Interesting choice to include that reviewer comment at the bottom which doesn't really comment on the article at all. The reviewer says "based on the opening p

Interesting choice to include that reviewer comment at the bottom which doesn't really comment on the article at all. The reviewer says "based on the opening paragraph I thought this was going to be about topic X. Here are my thoughts on topic X". That's great, but the article isn't about topic X. What are your thoughts about the actual topic of the article? Did you read it, or just the opening paragraph?