4 ms·
"A dollar given to a poor man multiplies faster, Keynes observed, than a dollar given to a rich man." This may be conventional wisdom, but it doesn't make sens
by pdonis 14y ago
"A dollar given to a poor man multiplies faster, Keynes observed, than a dollar given to a rich man."
This may be conventional wisdom, but it doesn't make sense to me. It seems to me that how much economic growth is caused by spending dollars depends on what they're spent on, not who is spending them.
Growth caused by dollars spent on consumption is linear: the "size of the economy" is just the total number of dollars spent. If people are buying more stuff, the economy is larger; but that's all.
Growth caused by dollars spent on investment and innovation is exponential: it increases the amount of stuff that can be had for a given number of dollars, or even adds new stuff that previously could not be obtained at any price.
I think most dollars spent by both poor people and rich people are spent on consumption, not investment. So it seems to me that finding ways to get more dollars to be spent on investment rather than consumption is the best way to increase economic growth.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> This may be conventional wisdom, but it doesn't make sense to me. It seems to me that... Uh huh. Please help me out with some links as to why Keynes was wrong on this. He may be, but "seems" doesn't suggest that you have made much of a study of it. I haven't gone much further in my studies, perhaps you could help me here? > economic growth is caused by spending dollars depends on what they're spent on, not who is spending Half correct. The argument is that an extra dollar in the hands of a poor person is much more likely to be spent sooner on some basic good like food, and to another relatively poor person who will do likewise. i.e. with higher velocity of money. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_of_money http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_of_money The article mentions this. You know about velocity of money, right? > I think most dollars spent by both poor people and rich people are spent on consumption, not investment ORLY? Most arguments that I have read on it claim that most dollars spent by rich people are spent on investment. i.e. Rich people can save and invest, poor people can't. Saving and investment is slow velocity money storage. In short, since money given to poor people will probably be spent a few times over before it ends up in some corporation's coffers, why would "helicopter money" http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/jan/26/economy-uk-high-street http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/jan/26/economy-... be worse than the current policy of printing money and giving it to banks who don't want to lend it out to any investment? > Growth caused by dollars spent on investment and innovation is exponential. So it seems to me that finding ways to get more dollars to be spent on investment rather than consumption is the best way to increase economic growth. please supply a link to an article about how "exponential innovation" is more important than monetary velocity. It may be, but not because it "seems" to someone. Right now, that's just gibberish to me.
- pdonis 14y agoYou know about velocity of money, right? Yes, and the most common definition of "the size of the economy" is GDP, which is, as I understand it, linearly related to the velocity of money. That's another way of saying what I was saying, that economic growth due to spending on consumption is linear. Most arguments that I have read on it claim that most dollars spent by rich people are spent on investment I'm not sure that's quite what they claim. They certainly claim that rich people spend more on investment than poor people, and as you point out, that makes sense because they can afford to and poor people can't. But that's not the same as saying that most of what rich people spend is spent on investment. Spending on expensive houses, cars, private jets, yachts, traveling around the world, personal assistants, etc., etc., is all consumption, not investment. As far as I can tell, that's what most of rich people's spending is. The ones that make the news, like Bill Gates or Warren Buffett, seem to me to be the exceptions. But I would love to see hard data if there is any. why would "helicopter money" be worse than the current policy of printing money and giving it to banks who don't want to lend it out to any investment? I agree that "helicopter money" wouldn't be any worse than giving money to banks that don't lend it out; in fact, economically speaking, "helicopter money" might actually be better, since the money would actually get spent. However, both of them are short-term solutions, like giving a nitroglycerine pill to someone having a heart attack. Neither of them fix any underlying chronic problems. please supply a link to an article about how "exponential" innovation is more important than monetary velocity I haven't seen my statement about growth due to spending on investment being exponential phrased in exactly that way, but investment being equivalent to compound interest, which grows exponentially, is a commonplace among economists. As for "velocity of money", try this article by Henry Hazlitt: http://mises.org/daily/2916 http://mises.org/daily/2916 Two key points, from the summary at the end of the article: "Velocity of circulation is a result, not a cause. It is commonly a passive resultant of changes in people's relative valuations of money and goods." "V is never an independent factor on the side of money, because the transfer of goods must speed up, other things being equal, to an equal amount. It is just as valid to think of the velocity of circulation of money being caused by what happens on the side of goods as by what happens on the side of money." In other words, trying to "help the economy" by trying to speed up the velocity of money is getting things backwards.
- lolcraft 14y ago> I think most dollars spent by both poor people and rich people are spent on consumption, not investment. Not at all. Poor people expend on consumption. Rich people spend far more on investment and savings. Yeah, Paul Allen might have a 10G$ superyacht, but he's worth 14.8T$, the majority in securities, bonds and so on, I presume. > Growth caused by dollars spent on consumption is linear [...] Growth caused by dollars spent on investment and innovation is exponential [...] Well, you implicitly assume there that this investment would mean that demand would increase. That is, you assume Say's Law holds true. But you are not being fair here. Symmetry in your argument would require that growth by demand should also be "exponential", as any increase in demand would the same effect in investment that any increase in investment has in demand. So both would be positive-feedback loops, to the exact same degree. Say's Law says it is. Second, this is the classical economic framework, which doesn't work. You need to factor in savings and debt, and then Say's Law breaks; demand doesn't equal investment anymore, and you need a Keynesian, IS-LM framework. Now, what I understand is that, while a failure of aggregate demand is a positive-feedback loop ( less demand -> less investment -> less income -> less demand ... ), the mechanism of debt makes a failure of aggregate investment be nothing at all: less investment -> more debt -> more investment -> more income -> more demand -> more investment ... Well, actually you have debt now, which can be easily be a problem. But my cursory, layman's understanding is that it's a much less severe problem, since d(GDP)/dt > 0 now.
- pdonis 14y agoYeah, Paul Allen might have a 10G$ superyacht, but he's worth 14.8T$, the majority in securities, bonds and so on, I presume. I assume you mean 10M$ (million, 10^6) and 14.8B$ (billion, 10^9)? I doubt that Paul Allen is worth the entire US GDP. :-) As for what his wealth is doing, say the majority of it is invested in securities, bonds, etc. How much actual investment is being done with that? "Investment" in the economic sense doesn't mean owning shares of stock, or bonds; it means applying resources to the creation of new forms of wealth, instead of to the consumption of existing forms of wealth. How efficiently is Paul Allen's money being used for that purpose? Since we're talking about Paul Allen, it may actually be used fairly well, but as I said before, he's an exception. I think most rich people do not really care how their money is being used, and don't spend much time or effort trying to use it efficiently. Why would they? Most of them are not entrepreneurs or investors; they're just people who happen to have a pile of money. you assume Say's Law holds true Even if I agree that it's true for the sake of argument (see below for further comment on that), it doesn't justify this claim: Symmetry in your argument would require that growth by demand should also be "exponential" No, because growth by demand is limited by supply. There was no demand for air travel in 1900, not because people could not have used it, but because it didn't exist. Once it existed, it created a whole new category of demand. To some extent that demand displaced other demand (some people now made trips by air that they would previously have made by car or train), but most of that demand was new demand that increased the total GDP. But that growth was only made possible by the existence of a new source of supply. New sources of supply are only created by investment, not consumption; that's the difference. Second, this is the classical economic framework, which doesn't work. Only according to all the non-classical economists whose jobs depend on saying that it doesn't work. You need to factor in savings and debt, and then Say's Law breaks In the short run, yes. But what is the savings and debt for? All these things do, in effect, is transfer resources through time: by saving now I put aside resources for later use; by taking on debt now I expend resources that I don't currently have, and pay for it later with excess resources. None of this changes the fact that ultimately, whatever is consumed must be produced. Well, actually you have debt now, which can be easily be a problem. But my cursory, layman's understanding is that it's a much less severe problem, since d(GDP)/dt > 0 now. Yes, it is, but why? As I said above, debt means you're using up resources now that you don't have (you borrow them from someone else) with the expectation that you will have excess resources in the future to pay it back. Where will the excess resources in the future come from? The best outcome is that you have used the debt to fund investments that create new sources of supply, so you have a lot more wealth in the future and can easily afford to pay back the debt. Another possible outcome is that you keep on increasing your tax base (this is the Krugman solution, referred to by someone else in another post in this thread), so that when the debt comes due you have a lot more people available to tax to pay it back. The third possible outcome is that you inflate the debt away, by denominating it in your own currency instead of in actual goods. This is how the US government has historically dealt with its debt; US debt is denominated in dollars, and the US can print as many dollars as it likes, so effectively it can make its own debt as small as it likes by making dollars worth less. For example, in the Krugman article, he mentions the US debt from World War II, and says that we never paid it back; it just grew increasingly irrelevant as the tax base grew. In other words, he says it was the second outcome. But he fails to mention that the US dollar has inflated by almost 1200 percent since World War II, i.e., by a factor of 12, whereas the tax base has grown by at most a factor of 3. So the third outcome has by far the largest effect.
- ap22213 14y agoFrom what I understood from sophomore economics, 1,000 transactions of $1,000 has potential to stimulate more economic growth than 1 transaction of $1,000,000. And, if we think about it, it seems pretty straightforward as to why.
- pdonis 14y agoI think the correct answer to this is "it depends". It depends on what the transactions are for.