5 ms·
29C3 Live Stream from Hamburg (Keynote: Jacob Appelbaum)
- dexcs 14y agoFor all not german-speaking: He's literally talking about how politicians and media use words and sentences to not blame themselves... Really funny...
- Inufu 14y agoI believe you are referencing "DIE WAHRHEIT, WAS WIRKLICH PASSIERTE UND WAS IN DER ZEITUNG STAND" (the truth, what really happened and what the newspapers said) http://events.ccc.de/congress/2012/Fahrplan/events/5181.en.html http://events.ccc.de/congress/2012/Fahrplan/events/5181.en.h..., which is the talk after the keynote. Jacob's talk was in English.
- dexcs 14y agostrange... your're right.... I just followed the link and saw this stream...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sneak 14y agoJake Appelbaum is an attention-whore who wished for the wrong thing and got it. The type of fight he's fighting, which, indeed, was foretold by the cypherpunks years before he ever compiled a program, is one of vast asymmetry. He's the source of the quote "the government has a monopoly on violence, but violence can't solve math problems". The problem is, when you function within an outlawed organization using your above-ground identity, you choose to have your own life destroyed, rendering you unable to be effective in doing the things you talk about being so important. We're talking, here, about a guy who gives sensationalist interviews to Rolling Stone about how he can hack into anything on the internet. They don't need to break your crypto. They can just break you. When fighting the surveillance state, you can be famous, xor you can be effective. Period. I wrote about this some time ago: https://eeqj.com/20110113/wikileaks/ Don't believe the hype. Every single person paying attention knows Wikileaks would have been way more effective if it had been fronted by a signing key instead of Julian Assange's haircut. They might have even been able to continue functioning instead of being extrajudicially harassed into oblivion. These people serve as examples of how _not_ to effect meaningful change. PS: It also speaks volumes about the current state of the Chaos Computer Club and their conference that they chose such a meaningless sycophant as their keynote speaker.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- magikarp 14y agoI should probably mention that this guy has been following Appelbaum around the Internet for literally years, commenting like this on every post about him that he can find. He's @sneakatdatavibe from Twitter, IIRC.
- sneak 14y agoInteresting that you should post this, as Schneier literally posted a blog entry seconds ago entitled "Public Shaming as a Security Measure": http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/12/public_shaming.html
- indiecore 14y agoMan, how little of a life/how boring of a job must this guy have...
- tptacek 14y agoSo what you're saying is that he actually believes what he's saying? THAT BASTARD. Thanks for alerting us.
- axusgrad 14y agoBased on sneak's HN posting history, it would be weird if he let this one go by without commenting.
- brain5ide 14y agoSo we basically have Anonymous or lulz-sec working on your proposed model. You think wikileaks made less noise and effect than Anonymous? Jacob's talk was a pretty good one for an attention whore and that's what keynote speeches are supposed to be about.
- sneak 14y ago1) You can't use Anonymous as a subject for the verb "working" because it's not a noun - it's an adjective, and it's capitalized out of convention, not because it's a name. 2) Those calling themselves anonymous are still operating. Wikileaks is basically paralyzed (which is unfortunate). 3) The Federalist Papers. 4) The Arab Spring revolutions.
- rdl 14y agoDoh -- I didn't realize the URL was just to whoever was currently in Track 1 (which was Jake's keynote at the time). A better URL for the whole thing is http://29c3.fem-net.de/ http://29c3.fem-net.de/ There seem to be some technical difficulties; I hope the talks end up on YouTube afterward.
- cvursache 14y agoPeople like Jake Appelbaum that manage (or actively try) to stay in the spotlight also educate the general public about security. That is something very valuable for a community: to have evangelists going around and spreading the word while getting all the attention. Just look at people like Noam Chomsky, Richard Dawkins, Jacob Bronowski, Carl Sagan, and so on. They could have all been doing science instead of working for months on television programs. They didn't because they believed educating the public is a worthwhile task. I sure hope we never run out of people that share the same opinion.
- maradydd 14y agoIf Appelbaum is trying to educate the general public, he's doing a piss-poor job of it. Sagan, Dawkins and Chomsky approach[ed] the general public via the media and reach[ed] hundreds of millions of people. (Cosmos alone: over 500 million. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmos:_A_Personal_Voyage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmos:_A_Personal_Voyage) Appelbaum found himself a community numbering in the tens of thousands, rode the coattails of actual researchers to prominence by making minor contributions to their work and overplaying his role, and now rests on other people's laurels. He's only a big fish because this pond is so small.
- cvursache 14y agoI am not as informed about Appelbaum as you seem to be, but regardless of his actual contributions to the field, maybe it's not so clear about whether or not he's doing a poor job educating the general public. The numbers of minds captivated with stories told by the likes of Carl Sagan are, as you mentioned, orders of magnitude bigger than what Appelbaum could accomplish. But take Mikko Hypponen or Moxie Marlinspike - great speakers with great things done - would you say that they come even close to what Noam Chomsky reaches with his talks? I don't have concrete data on this, but I do believe the answer to be a clear no. And that's maybe because the majority of the population of the world isn't as interested in computer security as they are in debates about religion, science, politics, sports, consumer electronics or whatever. Maybe this field is just too young to be a permanent part of day-to-day concerns or to have more than a couple of tens of thousands of people interested in it. And maybe that's why it's probably worth considering supporting the few public figures this field has.
- haakon 14y agoI guess it's over by now; is a recording available yet?
- janerik 14y agoThe talks will be published 1-2 weeks after the congress (so expect it in mid-january)
- haakon 14y agoTalk has been posted here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wl5OQz0Ko8c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wl5OQz0Ko8c