2 ms·
None of your arguments hold any water if big-corpo AI restricts open-weight models - which they very clearly want to do. AI is NOT “the best thing that ever hap
by r053bud 2mo ago
None of your arguments hold any water if big-corpo AI restricts open-weight models - which they very clearly want to do. AI is NOT “the best thing that ever happened to the Free Software world” if our only option is to pay a select few companies to use it.
- SuperV1234 2mo agoWe have open-source models, and they're getting better and better.
- smitty1e 2mo agoBut, rather that a wide Edenic expanse of communication, we seem headed toward walled gardens with gatekeepers and a need to pay money for all the usual reasons. This seems both inevitable, and an occasion to tout the https://www.fsf.org https://www.fsf.org
- jasonvorhe 2mo agoEh? Where exactly is that a reality though? I just spent like 20$ last week on various Chinese frontier models using openrouter and ppq building like 10 different projects that would've cost way more than double or quadruple per token at the big 3 if I didn't have those alternative options. Hell, for small tasks I even fell back to a local 27b Qwen model.
- hackmetothemoon 2mo ago[dead]
- nycdotnet 2mo agofor now.
- TeMPOraL 2mo agoThey will literally never get worse. It's a one-way street.
- nycdotnet 2mo agoI agree. The question is if they will remain legal.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 2mo agoThe law doesn't prevent someone from doing or using something. It punishes them for doing or using something (if caught), but never prevents. If laws had the power to prevent, Chicago would be some sort of utopia.
- wpietri 2mo agoChicago is pretty great, bub. This year I opened a pinball museum here, so I can testify that it's a fine place to run a business. Some friends just came from the Bay Area for a week and had a lovely time. If only for your mental health, you should step out of your media bubble now and again
- janice1999 2mo ago... if you can afford the ever increasing cost of hardware, a rise directly caused by the same AI companies.
- Marha01 2mo agoI don't think it will be ever-increasing. It might last a long time, but sooner or later supply will increase to meet the demand (or the demand will drop, or both) and hardware will be cheap again.
- roenxi 2mo agoThose arguments are independent of the state of OSS models. There appears to be no moat whatsoever on creating state of the art models commercially - the US threw the kitchen sink at China in terms of sanctions and barriers ... yet it has been unable to keep Chinese companies away from the frontier (arguably ahead in small local models with Qwen). Even if all the models were proprietary we'd expect the costs and capabilities to be widely available. The Europeans might even be able to field their own advanced models eventually. OSS models are strategically important, but that is a different matter to getting value out of them for OSS software development.
- shevy-java 2mo agoIMO, AI will have the same problems no matter which area or country uses it to dominate over others.
- amlib 2mo agoConsumers are way too fickle to pursue open models en masse. Even if they are 90% as good and fairly easy to use (works acceptably on most machines, easy installation, whatever), they will still go for the ones controlled by big corportions/big tech. Look at how consumers deal with free, open source software, alternate Operating Systems, alternate social networks, alternate search engines, alternate chat protocols... even when the barriers are low they just don't give a damn. I honestly think most people would choose to join the Borg out of sheer convenience. It's futile to think this won't happen with AI.
- leoc 2mo agoIt also seems pretty reasonable to worry that Oracle isn't banning LLM code contributions to OpenJDK https://www.theregister.com/ai-and-ml/2026/08/03/as-larry-ellison-bets-the-farm-oracle-says-it-loves-ai-written-code-just-not-in-openjdk/5281851 https://www.theregister.com/ai-and-ml/2026/08/03/as-larry-el... ( HN discussion at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49213754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49213754 ) purely on quality grounds. If things carry on as at present, and it turns out that indeed it really was legally safe to copy and paste almost any code that came out of an LLM, then that's one thing; but if instead there's a rash of code copyright (and indeed patent) lawsuits a few years from now then the big and middling companies will simply pay each other settlements, while FOSS projects and their small-fry users will likely be in a much worse situation.
- TeMPOraL 2mo agoBig corporations can't do shit about open-weight models that already exist, because those are... just bags of floats. Once released, there is no unreleasing them. The Internet never forgets. Download the files as they come out if you're worried, but there's no way to roll LLMs back beyond what we have in open-weight models right now. It's a ratchet.
- LogicFailsMe 2mo agoBig entertainment has been trying to restrict the distribution of movies online since that became possible, how's that going for them?
- wpietri 2mo agoPretty well, honestly. Somebody with both technical knowledge and familiarity with a particular subculture can get access to entertainment videos with some work. But they've managed to keep piracy economically negligible. Basically everybody uses streaming services, 90% of US households pay for at least 1, and the average household pays for 4. [1] Brand was wrong. Information doesn't want to be free, just cheap. [1] https://variety.com/2026/tv/news/how-much-us-households-spend-streaming-video-deloitte-study-1236694151/ https://variety.com/2026/tv/news/how-much-us-households-spen...
- Marha01 2mo agoThis is only the case because streaming services today are so cheap and convenient. Jack up the price, or decrease the convenience, and see people sail the high seas en masse again..
- LogicFailsMe 2mo agoIndeed, the origin stories of these streaming services are deeply intertwined with combating piracy if you go back 20+ years. And I agree, if they outlaw open weight models, then only outlaws will have open weight models. But good luck finding and prosecuting the outlaws beyond a few whales.
- 998244353 2mo agoYou can watch a lot of TV series online on some random pirate sites by simply googling "show x free online". It doesn't even require the relatively simple technical knowledge of using a BitTorrent client.
- mitxela 2mo agoQuite well. Lots of people in jail and it's quite obscure how to download movies as a casual.
- iloveoof 2mo agoThat’s like saying private libraries are bad for freedom to read, or Blockbuster was bad for freedom to view movies