3 ms·
On #3, I thought the general consensus among economists was for capital gains as having a substantial embodied inflation component. Thus, making a $100k invest
by rdl 14y ago
On #3, I thought the general consensus among economists was for capital gains as having a substantial embodied inflation component. Thus, making a $100k investment now, waiting 20 years, and selling it for $150k isn't really a gain at all under most historical inflation rates, and thus taxing the $50k as current income at the end is kind of unfair, and worse, would deter some capital investment (at least, would shift from long term to short term).
The argument for favorable taxation of dividends is less direct -- that they're roughly equivalent to capital gains returned through repurchase or retained as cash, and that there's an efficiency argument for returning that money to shareholders. If dividends are taxed higher than capital gains, there's a strong tax incentive to do stock buybacks or retain earnings instead.
- justincormack 14y agoMany countries discount capital gains by inflation but then tax as income (eg the UK).
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThat's one of the reasons, but I never thought it was the strongest one (though it may be the most mentioned). The real trouble is that it makes certain assets de facto inalienable. Suppose you've bought at $100k and your asset is now worth $150k. If you hold it, your expectation is to make $75k (a 50% increase) over the next holding period (say 20 years). By contrast, there is an alternative investment that will provide a 55% increase over the same period, which it would be economically efficient for you to take advantage of. But not under a 35% capital gains tax. Because then instead of collecting returns on $150k, you're suddenly collecting returns on only $132.5k (= $150k - ($50k x .35)), and the 55% return is no longer better for you than the existing 50% return, even though it's better for the economy at large. The effect is most problematic for small business owners, because they typically have near-zero basis in their holdings. They "bought" the stock when the company started for around $0 and now it's worth a million dollars, so the gain is the entire amount. If they sell they instantly lose 35% of their investment capital, so they don't sell, ever, because no alternative investment is worth that kind of a hit. And then on top of that, because of this, the government never sees the tax revenue, because the disincentive to sell is too large to ever be met -- so 35% of nothing ends up smaller than 15% of something.
- rdl 14y agoThat's a good argument. Would a wealth tax be less economically distorting than a capital gains tax, at least with respect to encouraging people to exchange assets in an economically efficient way?
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>Would a wealth tax be less economically distorting than a capital gains tax, at least with respect to encouraging people to exchange assets in an economically efficient way? Sure, but then you've got a different problem. What happens to illiquid assets? If the value of the illiquid assets your business uses in its operations goes up (land, trademark goodwill, whatever) then you would immediately owe wealth tax on the appreciation, but if the business is only just breaking even as an operation, now you've got to shut down the business and sell the assets to cover the tax owed. And then of course if you exempt illiquid assets you get a whole new kind of distortion where everybody puts their money in whatever assets are exempt. What you could do is have an asset tax with brackets, e.g. no tax on the first five million dollars of assets and then X percent on everything over that. And then presumably anyone subject to the tax would have so much wealth that selling some would not be a hardship. But it's still not perfect, because you would immediately see families dispersing their assets between everyone they can trust to keep any single individual's total below the threshold.
- rdl 14y agoMaybe accumulate per-year wealth tax liability against illiquid assets which is paid at sale (with some additional interest rate?).
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThen you're back to the same problem with a high capital gains rate, once the tax burden exceeds a certain threshold the asset becomes unsellable because the value of holding it so greatly exceeds the value of selling it less the tax to be paid. And then people don't sell and you don't get the tax revenue, but you get the economic distortion. The way you fix the distortion is by accounting for it. If someone sells an investment asset and then uses the money to purchase another investment asset, allow them to roll over the basis into the new asset. Then there is no distortion because you can trade investment assets for one another with no change in tax liability or tax realization. Which is actually kind of cool now that I'm thinking about it, because it's kind of like a consumption tax that only applies to investment income -- the money gets taxed when they spend it on something that isn't an investment, but poor people whose money doesn't come from investment sources don't pay the tax. Which means you can have a substantial tax rate without a lot of distortion -- or at least, the distortion would be to encourage the rich to invest rather than spend. But if we like investing then maybe that's OK.