4 ms·
A succession crisis that tore England apart (2023)
- roenxi 2mo ago> The double standards are evident when we consider that all of this would sound ludicrous if aimed at a man who had been proclaimed king... I don't know about that, the quoted criticisms sound a lot like those that would be levelled at a king too. The issue is more that nobody expects a man to care, even a little bit, if someone accuses him of being crude and arbitrary in his search for power. Obviously it is gendered, but the actual complaints are generic. Anyone with serious power has to bat through things like that. I can give an example by swapping in Trump. The criticism holds up with a gender swap, adjusted for the fact that by default we expect a man to be in the office so it isn't explicitly gendered. This sounds like stock criticism of him that might turn up in any political conversation. [Donald Trump] at once put on an extremely arrogant demeanour instead of the modest gait and bearing proper to --the gentle sex-- [his office], began to walk and speak and do all things more stiffly and haughtily than [he] had been wont … [he] arranged everything as [he himself] thought fit and according to [his] own arbitrary will.
- pjc50 2mo agoNo, the gender role stuff is absolutely critical and you can't just handwave it away. Married women couldn't own their own property independently in England until 1870. In particular, the belief that a married woman had no agency separate from her husband, who would then be de facto king, continued all the way up to Elisabeth II. Much reduced and not ultimately a problem, but it was still discussed at the time of her coronation. What is more interesting in all this is the reminder of the succession crisis. Monarchy is "supposed to" reduce chaotic power struggles like this by making it unambiguous, but quite often the English succession was disputed or passed down through a second degree relationship.
- roenxi 2mo agoIt's not a handwave - the article doesn't offer anything to handwave away. The article says that she was offered specifically gendered criticism, then quotes generic criticism. I'm sure being a woman counted against her, bit if the article is going to put up a quote as evidence of sexism then it shouldn't be a passage that can be realistically adapted to any politician ever. If the article had a passage that says "we can't let this woman be king, she can't even own property!" that would be different. But the quote in the article doesn't sound ludicrous when applied to a man. It sounds like something that is routinely said of men in positions of power. It could even keep the superficial gendering if you wanted it to, there is a lot of argument that men in positions of power should be exhibiting positive masculine bearing (stoicism, accountability, honour, etc, etc) that politicians routinely fail at to great public outcry.
- scott_w 2mo agoI’m struggling to follow your point. The article isn’t giving a major thesis on why medieval people thought Matilda couldn’t rule England. From the perspective of the barons at the time, Matilda couldn’t be queen in her own right because women can’t rule. They didn’t think any deeper than that.
- roenxi 2mo agoMy point is the article claimed it would show evidence of something when in fact it did not. It should either not have bothered to include evidence or found better evidence
- scott_w 2mo agoEr… no it didn’t? It just said the criticism being based on her womanhood was evident because of <reason>, it never promised to prove it, it was just a rhetorical device and they expect the reader to know the information already. If you want to learn more about early medieval attitudes to women and power in England, it’s on you to learn, not on the article to triple its length to prove every minor claim.
- scott_w 2mo agoMore importantly: a king was expected to embody the traits a queen was hammered for.
- graemep 2mo ago> Married women couldn't own their own property independently in England until 1870. This predates married women losing the right to control their own property https://lawandhistoryreview.org/article/married-womens-property-a-medieval-perspective/ https://lawandhistoryreview.org/article/married-womens-prope...
- Amezarak 2mo ago[dead]
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- flanked-evergl 2mo agoNothing tore England apart like winning the cold war.
- hdgvhicv 2mo ago> For the first time since 1066, the death of an English king did not result in an undignified scramble for the throne Yes 1066 was a peaceful transition and certainly not a scramble
- hdgvhicv 2mo agoHow refreshing to read something on my phone away from pihole which is actually prose and accompanying images, rather than thousands of adverts for al the trashiest scammiest adverts going and if you’re lucky a few sentences between
- GeoAtreides 2mo ago>Designating a woman as his successor was such an unprecedented action that Henry felt obliged to compel his nobles, barons and churchmen to swear an oath of allegiance to Matilda. All of them did so, although some complied with greater reluctance than others. [...] her cousin Stephen (a younger son of Henry’s sister Adela, dowager countess of Blois) had rushed to England, seized the royal treasury and had himself crowned. G.R.R.M.: it's free real estate
- jstanley 2mo ago> some complied with greater reluctance than others. Is always true, unless they somehow all comply with precisely equal reluctance.
- gcanyon 2mo agoI think they mean there was a greater variation in reluctance than might be expected, or that there was some serious arm-twisting to get people to go along, which had future consequences.
- mattmcal 2mo ago> [H]ad Henry left the crown to a 33-year-old, intelligent, well-educated, politically experienced son, such a situation would not have arisen. > However, even such a decisive military victory was not enough to overturn a genuinely deep-seated prejudice against a female monarch. Clearly prejudice, and lack of precedent, materially hampered Matilda's attempt at the throne, but speculative and reductive statements like these carry a whiff of dubious history. It gives the impression that Matilda's failed succession hinged uniquely on her gender, when her own father Henry I only gained power after a long and violent succession struggle involving both of his siblings. I assume the author's book goes into much greater detail on the many reasons Matilda's succession never achieved critical mass in England, but I think this short an article is probably worse for giving so much emphasis to this particular detail.
- sandworm101 2mo agoPrejudice and some practical reality. Woman at the time died randomly but very regularly in childbirth. Every pregnant woman had a sword dangling over her head: not a safe bet for leadership.
- saghm 2mo agoThe article literally gives an example of her cousin (i.e. not a direct descendant of the current monarch) trying to get himself crowned; it's not like she had to have kids in order for the monarchy to have an heir after her. Claiming that the reaction would have been less severe if she promised not to have kids seems pretty baseless.
- sandworm101 2mo agoNo. She couldn't lead while she was pregnant as she might die and start the whole process again.
- saghm 2mo agoShe was pregnant 15 years after the reluctancy that was described. Can you provide any actual evidence that they were concerned about that specifically? It sounds a lot more like you're making an inference of two arbitrary facts in the article being related, and it's hard not to get that impression it says a lot more about your biases than having any basis in history
- niklasbuschmann 2mo agoThe naming in this one is so confusing
- greenbit 2mo agoThe two Matildas in particular!
- tetris11 2mo agoFelicia Hemans's poem He Never Smiled Again is an ode to Henry I's reaction to his son and only male heir perishing in the tragedy > The bark that held a prince went down, > The sweeping waves roll’d on; > And what was England’s glorious crown > To him that wept a son? > He lived-for life may long be borne > Ere sorrow break its chain;- > Why comes not death to those who mourn? > —He never smiled again! https://www.poeticous.com/felicia-hemans/he-never-smiled-again https://www.poeticous.com/felicia-hemans/he-never-smiled-aga...
- erehweb 2mo agoSee also the BBC kids show "Horrible Histories" which gives an Abba-song parody of this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuZsueUBvdU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuZsueUBvdU