3 ms·
Apple Watches have had an audio recorder app for years and no-one cares. Sometimes people are just looking for a reason to be offended. You'd be shocked what t
by LeoPanthera 2mo ago
Apple Watches have had an audio recorder app for years and no-one cares. Sometimes people are just looking for a reason to be offended.
You'd be shocked what the suite of sensors in the smartphone 99% of the population has in their pocket can do.
- mikeocool 2mo agoPeople have plenty of conversations where if one party intentionally chose to record it, it would be big violation of trust. This is basically just "always on" recording/transcribing that people have to intentionally remember to turn off, that's a pretty big difference.
- wang_li 2mo agoAnd a crime in plenty of states. It shouldn't be, but it is.
- shagie 2mo agoIt's a 15 second loop of audio history. If you didn't record the bit a minute ago, it's gone. A short buffer is common with wake word audio processing.
- mikeocool 2mo agoIt also summarizes your full conversations.
- nomel 2mo agoNo, that part requires intent, where you have to turn it on with the button. It was in the demo. Regardless, you'll be mortified if you search the app store for software or Amazon for hardware devices that do this! You can still pick up voice recorders at Staples, actually (I was surprised to see they still sell them, and they have weeks of recording time now, along with transcription software).
- e28eta 2mo agoOne of the options was always on, or always on while in work mode. I’m curious if the lack of speaker identification is a privacy thing, or a technical limitation. It looks like it uses PCC, so it may run into usage limits
- vineyardmike 2mo agoYou missed the additional feature launch where they listen to your entire life and give you transcriptions and summaries. “Siri Recap” https://support.apple.com/en-us/148354 https://support.apple.com/en-us/148354
- anamexis 2mo ago> Siri Recap runs only when you choose. You can turn on Siri Recap in the Watch app on iPhone. When you turn it on, you can set a schedule based on time and/or location (for example, "only at work" or "never at night"), or you can manually turn it on and off. Across all these options, you can always turn it on or off at any time from Control Center. > Siri Recap and Live Rewind help jog your memory, not provide a detailed record. Siri Recap doesn't produce a transcript. It generates a brief, high-level summary — comparable to notes you might jot down after a conversation. Live Rewind shows a text snippet of what was just said in the last 15 seconds, so you can catch something you missed.
- al_borland 2mo agoMy hope is it’s off by default and most people choose to keep it that way. This featuring is undoubtedly to compete with, and crush, all of those stand-alone AI wearables that do the same thing. All those products failed, because people either didn’t find it that useful, or the creep factor was too high. I could see some scenarios where it might be useful. Being at a conference, for example, and having a summary of everything I heard in the various presentations. But at the same time, it feels like the people being recorded should have knowledge of, and give consent to, the recording.
- gumby271 2mo agoWhat sucks is that if you've ever pushed back on the people that use those stupid AI recorders they'll insist they're not actually recording you, its just a transcript and summary, and somehow that's fine. I'm not looking forward to more people explaining that to me, especially hardcore Apple fans.
- al_borland 2mo agoYeah, I had this happen last time I went to the doctor… one of the last places I’d want it. At least with the Apple one they talked about how it works and it’s not some random product off Amazon doing god knows what. My dad is probably the most likely person in my life to use something like this. I could see him sending me the summary of our dinner conversation or something, which would be very weird and off-putting. He has been very concerned about his memory as he ages, so I could see him using something like this to help with age related memory issues.
- Grombobulous 2mo agoThe doctor is probably the best place for this technology so that you can actually talk to your doctor rather than your doctor half-paying attention while they try to input everything into their EMR system on the computer.
- JoeBOFH 2mo ago
- socalgal2 2mo agoIt's also a violation of law in some places. https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/penal-code/pen-sect-632/ https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/penal-code/pen-sect-632/
- rz2k 2mo agoI think they gave us enough information to understand their legal strategy. They will argue that the watch has sufficient processing power to transcribe the text in real time, and a plain text transcript is not a recording. It likely stretches the definitions compared to what most people who do not want to be recorded think the laws should prevent, but on the other hand at least it couldn’t be used as legal evidence. It sounds intended as a memory aid, where passing a transcript for gossip purposes will hopefully be met with automatic skepticism as something that isn’t authenticated in any way and could be made up entirely. They probably spent enormous amounts of time weighing how much legal jeopardy it would create for their customers.
- Barbing 2mo agoI can’t tell how California law treats e.g. hitting the little microphone icon on the iPhone with the notes app open (realtime live transcription w/no recording that I know of) versus the voice memo app (illegal without all-party consent, as it creates a recording). The world’s fastest smartphone typist can do what the mic icon does. In, say, court, “look I typed this” & “look this was dictated” would seem to be just as trustworthy since either can be edited after the fact. And someone could type and say it was transcribed, or transcribe and say it was typed. Whereas the law doesn’t want us voice recording and having the actual (forensically provable? w/the right budget?) record, unless everyone agreed.
- loumf 2mo agoContemporaneous notes are absolutely used in courts. That doesn't make these summaries illegal, but I can't see how they won't become evidence. They will be subject to discovery. The main argument against them being good evidence is if they are not accurate and the public (i.e. the jury) knows that.
- mort96 2mo agoIf I learned that someone I've been speaking to for a while was recording the conversation using the audio recorder app on their phone, I'd find that extremely creepy.
- deleted 2mo ago[deleted]
- tshaddox 2mo agoFair enough. But people here are expressing disdain at this new feature, which is not that.
- bhelkey 2mo agoThis is a new feature. It is an always on recording of conversation.
- eigen 2mo agofrom the video I thought the wearer had to enable it, just as today where the wearer has to enable the audio recorder app.
- mort96 2mo agoIn the video, the waitress said something, then the guy looked up on his watch what she said. Where's the part where he enables anything? Clearly it was already listening, otherwise it wouldn't have caught what she said.