2 ms·
Maybe accumulate per-year wealth tax liability against illiquid assets which is paid at sale (with some additional interest rate?).
by rdl 14y ago
Maybe accumulate per-year wealth tax liability against illiquid assets which is paid at sale (with some additional interest rate?).
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThen you're back to the same problem with a high capital gains rate, once the tax burden exceeds a certain threshold the asset becomes unsellable because the value of holding it so greatly exceeds the value of selling it less the tax to be paid. And then people don't sell and you don't get the tax revenue, but you get the economic distortion. The way you fix the distortion is by accounting for it. If someone sells an investment asset and then uses the money to purchase another investment asset, allow them to roll over the basis into the new asset. Then there is no distortion because you can trade investment assets for one another with no change in tax liability or tax realization. Which is actually kind of cool now that I'm thinking about it, because it's kind of like a consumption tax that only applies to investment income -- the money gets taxed when they spend it on something that isn't an investment, but poor people whose money doesn't come from investment sources don't pay the tax. Which means you can have a substantial tax rate without a lot of distortion -- or at least, the distortion would be to encourage the rich to invest rather than spend. But if we like investing then maybe that's OK.
- rdl 14y agoOn your epicycle to correct the accumulated burden: That's essentially how tax-deferred retirement accounts work, right? (or other structures, like an investment company or REIT) It would be interesting to let people set up these more easily for individual purposes. There would be some corner cases like a non-rental property (do you tax the OER instead of the full amount?) All of this starts to get really complex. I wonder how much of the capital gains vs. income tax issues go away if the rate of each is the same and very low (<10%). At some point, transaction costs would start to dominate. The other solution would be lower taxes and higher inheritance taxes (even up to 100%). If there weren't family businesses as ongoing concerns, and all assets were financial, I think there would be a pretty reasonable argument for lower income and gains taxes and higher inheritance taxes.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>That's essentially how tax-deferred retirement accounts work, right? (or other structures, like an investment company or REIT) Sometimes, sure. The trouble is that not everyone can use those structures. A corporation can't use an individual retirement account, but it will still make investment choices and "pay" (i.e. make every cost effective but economically damaging contortion necessary to avoid) income and capital gains tax. Likewise someone investing money they anticipate needing before the official retirement age for any reason. And I think most structures of that nature have caps on the amount of tax you can defer using them. Making it the rule rather than the exception would reduce the distortionary effects substantially, and would simply things a whole lot too. >All of this starts to get really complex. I wonder how much of the capital gains vs. income tax issues go away if the rate of each is the same and very low (<10%). At some point, transaction costs would start to dominate. It's questionable whether that would raise enough revenue to cover existing expenditures, so then you've got to figure out what to cut. It seems to me the simple thing to do is to make the purchase of an investment tax deductible and then make the full amount of its sale taxable as income. Then if you sell an investment and buy another one in the same amount, the deduction cancels the income. If you sell an investment and use the money to buy a smaller investment and a non-investment purchase, the cost of the latter isn't deductible and becomes taxable as income. Then the only question is how to define what an investment is. Which is by no means trivial, but we already have a good framework in place in the form of deciding what purchases are eligible for existing deductions like business operating costs vs. personal consumption in partnerships and LLCs. >If there weren't family businesses as ongoing concerns, and all assets were financial, I think there would be a pretty reasonable argument for lower income and gains taxes and higher inheritance taxes. You can't have an inheritance tax rate higher than the personal income rate or people will just hire their heirs to be the Vice President of Collecting a Huge Paycheck and arrange to have no assets left when they die. That's why they call it the Death Tax: It only applies to people who die unexpectedly. Anyone old or sick enough to expect death within the next few years and with enough assets to hire a financial planner has already arranged to avoid it.