5 ms·
I can understand why the author feels bitter but it still feels juvenile to me. Certainly both Jev and Laya are based on the research of countless prior papers
by dcow 2mo ago
I can understand why the author feels bitter but it still feels juvenile to me. Certainly both Jev and Laya are based on the research of countless prior papers and academics. Diogo decided to build a product out of the concept. The author didn't. Publishing research papers and model weights is probably part of the problem--it feels academic. If you look at the author's profile they focus on applying AI to healthcare. Not selling general AI type safety to AI pilled companies and devs. There's a big difference there. Whether that's good or bad you can argue all day. But for the author to expect otherwise is pretty weird. I do applaud them for not stewing too much on it and trying to do something about it, though.
- operaopera 2mo agoI believe his qualms were with the "hype" in Jev's announcement: specifically calling this kind of model a breakthrough, without crediting previous art, and keeping everything closed source.
- prodigycorp 2mo agoAnd how is laya previous art? The project was vibecoded and posted yesterday. https://github.com/NandhaKishorM/laya/commits/main/ https://github.com/NandhaKishorM/laya/commits/main/ https://huggingface.co/convaiinnovations/laya/commits/main https://huggingface.co/convaiinnovations/laya/commits/main
- nandakishor_ml 2mo agoThe paper is one year old. https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.01237 https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.01237 https://pypi.org/project/hallunox/ https://pypi.org/project/hallunox/
- prodigycorp 2mo agoExcuse me, but calibrating language models to accurately reflect probabilities did not start with you.
- nandakishor_ml 2mo agoI didn't claimed it bro it was first. Just shared the findings here.
- prodigycorp 2mo ago[flagged]
- nandakishor_ml 2mo agojust not these jev guys not opensourcing their work
- verdverm 2mo agoYou used a number of not open source projects in your paper, are you equally upset with them for this reason?
- dcow 2mo ago[flagged]
- jeremyjh 2mo agoGenerally they do credit the papers and/or people who developed the theory behind their product.
- charcircuit 2mo agoResearchers definitely do get paid for research. That Google company you mention funds research which can be integrated into their products.
- Matticus_Rex 2mo agoSure, researchers get paid when they either do the research under contract or productize the research and sell it themselves. But they don't usually do the latter because that's quite difficult.
- verdverm 2mo agoAre you grouping academic research funded by grants under the contract category? To me, there is a meaningful difference and I'd add a third category, but I can also see the contract angle
- potterpie 2mo agoIdeas are cheap. But the ideas are cheap coming from anyone. The reason some ideas (like JEV's) are taking up our attention (as opposed to Laya's) is not because of their execution ability, but because venture funding now is subbing filling in for execution ability. I do understand your argument to this would be - "welcome to the world!" or "that's just how the world works" - but that does not mean we do not recognize the ideas that came well before "venture funding made it happen". I'd like to remind us all that there is a reason Joseph Liouville took the time to painstakingly review Galois’s chaotic manuscripts to credit him. It matters who did what before everyone else - if you do want to say "ideas are cheap" - we'd need to control for other variables before drawing conclusions.
- prometheus1992 2mo ago@prodigycorp - reading your comments here on this post - you seem pretty hurt by this post.
- prodigycorp 2mo agoYeah, the reason why I am annoyed by it is because a person (who felt like a burner account of the laya creator) yesterday was haranguing me for saying that projects like this were vibe coded, posting the link to this project. I evaluated this project yesterday and found its claims un-credible. It's literally nothing like jev. That's some context behind why, a day later, I find it annoying that this is somehow the top story on HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49752902 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49752902
- prometheus1992 2mo agoWhat is jev like? Did they release any research paper? I really think typesafe hired someone to boost their post because there was nothing "Breakthrough" about their product. At least this post has some touch with the reality that this functionality was available a year ago and was well known among ML people.
- prodigycorp 2mo agoI can't believe you say in another post that you have experience with bert and yet you don't understand the value of a generalist classifier. Good models take time and effort. There wasn't a good option for satisficers until a few days ago.
- jessrenoir 2mo agoIt is standard discourse on here if you look backwards. Attention is All You Need sounds like a big nothingburger according to this post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15938082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15938082
- dcow 2mo ago
- threecheese 2mo agoThe hype is kinda nuts; I use X for ML/LLM stuff, and I just can't get away from Jev - even in my Following feed. Even days later 75% of posts are about "how I use typesafe for cooking breakfast!" or Jev clones.
- tcdent 2mo agoSo many different theories on why this is. First, I think comprehensibility is a major part of why certain products grab the interest of the mainstream portions of the market. The 75% of posts in your feed are not from people who evaluate products based on underlying technology. They typically value signal from social reinforcement higher than anything else. This is the same reason why we see people mentioning products instead of technologies, i.e. PlanetScale versus Postgres & Tailscale versus WireGuard. The consumers understand the value proposition, but would have never discovered it without relatable messaging. This isn't a new phenomenon in computer software either; jQuery is probably one of the first examples that I can remember with this sort of texture. The other side is a perception of expertise in a specialty. Software development, especially in AI, has become an incredibly desirable profession, and there are more people than ever racing to be included in it. In my own professional experience I find an excessive amount of entry level talent leveraging the same comprehension of product, but not comprehension of technology to get their foot in the door. A vast majority of the "thought leaders" occupying our feeds are not as well practiced as they claim to be, they're just trying to get a job or raise funding. And finally, AI has brought out a certain amount of desperation in practitioners, for lack of a better term, materializing as an anecdotal, but certainly observable need to remain on the very tip of the news cycle in order to feel well informed. And so, using the dynamics above and many other human social dynamics, we find certain concepts spreading across cohorts that would not normally have a need or a want for these particular techniques, or products, or solutions, but because they feel pressured to remain relevant.
- m3kw9 2mo agoif is closed source, how does he know there isn't some breakthrough he doesn't know?
- jmalicki 2mo agoIf it's closed source, how do you know it's not technology given by aliens from the 43rd dimension running on quantum computers enabled by discovering that P=NP and finding a linear time reduction from NP to P? Occam's razor is that it's probably not all that different unless there is some specific reason to believe otherwise.
- vessenes 2mo agoAgreed. Another difficulty here is there are not good benchmarks for this new architecture yet, so it’s easy to potshot and snipe, where jev seems to be pretty broadly intelligent/at least have had a lot of rl in different domains. We haven’t seen any of these copy cats play doom or street fighter for instance; just categorize email. I imagine once the author cools down and evaluates on a broad harness of tasks he may find that his new thing has a lot of engineering work ahead.
- hirako2000 2mo agoThe doom demo would have to be reproduced to confirm what their model is capable of. Oh but it's all closed source, so who knows. It reminds. Me of Devin. Took a while to debunk. Not saying Jev is a fraud , but the gap between structuring typed output and playing a game involving logical interpretation of frames made of pixels, screams unstructured interpretation they made and forgot to mention.
- derac 2mo agoThey mention in their blog post that the model is working on text rather than pixels in the Doom demo.
- tomsyouruncle 2mo agoI’m not filled with confidence when the author’s first paper takes an RL approach but then doesn’t use it to change the action taken in the next turn. Seems like simple classification would achieve the same end. And this quote from the paper isn’t overly reassuring: “I personally found that this sequential approach captured sales dynamics much more effectively than traditional classification models.” https://arxiv.org/pdf/2503.23303 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2503.23303
- verdverm 2mo agothis was the period of arxiv history that led to the new vouching system that first person phrase stuck out to me, especially given it had plural versions on either side, the author never edited for clarity or consistency
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- ktimespi 2mo ago"Juvenile" is a weird label to assign to someone whose work is re-presented by someone else and not attributed properly. People here had a very different take on the Navier-Stokes situation XD