4 ms·
Everyone said, "Bail out the banks and you risk turning into Japan." You bailed out the banks. Now you're turning into Japan. Mazal tov, America! You're com
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
Everyone said, "Bail out the banks and you risk turning into Japan."
You bailed out the banks. Now you're turning into Japan.
Mazal tov, America! You're committing national suicide!
- prostoalex 14y agoAssumption here being that US needs more younger people. Let's see a couple trends here though: 1) US life expectancy is on the rise, I guess one of the most expensive healthcare systems in the world is good for something. 2) Average retirement age is moving farther ahead - Reuters recently ran an article about startup founders who are 60+ y.o. http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/11/27/us-valley-ageism-idUSBRE8AQ0JK20121127 http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/11/27/us-valley-ageism-i... 3) Rise of robotics outsourced a good portion of typical physical jobs to machines - iRobot, Kiva Systems, Tesla's car-manufacturing robot arms 4) Youth unemployment is on the rise 5) Youth STEM skills, the only applicable skills that matter in current economic climate, are declining Why does the country need large amounts of young people again? A bunch of the assumptions - you need younger people to slave off to contribute taxes towards the retirement of the elderly - are a bit shaky to say the least. Most of the youth employed at various menial jobs are earning low enough income to qualify them for tax credits, so they're not a huge revenue source.
- anigbrowl 14y agoA bunch of the assumptions - you need younger people to slave off to contribute taxes towards the retirement of the elderly - are a bit shaky to say the least. The assumption that they will be able to supply that revenue is indeed shaky, but the assumption that one needs them to do so is well-founded. Traditionally immigration has been the safety valve for demographic mismatches, as ably documented here: http://www.ssab.gov/documents/immig_issue_brief_final_version_000.pdf http://www.ssab.gov/documents/immig_issue_brief_final_versio...
- sliverstorm 14y agoIt's less about having a class of youth, as having a group of people up-and-coming to replace the old guard.
- prostoalex 14y agoThis is true for agrarian societies where if you had 20 people of current generation working the land, you'd very likely need 20 or more in the next generation. Rise of automation and increase in average employment spans removes that urgency. Rise of health care standards slowly eradicates the image of a feeble senile 70-year-old who is threatening kids to get off his lawn and needs constant medical attention 24/7. You still need the next generation, but it doesn't have to be 1x-2x of the current one.
- varjag 14y ago> 3) Rise of robotics outsourced a good portion of typical physical jobs to machines - iRobot, Kiva Systems, Tesla's car-manufacturing robot arms This is really of no consequence. Do you know any janitor who lost a job to roomba? CNC have been there en mass since 1970s, and robotics since 1980s. A robotic assembly line is featured in final scene of Terminator (1984), and it was very much state of the art then. However, contrary to doomsday prophecies of the time, what replaced American jobs were not the soulless machines in Japan, but penniless workers in China. The future never seems to play out in the coolest sci-fi way.
- kristiandupont 14y agoIt might not have happened as quickly as predicted. That doesn't mean it's not happening at all. http://techcrunch.com/2012/11/13/foxconn-allegedly-replacing-human-workers-with-robots/ http://techcrunch.com/2012/11/13/foxconn-allegedly-replacing...
- prostoalex 14y agoIt's just the matter of cost. Soulless machines are just more expensive to design and slower to roll to market. Some of the technologies (like self-checkout registers at supermarkets) make no economic sense until a certain price point is reached.
- antidoh 14y agoInteresting question: is it cheaper to use a low-skill, uneducated workforce for low-skilled work, or a smaller but somewhat higher-skilled and educated workforce to maintain the mechanized workforce replacement machines, as well as the smaller set of workers to design and program the machines? It's usually easier to point a guy to a corner and tell him to sweep, than it is to program a machine to do it and to get politely out of the way when a customer walks by. Who pays for those higher skilled workers? Can you get enough of them?
- lotsofpulp 14y agoThere's a lot of overhead (liability, benefits, dealing with people) that's removed when using machines.
- 3825 14y agoIs this[1] the problem in Japan that you are talking about? Seems like the main idea is we had to find a way to get the banks to start lending again. The government can't open a shop and lend to small businesses themselves. What other option did we have other than to bail out the banks? Honest question. I don't know very much about these things. [1]: http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/bailout.html http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/bailout.html
- tsotha 14y agoThe bank bailout had nothing to do with anything. This is a longer term trend.
- jlgreco 14y agoIf we are discarding of a distinction between correlation and causation, the best way to increase birth rate is to plunge the public into crippling poverty.