3 ms·
Even if my particular examples are specific to myself, the point remains intact and true of the larger population. But really, India not being 'Asian' despite
by jlgreco 14y ago
Even if my particular examples are specific to myself, the point remains intact and true of the larger population.
But really, India not being 'Asian' despite being in Asia is a readily observable American phenomenon. If you haven't noticed that, you either have not spent much time in America, or are deluding yourself.
And can you really deny that Egypt is treated differently in popular culture than what is commonly referred to as "Africa"? Do you actually disagree that this is the case, or are you just being a curmudgeon because I dared speak without first securing a sociology degree and perform a study?
You really want some data? The entire concept of "Middle East" is a pretty decent example of how Americans generalize at a finer grain than "continent". Go do a google news search for "Middle East". Count the results, enjoy your precious data.
Would you also demand data of someone who said that Americans think the sky is blue?
- lobster_johnson 14y agoApologies if I am coming across as a curmudgeon. Although you do seem to have been missing my point. I am not questioning the truth of your statements -- for all I know you may be right. I am questioning the form in which they are offered, in a discussion which is already rife with personal opinions disguised as fact. Everyone has an opinion; facts are harder to come by. Specifically, I pointed out that when you say "most Americans", you are just (as you readily admit) extrapolating from yourself. Why not just say "I"? That seems more truthful. I can't reasonably claim to know what "most Americans "think, and neither should you, I think. Extrapolating is just another way of assuming. Sorry about the tangent.