3 ms·
Once the hypothesis is assumed - that user access to their software source is a human right, equivalent to the inalienable right to life, liberty, and the pursu
by dalke 14y ago
Once the hypothesis is assumed - that user access to their software source is a human right, equivalent to the inalienable right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness - the logic itself is unassailable. Under that hypothesis, you are like someone saying that slavery is sometimes okay talking to an ardent abolitionist. You might have an economic argument for why someone deserves to be enslaved, but that doesn't sway the other person's sense of morality.
I, like you, happen to not believe that hypothesis, but I think you can see why your utilitarian logic may not be persuasive.
- smsm42 14y agoThis is a weird assumption. I certainly can see why you would want access to the source code - it has many practical and theoretical benefits. However, the fact that you want something does not mean you have right to have it - and I see no reason to accept the premise that access to the source code of a program created by somebody else is comparable to my right to life. I can not see where this right comes from - do I have the right to see all the source code in the world? Or just for the code I would like to use? Or maybe just for the code that does something deemed useful by the government? Or maybe just the code that was already seen by certain amount of other people? What about source code that contains private data - do I have the right to see that too? What if the code contains access key to your bank account and you never intended for anybody but you to see it - do I have the right to see that? What if you gave that code to your family (i.e. "distributed" it) - do I get the right to see it now? I think the whole concept of declaring it to be "human right" is misguided, and, even more, harmful for actual human rights - as it gives one the impression that "human rights" is something like "if I want something really bad, I must have it". Human rights is a very different concept, and saying that demanding from Microsoft to reveal their trade secrets is like fighting slavery is, IMHO, a bit offensive to people that suffered and fought the actual slavery. We may say Microsoft keeping the source secret makes their product worse but it's not the same as slavery, not by a long shot.
- dalke 14y agoThese are tricky waters, so I'm not sure I can do the GNU viewpoint justice. You should read their FAQ and other essays for details. They talk about the four freedoms: - The freedom to run the program, for any purpose (freedom 0). - The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish (freedom 1). Access to the source code is a precondition for this. - The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor (freedom 2). - The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others (freedom 3). By doing this you can give the whole community a chance to benefit from your changes. Access to the source code is a precondition for this. "do I have the right to see all the source code in the world?" No, you can't force someone to show you their software. Their list of freedoms is only triggered when you legally receive a copy of the software, or hardware which includes the software. "What about source code that contains private data?" - Since no one is forced to give you the source code, then this doesn't apply. If they gave you the private data voluntarily, then it's not really that private, is it? If the "private data" is a required decryption key, then you must be provided that information. If the private data is a data file which is not part of the program, then it's not covered. "What if you gave that code to your family" - Nope. It's triggered when you receive the software, not when someone else receives it. "demanding from Microsoft to reveal their trade secrets is like fighting slavery is, IMHO, a bit offensive to people that suffered and fought the actual slavery" - Oh, I agree. I think I'm being overly blunt in describing GNU's view that way. I do it to get across the view that they view it as a moral obligation, which is different than the Open Source view that it's an economic advantage. That's why "makes their product worse" doesn't cut it for GNU. They don't care if software is crappy or not, they only care that it's free ... and 'non-crappy' is only important when it advances the cause of freedom.