life without children. If you cannot think of a worthwhile use of your life that is not focussed on either your own material enrichment or raising your own progeny, that is merely a reflection of your own worthlessness. Saying "I regret having children" is one of the most taboo sentences in our society. Until we address that taboo, we are unlikely to find an honest answer as to whether having children really is a source of fulfilment.
- theorique 14y agoDon't know if he's a narcissist, but he's definitely sanctimonious about having seen the light.
- usaphp 14y agoactually narcissist and fool will be a person who decides that satisfying his own hunger for travel and business is more important than evolution.
- arrrg 14y agoEvolution is brutal and without mercy. To fight it’s brutality and lack of mercy should always be our goal. It is not and never will be our friend. We shall triumph over it. To make any of our decisions dependent on it makes no sense.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoChoosing not to reproduce is also a part of evolution.
- ErrantX 14y agoNot really. #2 is a narcassist because having kids is all about him and his fulfillment/ego.
- rdl 14y agoUgh. Where did they find those people? (oh, apparently at Quora, which makes me sad for my people) I, at 33, still wake up at least 3 times a week thinking "thank god I don't have children", and pretty much have felt that way for as long as I can remember. I really like my freedom. I mean, I'm reluctant to buy houseplants because they would tie me to one place to maintain them. Kids would be ok if they could be shipped off to boarding school most of the time, or were adults, but I viscerally hate being around young (under 10-12yo, but especially under 3yo) children. I am probably less likely to get married (not wanting kids) than I would be otherwise, but I'm fine with living in sin indefinitely. (I see no real benefit to marriage other than the legal benefits, and for me, those seem mostly negative).
- Tichy 14y agoNo offense to you, but I think they asked older people, not people in their thirties.
- RyanZAG 14y agoHaving children is not 'doing your part' anymore, and people need to understand this. We are quickly reaching the point where we have enough humans in the world. Feel free to have children if you want them, but please understand that 'doing your part' is quickly changing to mean 'no children - we have enough'. If you want to do your part, rather adopt a child. Also, the world isn't all about you.
- prodigal_erik 14y agoWe exceeded "enough humans in the world" forty years ago. Now we're basically manufacturing food out of fertilizer, which only works until the fossil fuel runs low (or a crash program of nuclear energy, which we haven't started). The Green Revolution was an impressive achievement, but one we are not prepared to repeat.
- Tichy 14y agoMaybe I would feel worse about having contributed to overpopulation if other people wouldn't multiply in such an unchecked fashion. What is the world all about anyway? Since I have a child, I actually want my friends to have children too, so that my child can have friends, too. Rather selfishly (you might even say racist), I want my culture to survive. The probability seems quite high that my child will be confronted with a difficult future. That held me off from having children for a long time, but ultimately, they deserve their chance. I don't need 10 children, but one or two should be OK.
- RyanZAG 14y agoThat's a pretty strange and common "us vs them" mentality. Unfortunately it doesn't really work - both your children and everybody else's children are all still human, as much as some people like to believe otherwise. It also doesn't work in the same way that making your adverts on a page bigger than your competitor's adverts doesn't work: eventually both you and your competitor have adverts so big that there is no content left on the page. Then the page is just junk mail and gets tossed in the trash...
- 14y ago
- usaphp 14y agoI don't understand why people are saying "I have so many things left to do and so many places to visit, I can't have kids now". But you can do all that with kids and have even more fun than doing all that by yourself...
- aortega 14y ago>I don't understand why people are saying "I have so many things left to do and so many places to visit, I can't have kids now". But you can do all that with kids and have even more fun than doing all that by yourself... Exactly. I have a 2 year old, two months after he was born I founded a security company (so you could say I'm a hacker). I have visited more places in this 2 years than in the 32 years before that. It's crazy sometimes, all the work, no sleep, wife hates me when I come too late from work, etc. But I love my son, I wish I could have 100 like him. Matter of fact I can, but wife doesn't approve :) Protip: If you want kids DONT wait until you have a nice job, house, car, etc. by that time you are in your 40's and it's way more difficult.
- debacle 14y ago> I mean the screaming kid in the restaurant. I'll say this for everyone else out there - deciding to not have kids based on bad kids in public is like deciding to not buy a house because of that one guy who never mows his lawn. My kids have never had an outburst in public. Had one have gone into a temper tantrum or anything of the sort, I would have quietly left the establishment as a courtesy to others. You don't notice the people who raise their kids well or have good kids because they go out of their way not to be a burden to others. I'll call myself lucky that I have two great, artistic, and intelligent kids that are also mannered and polite, but it's less about luck and more about parenting. If you want to have kids, and are scared by that horror scene in the restaurant, rest assured that you can have kids that aren't like that. It's not luck, it's parenting.
- rayiner 14y agoA great article along those lines: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204740904577196931457473816.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405297020474090457719...
- malachismith 14y agoIt should not be "decide to not have kids" It should be "decide to have kids" Having kids is a major decision. Not having them is not.
- debacle 14y agoIf you're a normal human being, it's actually a lot of work (or an outpatient surgery, for me) to not have kids.
- malachismith 14y agoUsing a condom is hardly comparable to having a kid (in work, implications, responsibility -- ie "decision)
- debacle 14y ago
- rocky1138 14y agoI'm confused by the first author's response: part of the way through the article she explains she regrets it and then quickly contradicts herself. Did she truly regret it or not? Or has she not yet decided?
- afterburner 14y ago"We've always had two or three dogs at a time" Damn... all that time walking the dogs... coulda had a kid! The thing about people hating shrieking children, that seems to be a very strong sentiment among those who feel the same. I really wonder what it is, because I really am able to tune it out, or at least not let it bother me much. Is it about taking it personally, or is that a condescending (and incorrect) theory?
- dhimes 14y agoIf you choose to not have kids, think very carefully about this. Reading things like this post may help you anticipate some of the emotions you are going to feel. I say this because I've witnessed a pattern that I find very tragic: A couple in their relative youth (30s) decide that they don't want kids. Later, however, they start having second thoughts. And by the time they decide that they do want kids, they are desperate. IVF rates, to my knowledge, are still pretty low (once you rule out the four-fertilizations-at-once average-movers), and carrying to term is also hard. So there is depression and tragedy every time the bad news is revealed- the pregnancy didn't take, or the woman miscarried. I know several people who regret not having kids, but I don't know any who regret having kids (or, to be fair, admit to regretting it). I'm not trying to preach here, I'm just saying that I would recommend only making the decision not to have kids after giving it a deep, emotional consideration. The rational reasons (I wouldn't be good at it, etc.), may not hold up as you age.
- zzzeek 14y agoThis is an extremely important comment that I'm glad has been made in the midst of the other "kids are overrated" comments I see here. If you don't want kids, great. But if you are in your early 30s and don't have much of an opinion yet, start thinking about it right now. Fertility drops like a stone in the mid thirties, and due to our delays in this area my wife and I will probably remain childless despite an outlay of many tens of thousands of dollars over the course of seven years towards many failed fertility procedures. If writing a check for $20000 in exchange for absolutely nothing but yet another heartbreak in return doesn't appeal to you, please make sure you make thoughtful decisions about having kids sooner than you might usually think is warranted.
- xnxn 14y agoStupid question, I know, but have you considered adoption? I wouldn't exist at all if my grandparents hadn't.
- zzzeek 14y agoAdoption is a $30-$60K process to embark upon and often takes years, featuring many potential roadblocks - the recent Russian decision for example shuts the door to many couples who've been waiting for months or years on waiting lists. Domestic adoption is a complex process also. Assuming our upcoming donor cycle fails, adoption will be our final alternative. We are in our mid-40s now.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mgkimsal 14y agoMarried 15 years, no kids, no desire. I can't have kids, I think my wife would have had kids had she married someone else who wanted kids, but has never expressed that she's wanted kids (and has more recently expressed thanks that we don't have any). What's it like? It's just life. You keep living, with or without kids. What does bother me some is the moral high ground some people take when they know you don't have kids. "You couldn't possibly understand what it's like." "Once you have kids, you'll know." To some extent, that might be true, but I don't think it's impossible to make judgements about certain situations without being in that situation entirely. Some people tend to make a lot more judgements about me and my decision not to have kids than I do about their choice to have kids. "But... no kids? That's so selfish of you!" Then 10 minutes later... "aren't you worried about who will take care of you when you're older?". WTH?
- larrys 14y agoFunny. I had noted your name after seeing what you did quite some time ago. Now I just updated it with "has no kids". (A bonus to me). I hired an attorney many years ago and when I found out he had no kids that was a plus. It meant that he would be able to think about law without distraction and I wouldn't be hearing excuses about how he left the office early to watch the soccer game. (I have kids by the way but have managed to still keep work a priority. I haven't found this to be universal though.) I was right about the attorney. Many Friday's he was at the office late and was generally available any day any time he didn't have many distractions. Of course I'm not commenting on what is good for him but for me I saw it as a positive.
- mgkimsal 14y agoNot sure what I did to get 'noted', but I hope it was good :) I might dispute your view of that attorney - he may well have many other distractions that prevent him from getting stuff done, but certainly the 'time with the kids' factor isn't there. Of course, when interviewing people for jobs, we're never supposed to ask about personal/family issues, but I do eventually bring it up (though I haven't been in a job interview in several years). My wife and I are both self-employed, have no kids, and are able to devote stretches of time to work when necessary. I point that out - "if you need someone to travel and stay overnight, I've got no issues with that" sort of thing. Not sure it helped all that much for 'jobs', but it has helped in freelance/consulting. "Yes, I can be there tomorrow, and my fee is $x".
- danielrm26 14y agoI believe the future will see far fewer people having children simply because it won't be necessary. I've captured a lot of this idea here: http://danielmiessler.com/blog/the-future-of-human-identity-and-reproduction http://danielmiessler.com/blog/the-future-of-human-identity-... . Basically, as we move from 100,000 years ago to 1000 years from now we'll have gone from needing to have children to survive to essentially living forever. All the way back there was zero individuality, and we have more now, and we'll have more in the future. Individuality is the opposite of parenting. That's why women are still behind. To a larger extent than men they live their lives for their children. And when you pour your entire life force into another human, you simply cannot achieve the same as someone who does that to create art or music or literature. Men started being individuals before women did, and they are ahead as a result. Women are catching up, though, and that's a good thing. The important thing is that in the distant future we won't have the requirement. When we are creative life forces with arbitrary bodies that live (effectively) forever, what will be the need for reproduction? At that point we'll be enlightened entities providing services for each other. In short, reproduction is a vestigial requirement that we sill possess. And because it's evolutionary it provides us pleasure, but it will give out to advanced happiness in the future, and that happiness is the happiness of creating art, music, literature, etc. There will still be children for a long time, and they should be celebrated and loved enjoyed when they do happen. But we've long since past the time where everyone needs to make them. In fact, it's nearly becoming criminal to keep making them when so many exist that have no loving parents. As for the article's direct point of whether one can be happy without them, I think the answer lies in how much happiness one can gain from being an individual. If you are an author or a painter or a musician, and you truly love what you do because it helps other people then you likely are tapping into the same sensation that parents get--and likely something more as well. For people like that, having children is not a requirement. And since this should be the goal anyway, i.e. people CREATING things for others to enjoy (as opposed to http://danielmiessler.com/blog/parent-to-child-propagation-of-false-meaning http://danielmiessler.com/blog/parent-to-child-propagation-o...) then those who can do so should pursue this course without fear. As for those who simply feel elation from raising children, there should be no shame in that either. Opposing nature in the name of a distant, future type of happiness that may not be possible for that person is not likely to be fulfilling. It's not time to abandon parenthood. But it is time to adopt adoption, and to look forward to a time when creation of art and beauty should become the goal of everyone living rather than a default action of creating new humans who will participate in a mostly meaningless means of making money so that their offspring can do the same. Anyway, sorry for the ramble. I think a lot about this.
- 16s 14y ago"We've always had two or three dogs at a time" A dog is not a human child. It's not even close. I've had dogs and kids. I know the difference. Why childless people compare their dogs to human children is beyond me. It's a dog. In the wild they run in packs and kill moose and stuff. It's not a child and never will be, so please stop pretending that it is.
- Tichy 14y agoAlso, I suspect dogs are actually a lot more work to maintain than kids. Changing diapers was actually no big deal at all, but I can't imagine having to pick up my dogs feces from the road (because if you are a nice dog owner, you do that, right?).
- aortega 14y ago>Also, I suspect dogs are actually a lot more work to maintain than kids. Ha, lets see: a Dog can raise a litter of 6 puppies every year with no effort, but to correctly raise 2 or 3 humans you need the time and income of at least two adults, for a lifetime. Which looks more difficult to you?
- Tichy 14y agoNot sure about that: have you had dogs raise 6 puppies in your house? If you argue like that, kids can be raised much cheaper, too. And there are even examples of kids being raised by wolves, I think? Hm, problem solved: get a dog and a kid, let the dog raise the kid?
- aortega 14y agoHave you raised a kid? lets try another example, you get fed up with the puppies barking all day, you could legally kill them all in the spot (horrible I know, but some people do that). Now compare that with raising a kid. If HE don't like the food and gets too thin, YOU may end in prison for kid neglecting. So you better cook nice food to your kids. Still think it's easier than a dog?
- mjackson 14y ago> We've always had two or three dogs at a time, and they've had our love, attention, and affection. They're spoiled rotten. Better dogs than children. One very common trait among people I know who don't have kids is that they have dogs. For them, dogs help to fill the need they have for unconditional love and the seemingly built-in paternal/maternal need to care for someone. That's great. Nothing wrong with that. I've had lots of dogs in my life. In my experience, the dogs were fun. We played and wrestled and went on walks and went to the park. I was sad when they passed away. I also have three children. I can honestly say that I never experienced anything close to the feelings I have for my children with the dogs. My children look like me, and like the woman I love. They think deep thoughts and ask questions and figure things out. Instead of teaching them to sit or rollover (though you have to start somewhere!) I teach them to reason and understand. I try to teach them as best I can to be a good person. That's a process that has inspired deep introspection and personal growth, as well as some of the best work I've done in my career and my community. Owning a dog is certainly easier than having a child, by which I mean it's a lot less work. So if easy is your metric for better you could probably say something like "Better dogs than children." But using every other metric that I can think of I would say the opposite.
- zargon 14y agoContext. The author said it's better that they spoiled their dogs rotten than spoiled kids rotten. She's not saying that dogs are better than children.
- wellpast 14y agoI think the two voices here are interesting. The first account is very much a personal account (here's my story), the second comes across as much more prescriptive and didactic (you should have kids). The first person seems content with her choices, these ons comes across as frustrated and unhappy. I found this fascinating and took from it no lesson about whether or not to have children--only that, here, happiness/contentment accompanies humble self-awareness, frustration with the idea that your life should serve as some kind of black & white prescription for the world.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- johngalt 14y agoAm I the only parent who was surprised how easy raising kids is? All I've heard was how much of a sacrifice and struggle raising kids is. My experience is the complete opposite. You make larger portions of the same meals, run a full washing machine every day instead of a half full one. Play chutes and ladders instead of settlers of catan. Are there constraints on your life that didn't exist before? Yes, but nothing intolerable if you don't obsess about it. The hard part for a lot of parents is the number of things you 'should do to be a better parent', stretches out into the infinite. No matter what good they do, all they see is an endless list of ways in which they've failed. Keep yourself out of that mental trap and parenting is a piece of cake.
- blazingfrog2 14y agoWhile staying clear of that mental trap is key (so easy to forget, at least here in the US), I also think that for it to feel easy, some people have to make a conscious effort to make it easy. If you're anything like me, any intellectually-gratifying side project I get started on will slowly consume me if I'm not careful. By that, I mean that it's what I'll think about when I get up, before I go to sleep and, yes, during all my free time. I can't do the one hour a day thing. It's simply impossible to balance that state of mind with young children, at least the first few years, because it's not so much that they'd resent you if you chose to spend your free time on that side project instead of them (although if they're old enough, they will), it's that they physically need you for reassurance, feeding, diaper-changing, etc... That's a lesson I learned the hard way, especially after my second child. A real danger for people like me is that you could end up resenting your own kid for depriving you of that intellectual gratification you crave. No matter how much fun little kids are (say < 4), they cannot satisfy that craving.
- jaequery 14y agohave a 3 and a 5 year old. coincidentally, they came into my life when i was starting my own startup and i'd have to say it wasn't easy but doable. the time i get to work on my projects are limited for sure but the time you get to spend with your kids trumps any other activities. i can honestly say that you haven't found happiness until you've got kids. just my two cents.
- zeidrich 14y agoI find the first author's comment a bit funny. Not because of her decision to not have children, but because of the reasons. - Diapers, Soccer Games, Braces, Tantrums. - Those are pretty poor reasons to me. A good reason to me is "I am fulfilled doing what I do and have no reason to want children" or even "I have never wanted to have kids" But the way she writes, it sounds like she actually really wanted children, but was afraid that they would tie her down too much, ruin her life, and make her do icky things like change diapers, and make her feel uncomfortable when they threw tantrums. Her response to getting her tubes tied was "Freedom." as though there was this specter of child-rearing that she was so afraid of. Her followup states that she is afraid she would have been a bad mother anyways so it was probably for the best. As someone else said, the decision should be to have kids, not deciding to not have kids. But the first author sounds more like she wanted kids but was afraid, regrets the decision and is spending her time trying to justify, to herself, that decision to get her tubes tied back at 30 now that she is getting to the point of no return. Second author would have sounded a lot better if he had written it in the first person instead of second person. He's describing his experience, not mine. It's pretty presumptuous to tell me how I feel, or will feel.
- lucisferre 14y agoSo Q and A mined from Quora qualifies for Slate now? Oh well. Kids or no kids are definitely a YMMV issue. I have a 18mo old daughter who I love dearly and is "the light of my life" yawn. But I'm also aware enough to know the tradeoffs of children and belive that it is just as equally possible to be wonderfully happy without them as it is to be miserable with them. Please. Children != happiness. In fact I believe this has been studied at length, but I can't recall the source now. That said, sharing your life with a child or two can be highly rewarding.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoThe thing is, having children is a transformative experience. I don't think you can compare the two states of existence in the way the question assumes. I call kids a "terrible blessing". There's so much downside, yet on the whole its not something you regret, once you make the transition. All generalizations are false, yet biologically we are made to sexually reproduce. Therefore reproduction and the creation of replacements is a natural part of life for most of us. I don't think you can make value judgments about whether one situation is better or worse than another. It doesn't work that way. Having said that, I am reminded of something my adoptive mother told me before she died. Having spent a couple of decades in a very active community of older people, she found the ones without children the saddest. "They don't have anybody," she'd say sadly. Yes, they might have had a great life where they accomplished much and did all they wanted to do, they might even have a Rolodex full of friends, but at the end, there was nobody left for them. There were no replacements or people to carry on their memory long after they were gone. There was a deep loneliness and an empty spot as they socialized with others and enjoyed their last days. This was something others could notice. This was something most of them admitted to feeling. Take that for what it's worth --- probably not a lot. For me, this is one of those things that looks dramatically different at age 47 than it did at age 17.
- zargon 14y agoHaving kids doesn't protect one from loneliness in old age. Adult children are independent and choose their own social circles.
- Evbn 14y agoDaniel was real hinting at the evo bio genetic imperative, and how facing end of life not having kids makes you admit the death of your genetic line. I suspect that elders with nieces and nephews would feel something in between the other two cases.
- lotharbot 14y agoI'm reminded of a favorite comic strip: http://www.sheldoncomics.com/archive/090614.html http://www.sheldoncomics.com/archive/090614.html
- bitwize 14y agoPretty freakin' cool. One thing the world doesn't need more of is Westerners living Western lifestyles. In addition to the freedom to focus on your life (if, like me, you are too selfish to give your life away for the sake of a child then you're better off not having a child), your conscience is soothed by the fact that you're sparing the world additional Westerners.
- corporalagumbo 14y agoI think when you have kids, you accept that you are no longer fully in control of your life; you are forced to let go and accept your humanity. This is quite a healthy thing to do, among other things that sense of control was mostly illusory anyway. People who don't do this and keep trying to swim against the current of life end up pretty strange and warped I think.
- pekk 14y agoYou seriously think people who don't want to have kids are inhuman, strange and warped?
- corporalagumbo 14y ago"Inhuman" connotes differently from what I was trying to express. As for the other two, perhaps I should specify: I believe that this is true specifically for people who openly proclaim childlessness as their free choice, who defend it as a superior option, and who counter-attack and try to de-normalise having kids. People in other words who flaunt childlessness and try to pretend that having kids is not really an important issue. All of the people I have met who act in this manner have been strange, warped people. One lady told me she couldn't stand the idea of an "alien parasite growing inside of her." Others I have met scream about the horrors of childbirth, or the disgusting, pathetic and needy nature of babies. None of them seemed to have enough love in their hearts to care selflessly and unquestioningly for another human being, and all seemed to be gripped by pretty nasty self-loathing fears of their own humanity/mortality. On the other hand, I am sure there are many people who for whatever reason miss on out on having kids or choose not to for decent reasons, but maintain good perspective about their decision/fate, and feel a measure of quiet regret and curiosity about the road not taken, which helps keeps them soft and human.
- SteveJS 14y agoMy wife and I never wanted children. Neither of us needed to convince the other. We did agree that, if either of us did change our mind, adopting would be the right path. I don't get the idea that you need to hate kids to decide that having your own is something you don't wish to do.
- mzarate06 14y agoI wasn't "made" to be a mother. I had spared a child from having to have me as one. I believe some people are born with DNA that enables them to be great athletes, scholars, parents, etc. I always tell my friends and family that it's not in my DNA to have kids. I honestly don't know the exact science behind DNA to know if my statement holds true or not, but figuratively speaking it delivers the point that I believe I lack the traits to be a good parent, including the motivation to become one.
- hudell 14y agoI'm still 24 and I have no intention of ever having a kid, but one year ago, I thought I would never want a girlfriend again either. I still don't want a girlfriend, but my best friends started some really serious relationship and they can't be with me all the time anymore, so I had to start thinking about dating again. Maybe some day something will happen and I will need to think about having children too.