3 ms·
well its the tax breaks of course silly. In the UK the grants for solar used to guarantee around a 8% return - this is a tax break for the Upper middle classes
by walshemj 14y ago
well its the tax breaks of course silly. In the UK the grants for solar used to guarantee around a 8% return - this is a tax break for the Upper middle classes who can spend $20k or so.
This is a result of the silly panic over fukishima in Germany and the greens being brought off to keep Adrea Merkal in power.
- arrrg 14y agoNo it’s not, silly. There aren’t any tax breaks for solar installations in Germany. There are guaranteed prices energy companies have to pay for solar energy from small private installations. And besides, this is about the cost of the installation. You did read the article?
- tsotha 14y ago>There aren’t any tax breaks for solar installations in Germany. There are guaranteed prices energy companies have to pay for solar energy from small private installations. That's even better than a tax break. Who can turn down free money?
- arrrg 14y agoThat’s not the point. The point is the ignorance on display here. If you don’t even know the basics of a policy you have no right to talk about it.
- uvdiv 14y agoThere's a tax break right in the article: "They pay more in sales tax (German installers are exempt)." But you're right, that the largest subsidy is not paid out of tax money, but through a (very large [0]) mandated surcharge on private utility bills. There's little practical difference. It's functionally equivalent to a tax subsidy funded by a tax on electricity. [0] http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/25/eu-oettinger-idUSL5E8KP22V20120925 http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/25/eu-oettinger-idUSL...
- arrrg 14y agoThat’s not a tax break specific to solar installations. In fact, it’s not a tax break at all. It is just a consequence of how German tax law is constructed. It has nothing to do with subsidizing solar installations. If you register your private solar installation as a business, you are exempt from paying sales tax if you also pay revenue tax (= sales tax) for the energy you are selling. Just like the baker buying her oven, if a business buys something for the business, it is (usually) exempt from paying sales tax for it – since sales tax is supposed to be only paid once, not several times. You know, what annoys me is ignorance about the actual policies and then pontificating as if you have it all figured out.
- walshemj 14y agoif the tax law is constructed to have advantages for these "home businesses" then its a tax break and don't get me started on the "hobby" farms that get subsidy's from the CAP budget. An I am a pro EU guy you can see why Ukip are gaining in popularity
- stfu 14y agoIf you want to spur private investments it seems to me smarter to target the middle class than those closer to the welfare benefit system. Home owners are a lot more willing to put money into their property today, i.e. invest money today for the vage promise of the government paying it back over the next 20 years. This seems a much more value creation oriented idea than just to stimulate short term consumption.
- walshemj 14y agoThe voters in Germany might want to to increase funding for Care homes for the elderly or funding for start ups not providing a subsidy to well-of middle class.
- DanBC 14y agoGermany had a lot of solar a long time before Fukishima. Germany's use of solar drove up prices of silicon in 2004. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_cell#Cost http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_cell#Cost) > The price of solar panels fell steadily for 40 years, until 2004 when high subsidies in Germany drastically increased demand there and greatly increased the price of purified silicon (which is used in computer chips as well as solar panels).