3 ms·
Mary Mallon wasn't merely an asymptomatic carrier. She was informed of what she was, and refused to listen. As a result she was held in isolation for three year
by jlgreco 14y ago
Mary Mallon wasn't merely an asymptomatic carrier. She was informed of what she was, and refused to listen. As a result she was held in isolation for three years, but eventually released after promising to give up being a cook. Five years later, after another series of outbreaks, and several deaths, it was discovered that she had changed her name and was once again working as a cook. She was imprisoned/quarantined for a second time, that time for the rest of her life.
It probably is not very nice to call uninformed asymptomatic carriers 'Typhoid Mary's. ;)
- tomjen3 14y agoReading it that way she sounds like an asshole, but what job, other than being a cook, could she even get?
- Tichy 14y agoIt sounds to me as if she was either really stupid or a murderer (or both, if you want).
- jlgreco 14y agoAfter being released she got a job doing laundry. Apparently the pay was less than she was used to, so she started cooking again. I am conflicted on whether I would call her an asshole or not. On one hand it seems she really was lacking malicious intent and simply didn't believe everyone who told her she was hurting people. On the other hand, she really should have believed them. She should have believed them, or at least cooperated with them the first time they tracked her down, and the second time they tracked her down it really should have sunk in. So is it a case of "sufficiently advanced incompetence" being indistinguishable from malice? People were dying because of her deliberate actions, so does it really matter if she didn't intend it? I think it's a fairly complex case.