3 ms·
The reality with releases like this is that I'm 90% sure most Google bigwigs have never heard of it, and it's misleading to label it as "Google's" in the title.
by Mond_ 2mo ago
The reality with releases like this is that I'm 90% sure most Google bigwigs have never heard of it, and it's misleading to label it as "Google's" in the title.
Yes, it was developed by Google employees, that does not imply it has the full backing of Google, or Deepmind, or GCP. Notably, the website doesn't seem to claim this either.
- foota 2mo agoThis /looks/ at least more official. Most unofficial Google projects have a disclaimer in the repo.
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- Stagnant 2mo agoIt is on Google's github https://github.com/google/ax https://github.com/google/ax and the title comes from there.
- yla92 2mo agoWhile this one seems like an official Google project, some other projects are not, even if it is on github.com/google A random example E.g https://github.com/google/filament#disclaimer https://github.com/google/filament#disclaimer This is not an officially supported Google product.
- welhoilija 2mo agoDoes Filament claim that it's Google's in the repo description? It's a valid title.
- Mond_ 2mo agoFair enough, I missed that specific line. The point still stands that I wouldn't expect this to have GDM leadership backing. (If you're planning to use this at all, that matters for how much faith you should have in the product.)
- ShinyLeftPad 2mo agoit's built on top of https://github.com/agent-substrate/substrate https://github.com/agent-substrate/substrate which is not on Google github.
- jcw90210 2mo agoAgent Substrate is being moved to CNCF: https://github.com/cncf/sandbox/issues/523 https://github.com/cncf/sandbox/issues/523
- varun_ch 2mo agothe repo description https://github.com/google/ax https://github.com/google/ax is "Google's open agentic orchestrator"
- verdverm 2mo agofor comparison/contrast, another very related Google project (one employee) on one of their github orgs that comes with the following disclaimer > This is not an officially supported Google product. This project is not eligible for the Google Open Source Software Vulnerability Rewards Program. https://github.com/GoogleCloudPlatform/scion https://github.com/GoogleCloudPlatform/scion
- mpeg 2mo agoThe project that ax builds on top of does have that disclaimer, and sits on a non-google organisation https://github.com/agent-substrate/substrate https://github.com/agent-substrate/substrate
- ahmedtd 2mo agoSubstrate is in the process of being donated to the CNCF as a vendor-neutral common ground (similar to K8s). (The agent-substrate org is currently Google's, but that will change).
- mynegation 2mo agoI have no insider knowledge but https://x.com/rakyll https://x.com/rakyll is working on it and she is tweeting about it and I got the impression there is a quite a team behind it. It looks like an effort in GCP.
- Mond_ 2mo agoYes, and one thing to understand about Google is that no AI framework or tool is guaranteed to survive unless it has the explicit backing of Google Deepmind. "Effort in GCP" is a red flag. (See Gemini CLI, which was shut down in favor of Antigravity CLI.)
- panarky 2mo agoAntigravity CLI is far, far superior to Gemini CLI. Plant many flowers, keep the ones that bloom and stop watering the ones that don't.
- Mond_ 2mo agoI agree on both accounts fwiw.
- ychnd 2mo agoIt is not, it is intentionally not-interoperable walled garden, unlike Gemini CLI.
- fg137 2mo agoIs it superior in terms of license? And anyone who bothers to just do a side-by-side feature comparison can immediately see how many features antigravity is still missing compared to Gemini CLI even today.
- esseph 2mo ago>The reality with releases like this is that I'm 90% sure most Google bigwigs have never heard of it Google has around 200,000 employees. They probably haven't heard of most things Google releases.
- dudus 2mo agoIt's got a formal announcement on the blog. 4 months ago. https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/agent-executor-googles-distributed-agent-runtime https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/a...
- fg137 2mo agoYeah, anyone should think of this as an experimental side project that may be forgotten in 15min and make careful decisions about using them in production environments. We have used a few of Google's (smaller) open source projects, and in the last 2-3 years most of them are getting fewer updates if any updates at all. Some became very bad tech debt and we had to spend a lot of time migrating them. Of course, that is the nature of open source projects (written in the license terms), and there is nothing to complain. But it's important to point out these days Google's open source project are not any more trustworthy than a one man's project in terms of support and maintainability. Personally I would stay away from them as far as possible. Especially if you look at what happened to Android, Gemini CLI etc. (To be honest, even if it were officially supported by Google, that barely means anything. https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/)
- Havoc 2mo agoYeah especially with their tendency to depreciate stuff they’ve grown tired of