3 ms·
> But only 13% of savings actually went to the citizens. 87% of that tax money went to coroporations with large tracts of land (agriculture, warehouses, ...).
by anamax 18y ago
> But only 13% of savings actually went to the citizens. 87% of that tax money went to coroporations with large tracts of land (agriculture, warehouses, ...).
The last time I looked, biz were owned by people. More important, biz expenses, such as taxes, are paid by people too. As a result, that distinction between "biz" and "people" doesn't make sense. Prop 13 limited the tax increases paid by people due to property value changes.
> stated that the property tax of a piece of land would be fixed at 1975 levels with a maximum of a 2% increase each
As I pointed out, that's wrong. There is a reassessment on on sale. My "prop 13" basis was set when I bought my house, decades after 1975. (My parent's basis, on the other hand, was set in 1975.) That's why my property taxes went up last year even though my "if I sold" value went down. (They'll go up next year too.)
That's why CA's property tax revenues are roughly stable.
I note that CA's income tax collection is incredibly variable, in part because so much is paid by the folks at the top.
- fgimenez 18y ago>The distinction between "biz" and "people" doesn't make sense The business doesn't necessarily need to be based out of California, which means that money doesn't necessarily stay in California. Also, while that business can reinvest in the state, I just don't see how that can quickly reach the needs of citizens. A corporation saving millions might pay its employees more, who will pay income tax, which will eventually reach a state government only causing further centralization of state powers. >There is a reassessment on sale. Your right. That reassessment is exactly what drives away large new corporate jobs. Imagine company A has a warehouse since 1975. A pays taxes at (1975 level)*1.02^34. This increase is significantly less than actual property values have increased. So when its main competitor, company B, comes to town shopping for a huge tract of land, it's looking at paying reassessment taxes. If they both did the exact same job with the same income, company A stands at a huge advantage solely because it pays so little in property tax compared to B. Warren Buffet nearly destroyed Arnold Schwarzenegger's campaign when he stated that prop 13 was terrible, specifically targeting the reassessment clause. http://www.wealthandwant.com/docs/Buffett_Prop13.html http://www.wealthandwant.com/docs/Buffett_Prop13.html
- anamax 18y ago> The business doesn't necessarily need to be based out of California, which means that money doesn't necessarily stay in California. Biz taxes are paid by customers. So yes, some of the savings will go to out of state customers. If you want to argue that CA should have fewer biz that serve out of state customers, feel free. > Also, while that business can reinvest in the state, I just don't see how that can quickly reach the needs of citizens. Huh? > A corporation saving millions might pay its employees more, who will pay income tax, which will eventually reach a state government Now I understand. You don't count money paid to employees as "reaching citizens". You think that the only money that "reaches citizens" comes from govt. That's an interesting position. > Warren Buffet nearly destroyed Arnold Schwarzenegger's campaign when he stated that prop 13 was terrible, specifically targeting the reassessment clause. Yes, Warren Buffet. The guy who argues for the estate tax yet has arranged things so his wealth will never be taxed. Moreover, he sells insurance to folks whose estates can't be so arranged so they can pay the estate tax. (In other words, he profits from the estate tax.) Buffet is a great stock picker, but if you're looking to him for advice on good and evil....
- lutorm 18y ago"The last time I looked, biz were owned by people. More important, biz expenses, such as taxes, are paid by people too. As a result, that distinction between "biz" and "people" doesn't make sense." Maybe you want to elaborate on this point, because I don't get it. How does the fact that businesses are owned by people equate to the fact that they should be protected from taxation from their valuable property? My impression of Prop 13 was that the intent was to prevent retired people and low-income people who happened to live in an area of rapidly increasing property values from being forced out of their home. This I agree with. To argue that this should necessarily mean that businesses should be protected from paying taxes on property values that go up does not follow for me. What is the greater good achieved by this?
- anamax 18y ago> Maybe you want to elaborate on this point, because I don't get it. How does the fact that businesses are owned by people equate to the fact that they should be protected from taxation from their valuable property? I didn't say that biz should be treated differently. I said that taxes paid on biz owned property was actually paid by people, mostly by their customers.