2 ms·
That much is obvious and everyone learns it like on the first week of English learning, of course. It’s the various cases where that simple rule doesn’t apply t
by Sharlin 14d ago
That much is obvious and everyone learns it like on the first week of English learning, of course. It’s the various cases where that simple rule doesn’t apply that are difficult.
"I play the piano"
And then there are those cases where you actually use neither!
- necovek 14d agoAnd "There is a piano in the lobby."
- Nemi 13d agoI see this as consistent. When you say "I play the piano" you are really saying, "There are many instruments – banjo, trumpet, clarinet, and piano. I play the piano". Saying "I play a piano" is also correct. But the inference is that you are referring to one particular piano. In the sentence "There is a piano in the lobby" you are saying "There are many objects in the lobby. Among them is a piano, one of many in the world".
- necovek 13d agoBut it's still where the generic, simplistic application of the rule of "the for distinct, a for generic" fails. When "you can play the piano", you can play any piano. When "there is a piano in the lobby", it's distinctively a very specific one. So I would go on a limb and claim: whether you use the or a is also philosophical in nature :)