4 ms·
When the history books are written and all is said and done, the hubris of this moment where all the American labs decided to punk their investors and join hand
by nickysielicki 2mo ago
When the history books are written and all is said and done, the hubris of this moment where all the American labs decided to punk their investors and join hand in hand in agreeing to let the Chinese win forever is going to be the main story.
- EGreg 2mo agoWin what? The race to the bottom always has this competitive language. “If we ban CFCs now the Chinese will win!” “If we ban chemical weapons, nuclear weapons, etc etc our enemies will triumph! They won’t stop!” “If we switch to biodegradeable plastic then our rivals will have an advantage.” “If we dont externalize the costs to our population, then they will, and then will win!” I think workflows can do the job agents do, 20x cheaper and more predictably and safely. They can completely displace agents, just as HFCs displaced CFCs and then we were able to ban CFCs and phase them out through international COOPERATION. The language of COOPERATION is what saves us vs COMPETITION is all about cutting corners and externalizing costs. Google the Montreal Protocol, Geneva Conventions, Nuclear Non Proliferation Treaty, Unleaded Gasoline etc etc. Agents have got to be marginalized. They are just popular because the labs need to make a ton of money for their investors and recoup their massive spending on training models.
- airstrike 2mo agoThose comparisons are pretty irrelevant You can't compare banning football to banning genetic experiments and say "they are both bans and therefore directly comparable"
- EGreg 2mo agoNo one was talking about football. We're talking about replacing most uses of Agents with uses of Workflows. That's the key first step, without which the industry will cry "don't regulate us... do you want China to WIN???"
- palmotea 2mo ago> When the history books are written and all is said and done, the hubris of this moment where all the American labs decided to punk their investors and join hand in hand in agreeing to let the Chinese win forever is going to be the main story. Come on. Lecturing about hubris when your message is damn the consequences, full speed ahead? If it's a race to build the torment nexus, or a race with a nonzero chance of building the torment nexus by accident, I don't care about winning.
- strictnein 2mo ago> Lecturing about hubris when your message is damn the consequences, full speed ahead They said that... where?
- palmotea 2mo ago> They said that... where? By dismissing concerns and focusing exclusively competition and "winning the race."
- nilamo 2mo agoThere's a race? I didn't see that at all in the OP
- strictnein 2mo agoYou don't win a race by having a "damn the consequences, full speed ahead" attitude. That's how you lose a race.