4 ms·
Align AI and Mathematics–To Something Else
- andrepd 2mo agoHow in god's name—irrespective of how valid this is, and its very valid—is this even remotely germane to the issue of AI in mathematics? Rattling off incidents and making the case that there is discrimination and sexists in mathematics (yeah no shit), how is this related to the issue of AI that was raised in the letter? Are the complaints raised in that letter any less valid because the mathematicians who signed them make part of a community which has reproachable behaviour, both past and present? I really don't get it.
- thorum 2mo agoWhy does it have to be about that? The author says they agree with the letter in the first paragraph.
- warkdarrior 2mo agoThe letter claims that AI is destroying the mathematics community as is now. The blog asks whether the mathematics community as is now is worth saving.
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- rramadass 2mo agoYou are right. This just reads like a rancorous rant. In any human group there will always be issues on how we treat each other dependent on time/context/culture. But while not condoning it, this issue is orthogonal to that of misaligned AI. The communique from the mathematicians when shorn of polite language is blunt viz. AI companies are stealing our hard-won lifelong research findings, which we were already sharing freely, without attribution/credit and building upon them without informed consent nor compensation. The above is true for "misaligned AI" in all the Sciences. It is time the Scientific Community got together and sued the hell out of the AI companies.
- pfdietz 2mo agoNo informed consent is needed to use previous research findings. This is the invention of IP that doesn't exist.
- rramadass 2mo agoYou do with leading edge research problem approaches; particularly if you plan to throw millions of dollars worth of resources to brute-force a solution which a normal researcher (who has actually done part of the hard work over a long period of time) cannot afford. It is called common decency/etiquette, having ethics/morals and not plagiarising/stealing others work.
- pfdietz 2mo agoYou've pulled that out of thin air, so I can dismiss it in the same spirit. No, there is no such requirement. Deal.
- rramadass 2mo agoWhat part of "It is called common decency/etiquette, having ethics/morals and not plagiarising/stealing others work" don't you understand? It is the accepted way to use each other's works in the scientific community. That is why citations/references/bibliographies exist.
- pfdietz 2mo agoI understand it. I just consider it a bullshit take that has nothing to do with the reality of mathematics. There's never been such a consideration that one should not work on a problem that someone else is working on or has worked on. Nor do I think it's something that should be true. Mathematics exists and is supported to benefit society, not to pamper mathematicians.
- rramadass 2mo ago
- WCSTombs 2mo agoIt's a clumsily made point, but I think the gist is that the letter asks AI to align to a certain ideal vision of the field of math, that the math community itself is not well aligned to. I don't think the article makes this point well, though, just by listing these incidents. Don't get me wrong - each incident is important and worthy of attention in its own right, but I find the overall argument to be pretty weak and strongly reeking of whataboutism.
- andai 2mo agoI've heard this idea before, that civilization itself is already a misaligned intelligence, and that AI will merely amplify the existing tendencies. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KCSsKV5F4xc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KCSsKV5F4xc
- rramadass 2mo agoThis is actually pretty good! Thanks for sharing.
- stbede 2mo agoI think the letter is misguided. So what if the AI labs are misaligned to math? - But they announced a result before a paper was peer reviewed! The horror! So what? The mathematics community can read the paper once it is written up. - But their results they publish may not care about conceptual understanding and insight! So what? If that's the mathematics community's goal, then they should sift through the lean proof and reformat the ideas to make them more insightful and develop their own conceptual understanding. - But they aren't bothering to do literature review to tell the history about how humans contributed to the final result! So what? If it's so important to the mathematical community, they can do that themselves and throw a party every Tuesday in the honor of Luis Martínez-Zoroa and wear jeans on casual Friday in honor of Buckmaster and Alpöge - the left leg for Buckmaster and the right for Alpöge. An AI giving a definite result of an open problem doesn't decrease the mathematical community's insight or conceptual understanding. They are still free to continue doing their work and pursuing their goals. If it's really so bad, they can just pretend they don't know NS is solved and keep spending their efforts trying to prove it never blows up (or a hand full of them can try to blow it up from scratch). Guess what! I spend no part of my life working on unsolved math problems. I read some books for pleasure. I work in a hospitable with sick kids. I help my wife raise our kids. My goals are misaligned with the mathematics community! I've done nothing to increase conceptual understanding and insight! So what?
- MattGaiser 2mo agoThis whole discussion is basically a field demanding that their field be preserved for them alone to discover. No competition allowed besides the monks of mathematics.
- mag7269 2mo ago"People inside a moat, want to keep the moat from being breached because it fucks with their status quo." EVERY.SINGLE.TIME. No shit, why would they want something disruptive to fuck with the way elite academia operates? And obviously I am talking about the "Master of the Universe" types atop the Ivory Tower. They have been A-OK, with privately-funded professorships, partnering with book publishers to milk students with single-access codes and never-ending "new" editions to their books, summer salary grants, partnering with all sorts of private companies as contractors, and/or milking on the tenure tit while the average adjunct lecturer at a local college/university struggles to make ends-meet and has 150 students in a lecture. The author talks about his UC Berkeley years. That UC Berkeley that opened and operated for nearly a century as a public institution educating California's true middle class up until the 1960 Donahoe Master Plan, but slowly progressed to gate-keep "normies" out and pivoted to a model of elitism that is absolutely and catastrophically broken. Fuck off.
- rramadass 2mo ago> book publishers to milk students with single-access codes and never-ending "new" editions to their books, The best example of this is James Stewart's Calculus textbooks. It is priced so high and made him so much money that he built a $24 million "Integral House"! Where the money from your Stewart calculus book goes - https://www.mprnews.org/story/2011/04/18/where-the-money-from-your-stewart-calculus-book-goes https://www.mprnews.org/story/2011/04/18/where-the-money-fro... The House That Calculus Built - https://www.fastcompany.com/3052267/the-house-that-calculus-built https://www.fastcompany.com/3052267/the-house-that-calculus-... PS: Just to be clear, the above has got nothing to do with mathematicians and their work. It just goes to show how bad the textbook publishing industry is in shafting students that you can make money off of them by selling centuries old well-known mathematics.
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- throwaway_7274 2mo agoFat cat math professors have had it too good for too long. Leave some crumbs for the AI company CEOs!
- xanderlewis 2mo agoI have a strong sense that almost none of the commenters and blog post authors ranting here about mathematics have any clue about mathematics or its culture. I do not recognise any of these descriptions of mathematicians at all, and can only imagine they’re based entirely on experiences of other, almost entirely unrelated, parts of academia. This is not the first time I’ve seen it online, but recent events seem to have exacerbated it. Not sure quite what animates the absurd hatred of one of the least greedy groups of people on the planet, but it certainly isn’t experience. To anyone with any, it just looks like absurd derangement.
- rramadass 2mo agoYou are quite right. All threads on this topic (i.e. Mathematicians and AI) are overrun by bots/shills/vested interests/etc. astroturfing for the companies. It is just Propaganda and attempting to manipulate Public Opinion.