2 ms·
You rarely hear of Google outages, or iTunes, or Youtube, or [insert six dozen other popular brands], do you? Yes it can happen to the best of them, but the EC2
by jrockway 14y ago
You rarely hear of Google outages, or iTunes, or Youtube, or [insert six dozen other popular brands], do you? Yes it can happen to the best of them, but the EC2 outages are really piling up lately.
To me, this makes perfect sense. Google products are almost always designed to tolerate data center failures, and so you don't hear about data center failures affecting Google products. On the other hand, Joe's Random EC2 app is not designed for the same high availability, and so it's down whenever Amazon is. (This, incidentally, is a reasonable trade-off for most people. A few hours of downtime a year is often much cheaper than paying engineers to ensure that those few hours are five minutes or less.)
So the flaw here is not Amazon. The flaw is relying on one cluster of computers to handle all your computing needs. Amazon could make their product high-replication by default, but it would be so slow and expensive that nobody would use it. So the task is kicked to the application developers instead of the platform developers, and you should consider holding them responsible for the downtime.
(Incidentally, you can compare EC2 to AppEngine here. How often is your favorite AppEngine app down? Less than your favorite EC2 app, probably, because AppEngine pretty much forces the high-replication datastore, even though the semantics are strange for developers used to traditional single-homed or master/slave architectures. And if you read the AppEngine discussion groups, you'll see that users raise most of the concerns that I describe here: "Why is AppEngine more expensive than EC2?" "Why is AppEgnine slower than EC2?", and so on.)
Now, why does Netflix's video serving go down when an EC2 cell does? I have absolutely no idea. I do know that they do more than just stream bytes, though; they have to authenticate users, track what they're watching, and apply DRM to the streams. So there's that.
If you want fault-tolerant video distribution, look no further than the Pirate Bay. Although their servers are frequently seized, the video bits keep flowing. That's by design, not by accident.