4 ms·
Don't be so generous in your assumptions. Meta simply stole the username because they could, and gave the old owner nothing in return. Or if they were lucky, ma
by nvme0n1p1 2mo ago
Don't be so generous in your assumptions. Meta simply stole the username because they could, and gave the old owner nothing in return. Or if they were lucky, maybe the band got a few Meta branded t-shirts, as was the case for one of the other victims from the article.
Seriously, look at that list of all the times Meta stole people's handles. Why would this time be any different?
- blast 2mo agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49636930 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49636930
- usef- 2mo agoIf it happened across multiple platforms (of different owners) and the band themselves are not complaining, months after the rename, it seems quite likely. Note that if this was done against the band's will it would be fantastic publicity for them to say so. Everyone would be on their side. Meta probably reached out to them to remove any uncertainty around sharing the Muse trademark, and this was included in the deal. The band themselves didn't lose any followers, it was a rename. They might have asked for a clause not to talk about the deal.
- 00ze 2mo ago"The old owner" was $platform Read the TOS for these services ... you don't own anything stored on their servers
- Aurornis 2mo agoIncorrect. This happened across platforms including X.
- loeg 2mo agoI think GP is (correctly) claiming that you don't actually own your account handle on social media services, including X. But I don't think it was a particularly relevant response at that point in the comment thread, and I agree Meta likely bought the usernames from the band on the various platforms.
- Aurornis 2mo ago> Meta simply stole the username because they could, and gave the old owner nothing in return. The name changed happened across platforms including Twitter\X. Meta doesn’t own X. Is nobody reading the article? This comment section is crazy.
- brookst 2mo agoThis place has become Reddit with how easy it is to farm upvotes for any “evil corpos” take, no matter how clueless or inane.
- throw0101a 2mo ago> This place has become Reddit […] Not reading TFA (the fine article) has been a noble Internet tradition since (at least) the earliest days of Slashdot.
- underlipton 2mo agoThat's what happens when you abuse people's trust for years: they don't trust you.