3 ms·
I actually think that would be a valuable exercise. Were they right about everything 20 years ago? Or just some things? When did they say AGI would arrive? Shou
by afavour 2mo ago
I actually think that would be a valuable exercise. Were they right about everything 20 years ago? Or just some things? When did they say AGI would arrive? Should that perhaps influence the way we interpret their assumption that AGI is right around the corner?
- jeremyjh 2mo agoThey were not right about everything and they - at least Yudkowsky - has not made specific predictions about "when AGI" will happen that I am aware of. But he did predict it is possible in our lifetimes, which I was very skeptical of. He did predict alignment would be hard - I was in the "why would we even hook it up to the internet?" crowd. He thought he should spend his time on that, and I wish he'd done more of that, or at least convinced others to do more of that.
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- agos 2mo agoFor those out of the loop like me, what is the “everything” they were right about? Is there like a list?
- jeremyjh 2mo agoThe comment said they were not right about everything. I don’t have a list of the predictions or priors you had 20 years ago. I just have my list and I already mentioned them. If this is all new to you, you can’t really do the exercise.
- watwut 2mo agoHis idea of "alignement" is my idea of "dangerous dystopia".
- jeremyjh 2mo agoAlignment means the AI shares the values its creators intended for it. It is not a specific set of values. He has some, sure. For example he wants human society and creative intelligence to survive.
- watwut 2mo agoBut they do have specific values. > For example he wants human society and creative intelligence to survive. They want transhumanism - humans evolved by merging with machines. If we die in the process, it does not matter as long as minority survives and "evolves" they see it as wanted result. I am not OK with minor nor larger genocide, I dont mind at all if we dont evolve.
- XorNot 2mo agoAlso how many predictions did they make? Everyone always goes looking the economist who predicted the last recession, it's just so weird how it's usually a different person each time!