5 ms·
The problem is Intel has already lost on the performance side. Intel has always needed 3 things to beat ARM, and they need all 3 to be competitive: performance,
by mtgx 14y ago
The problem is Intel has already lost on the performance side. Intel has always needed 3 things to beat ARM, and they need all 3 to be competitive: performance, energy efficiency, price.
With Atom, they've always had the performance advantage. In fact they've had a big advantage over ARM at the time when when Atom came out. It was like several times more powerful than the ARM chip inside iPhone 3G.
But to be competitive, Intel needed to compete on the other 2 levels, as well. So they kept Atom's performance mostly the same, while they tried over the years to push Atom down from a 10W TDP. But while Intel tried to lower the power consumption, ARM's chips were gaining in performance - faster than Intel. So now when Intel has finally reached parity with ARM in energy efficiency, ARM has surpassed it in performance with Cortex A15, and from what I've seen so far, by a lot.
Then there's also the pricing issue. I think they've improved there quite a bit. An Atom chip used to be close to $100. Now it's probably more like $40-$50 (this dual core version). But that's still like at least 50% more than an ARM chip.
So Intel still has a lot of catching up to do in "overall competitiveness", because right now it looks like they've only switched the much bigger performance leadership for "energy efficiency parity", and are losing at the other two. I'd like to see how high they are willing to go with Atom on performance, until they realize that it's going to cannibalize their Core i3 market.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThis is a faulty analysis, I think. The Atom wasn't originally directly in competition with ARM, they were in different market segments. And it wasn't a case of the atom merely being iterated in design until it matched ARM efficiency levels, that's not what's happened. Instead, the Atom was originally just a low-power stand-alone processor and now Intel has developed a first generation Atom based system-on-a-chip. The fact that Intel's first SoC designs are so closely competitive to ARM's n-th generation designs should send alarm bells ringing throughout the ARM industry. Intel is good at improving design and they are even better at economies of scale. It's easy to dismiss Intel's offerings as not being competitive with state-of-the-art ARM designs, but only a sucker would dismiss Intel and rest on their laurels. Intel's 2nd and 3rd generation chips are just going to be that much better, and ARM could be in serious trouble in as little as a year or two from now. Imagine, for example, an Intel based android powered tablet that can run stock Windows in a VM or emulate windows and can run most windows applications and perhaps even games, while also being able to run all android applications. And do so at a cost/performance/efficiency level equivalent to any ARM based system. That's the sort of thing that should send shivers down the back of Samsung or even Apple.
- thrownaway2424 14y agoIndeed. It would also be a serious error to assume that anyone will be on Intel's leading edge process any time soon. At some point there is a process node that only Intel can afford to develop, and ARM makers are going to just sit there on their old process, whic might be cheaper but isn't going to be as efficient.
- justincormack 14y agoIts not really a SoC in any meaningful sense, other than integrated GPU and memory controller (which most CPUs have now) is it? Compared to ARM SoCs which are very highly integrated so you more or less have to wire up power and RAM.
- vidarh 14y agoARM CPU's outsold Intel CPU's in volume well before tablets and smartphones started using them. If I remember correctly, projected volume of ARM CPU's for this year is in the region of 3 billion units. The smartphone and tablet market is not even near being the majority of ARM CPU sales. So I don't think ARM will despair over Intel's designs just yet.
- Joeri 14y agoVolume is not profit. Intel is an order of magnitude more profitable. However, ARM's model seems to be to suck the profit out of the market. It's a textbook example of a paradigm shift, with an initially inferior product offered at a much lower price point gradually catching up with the market leader. Intel has no choice but to follow ARM down the price curve to settle at a lower profit margin. They seem to have realized this with their current chip strategy. I would be looking at intel to start diversifying into the device market, because that's where the profit is moving.
- hga 14y agoA lot more: From Wikipedia: "In 2011, ARM's customers reported 7.9 billion ARM processors shipped, representing 95% of smartphones, 90% of hard disk drives, 40% of digital televisions and set-top boxes, 15% of microcontrollers and 20% of mobile computers." That roughly matches my memory of previous recent years' reported sales.
- phaus 14y agoThe new atom processors really only cost 50 bucks? So does that mean there is pretty much no reason at all for the 150-300 dollar premium on atom based that we are currently seeing?
- stdbrouw 14y ago> Intel has always needed 3 things to beat ARM, and they need all 3 to be competitive: performance, energy efficiency, price. It's a nitpick, but surely you don't mean this literally? What if Intel's offerings beat ARM chips on, say, efficiency and price, or efficiency and performance... would you still believe ARM to be in a superior position?
- Raphael 14y agoThere will always be room for ARM if Intel doesn't compete on price.
- eupharis 14y agoShareholders will be very happy if Intel remains dominant at the high-margin, high-performance end. And competitive everywhere else. AMD has been competing with Intel on price for the past two decades. I know which of these two stocks I'd have rather owned over the past ten years: http://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdd=1&chds=1&chdv=1&chvs=maximized&chdeh=0&chfdeh=0&chdet=1356413832270&chddm=983365&chls=IntervalBasedLine&cmpto=NYSE:AMD&cmptdms=0&q=NASDAQ:INTC&ntsp=0&ei=WjvZUKiVOqajiAL83wE http://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdd=1&chds=1&... The data from this article is the first I've seen that indicates Intel could dominate the high-end mobile chip market in the near future.
- drivebyacct2 14y ago>Shareholders will be very happy if Intel remains dominant at the high-margin, high-performance end. And competitive everywhere else. Not with mobile trends and ARM uptake trends persisting. ARM speeds are getting more and more competitive. (I would argue, please forgive me, that signs are pointing towards Linux uptake. Intel's high-margins are on consumer processors as well, surely a large percentage of it. It will hurt as mobile continues to displace desktop and as desktop increasingly targets ARM.
- mtgx 14y ago> What if Intel's offerings beat ARM chips on, say, efficiency and price Very unlikely. First, because ARM already has chips that are much more efficient, like Cortex A7. Intel can't bring Atom to that level right now. It would take a few years, just like it took for Atom to get from 10W to 2W. By that time A7's successor would probably again be more powerful. I also doubt it will be cheaper. So far no indication that Intel has managed that compared to ARM - ever. >or efficiency and performance That may already exist, in the form of their high-end chips, and in terms of performance/Watt. But their prices are 10x bigger. So pretty irrelevant when it competes to competing with ARM in the same markets.
- ksec 14y agoAtom SoC NEVER cost close to $100. And it doesn't cost $40 now either. What you are talking about is the Desktop Atom. Which is different to Mobile / Tablet Costing. I dont think anyone should doubt Intel's Enginerring Power to bring Power and Performance Level unseen before to SoC market. The only problem is Margin and Price. Who these should work out are remain to be seen.
- tjoff 14y agoCheck out the Intels ULV processors. Intel haven't bothered to do anything with Atom because they don't want to cannibalize their own products. Long before Atom even came out a dualcore Core Duo ULV processor with a TDP of 5 was usually twice as fast as the Atom, if you disabled one of the cores on the Core Duo ... In other words about four times the performance at a much lower power consumption. I'm writing this on a 7 year old laptop sporting such a processor... Yes it is slow, but compared to an atom it the performance is just hysterical. The Atom is, and has always been, a pathetic joke in all regards except for price. And the performance is so abysmal that the only reason it ever sold was because of shortsithed consumers that can't look passed the price tag. Which of course took everyone by surprise, and intel obviously haven't dared to improve on Atom too much since it's launch for this very reason.
- Tuna-Fish 14y agoULV chips are just the lowest-power top bin of all normal cpus. To get chips that can be called ULV, Intel has to bin hundreds of non-ulv chips. As such, ULV chips can not be mass-produced in the kind of volumes needed for tablets.
- tjoff 14y agoMay be so, but I have hard time believing that you can find a worse comparison than Atom vs. ARM (in this context). It just isn't that simple.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>The problem is Intel has already lost on the performance side. Really? From TFA: """For us, the power advantage made a lot of sense. We've already proven that Intel's Atom core is faster than ARM's Cortex A9 (even four of them under Windows RT). Combine that with the fact that NVIDIA's Tegra 3 features four Cortex A9s on TSMC's 40nm G process and you get a recipe for worse battery life, all else being equal."""