3 ms·
I dislike a badly designed mall like everyone else, but is it already sealioning if an article ends on a leading question to hide its far-right liberal conserva
by janpeuker 19d ago
I dislike a badly designed mall like everyone else, but is it already sealioning if an article ends on a leading question to hide its far-right liberal conservative agenda?
The National Civic Art Society is designing the White House State Ballroom [1] and Create Streets is a conservative influence group that likes speaking at Reform UK events [2]. As many others here have pointed out, visual preference, especially in such a binary choice between obviously cheap and ugly vs expensive and generous, is of course highly biased - pseudo greek style doesn't fly in Asia, even in Australia minimalist styles are much more en vogue.
The most important claims like "exclusively teaches broadly modernist styles" are completely unsupported - especially when a few lines down they literally use their own review of an architect's design, but then call it "in a style drawing on Victorian commercial architecture and Art Deco", again unsubstantiated - it has pretty "modern" clear lines, probably due to sustainability [3], and brick facades themselves have been around for long. In the report they praise the 2010 (!) London city building design guide recommending exactly this brick design. "hardly a single public commission" and "we commissioning styles"?
Where is the line between justifying dictator-style grandiose architecture and the actual empathy needed for simply good design?
I'm just asking questions.
1) https://www.dezeen.com/2025/01/29/justin-shubow-trump-architecture-executive-order-interview/ https://www.dezeen.com/2025/01/29/justin-shubow-trump-archit...
2) https://www.building.co.uk/focus/reform-uk-conference-funding-furore-overshadows-radical-planning-proposals/5143969.article https://www.building.co.uk/focus/reform-uk-conference-fundin...
3) https://www.archpaper.com/2025/10/biennale-architettura-carlo-ratti-justin-shubow-classical-architecture-mandate/ https://www.archpaper.com/2025/10/biennale-architettura-carl...