4 ms·
My point is that their legal arguments in this case aren't limited to bulk importation, but are arguing that there exists no first-sale right at all for books t
by _delirium 14y ago
My point is that their legal arguments in this case aren't limited to bulk importation, but are arguing that there exists no first-sale right at all for books that didn't undergo that initial authorized domestic "first sale", regardless of why, e.g. whether it was one book imported by a tourist who bought it in France.
If their arguments applied solely to bulk parallel importation, that would be another matter. That's the "narrower" legislative fix that I proposed above: to ban the act of bulk commercial importation itself, rather than doing it in a roundabout way via resale restrictions.