5 ms·
I don't know why anyone would trust this system. China already requires maps to be "fuzzed" for location (if you use Google Maps on your phone in China, your lo
by kalleboo 14y ago
I don't know why anyone would trust this system. China already requires maps to be "fuzzed" for location (if you use Google Maps on your phone in China, your location on the map will be up to 1km wrong), so there doesn't seem to be anything stopping them from doing the same here when they feel it's a sensitive time or area.
- wmf 14y agoThe Chinese military will trust it and Chinese consumers will be coerced into using it just like all the other homegrown standards.
- kalleboo 14y agoOriginally the american GPS system had a encrypted higher-precision signal for military use, and and an open lower-precision signal for civilian use, which could be independently shut off. One day they decided to open up the full precision to everyone. I don't know if the Chinese system is set up similarly, but it's a possibility that the military gets different data from civilians.
- estel 14y agoIf the cost of receivers comes down sharply, devices might try to use as many networks as possible to get an accurate fix as rapidly as possible. I can definitely see GPS-Beidou-Galileo together.
- celoyd 14y agoDefinitely. Mid-range and high-end receivers (for things like ecology surveys and continental drift tracking) integrate GLONASS and GPS already. I don’t have the RF/SP domain knowledge to back this up, but I speculate that multiple low-end receivers for 2–4 of these networks on a single chip might be more useful in practice than a single good receiver for any one network. In other words, a $20 Galileo chip + a $20 GPS chip might give me a faster time-to-fix than a $40 GPS chip. (In terms of units shipped, most GPS goes into phones, where time-to-fix is way more important than centimeter accuracy.)
- pilsetnieks 14y agoEven phones, if they want to be sold in Russia, integrate GLONASS and GPS now.
- rwg 14y agoThere's no reason mobile phones with GPS-only chipsets can't be sold in Russia -- they just get hit with ~25% import duties that phones with GLONASS-supporting chipsets don't have. I wouldn't be surprised at all if China does something similar with Beidou and mobile phones sold in China.
- shawn-butler 14y agoiOS and iPhone hardware since the 4s has supported both aGPRS and GLONASS. Qualcomm snapdragon parts also supported both (so the S2 maybe?) Faster time to fix translates into longer battery life. Whether this matters in practice for much of the Continental US I don't know.
- kamjam 14y agoThis was my initial impression too, but I got the feeling from the article that the Chinese government probably really don't care if no one else uses it, it's for use by their own military and as a means of "protection" against thew US shutting off GPS services to them - highly critical if they want to build those drones which rely on GPS. As an aside, how does the US government make money from the GPS? As a consumer, I pay no money, so I can only assume the GPS chip manufacturers pay some sort of royalty fee?
- sethg 14y agoThe government doesn’t charge anything for GPS: http://www.gps.gov/policy/funding/ http://www.gps.gov/policy/funding/
- jtl09 14y agoyes that is true if you dont count the money you paid for the chain products of GPS.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- michael_miller 14y agoI don't think the purpose was primarily military-related. The US's GPS system can be jammed as is, and I don't see any reason why this system would be any different. GPS satellites are very far up in the atmosphere and thus produce a very weak signal to near-earth. This isn't just a theoretical attack: a few years ago, a truck driver with a GPS jammer accidentally jammed the GPSs of planes above him landing at Newark [1]. I think it's more a matter of national pride issue: to show the world that China doesn't have to rely on the US for technology. Russia's GLONASS system (briefly referenced in the article) is more or less the same thing. The good news is that this system, like GLONASS, will likely improve positioning speed / reliability, since there will be more navigation satellites in the sky. Already, receivers can tie GLONASS and GPS together; it's only a matter of time before Beidou is integrated as well. [1] http://www.economist.com/node/18304246 http://www.economist.com/node/18304246
- 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jtl09 14y agoNot just because U.S. exports the cheapest beef, the other countries no longer raise their cow.
- vivaforever 14y agoIf BeiDou happens to be more advanced than GPS in the future, I bet more people would say, China must have stolen GPS technologies from US, there's no way that the Chinese could ever do something great, just the way as YE SHIWEN won gold medal in London Olympics, the first reaction was not congratulations, but suspecting she must have taken drugs! They didn't find any evidence in exhaustive testings, they claimed that, she had been genetically changed by Chinese government!
- CountSessine 14y agoThe beautiful thing is that with 4 more or less independent global navigation satellite systems in play (GPS, Galileo, Compass/Beidou, and GLONASS), there will be more than 70+ satellites in orbit providing ultra-reliable, ultra-accurate navigation and positioning and you won't necessarily have to trust any one of those networks individually.
- dfc 14y agoDo you have a receiver that works with all four systems?
- justincormack 14y agosoftware defined radio would be a good bet for that.
- kalleboo 14y agoI'm curious how soon mobile phones will have so many tuners that SDR is worth it. A typical phone now has what, 4 GSM bands, 3 UMTS bands, 3 LTE bands, WiFi, Bluetooth, GPS, GLONASS, FM Radio, 1seg, NFC...
- justincormack 14y agoThey would probably have more if they were cheaper, all sorts of countries have random frequency bands being freed up for mobile. But I think power consumption still the limiting factor.
- rwg 14y agoSuch a thing doesn't exist. For one, neither Beidou nor Galileo are operational GNSSes, so there is no economic incentive to create receivers that work with those services. Also, the Chinese government only just today published Beidou's ICD, the document that specifies the open-access Beidou signals: http://www.insidegnss.com/node/3331 http://www.insidegnss.com/node/3331
- jtl09 14y agoPlease keep goosey. You didn't how happy the Chinese are now. you can't see they've become stronger because your eyes were blinded by your arrogance and the fear of rising of China.