9 ms·
Cherry Is Shutting Down Its On-Demand Car Wash Service
- joshfraser 14y agoLately I've noticed an increase in companies that are trying to deal with the real world, instead of selling software strictly as a virtual good. TaskRabbit, YourMechanic, Uber, Instacart, Cherry - I love all of them. But dealing with the logistics of a physical world is really really tough. I don't envy any of them. Cherry was a great idea, but a tough one to pull off. Good luck to the Cherry guys in whatever they do next.
- nirvdrum 14y agoPardon my ignorance, but what made this a great idea? I'm not overly familiar with the company, but it seems like yet another "instead of going to place X to have service Y, X will come to you." It doesn't strike me as entirely novel. And most businesses following that pattern sputter out because they're just not scalable or there's little demand. $5.25 MM seems like an awful lot of money for something with seemingly few exit opportunities. So I assume there's something I'm missing here.
- joshfraser 14y agoI called it a great idea because it's actually something I could see myself using. My time is my most valuable asset and so I love the idea of having my car washed in my driveway instead of driving somewhere and waiting around. But as I learned with my last company, a good idea doesn't mean that it will be a good business. It's a rough business for the all reasons listed above. And yes, it's a shame they weren't able to figure that out on 500k instead of 5m.
- absconditus 14y agoHome car detailing businesses are already successful. Basic car washes are only profitable when done at a facility designed to make them as cheap as possible. I cannot see trying to make something more convenient that takes a few minutes and can often be done at the same place where one fuels their vehicle.
- orangethirty 14y agoWhy would they need $500K to figure it out? Honestly, why? I did it with $600 (no zeroes missing). I dont get how people just throw around huge amounts of money like it was nothing. 500K is a huge amount of money and it should be put to work towards building wealth and not towards speculating on bad business models. And see, you just said something very important. You see yourself using them. But tell me, who washes your car right now? How much do you pay them? How come you don't have one of the local on-site car wash businesses come by and work on your car?
- prostoalex 14y agoProbably marketing. You need to buy your initial leads to get the business going.
- orangethirty 14y agoNot marketing. Definitely not marketing. I spent $50 on marketing and it got me about $3k worth of business on the first two weeks. Just some flyers and self-printed business cards.
- prostoalex 14y agoOk, so you had 1 subcontractor (yourself). I don't know Cherry's deal, but doesn't seem unreasonable to say that they were shooting for a 1,000. Or 10,000. In geographically dispersed areas. You can see how it can start adding up.
- orangethirty 14y agoI never said I was the only one washing cars. I had sub-contractors that I paid on a per-car basis. Scaling an on-site car wash to 1,000 or 10,000 sub contractors is not going to happen. And here is why: Too many problems will arise. Insurance claims, theft, etc. will quickly make them raise the price to keep a healthy profit margin. Problem is, once you pass a certain price point, people will simply not buy. Thus you end up scaling for nothing. On site car washing is one of those businesses that just doesn't scale favorably.
- artag 14y agoJosh - they did their series A 7 months ago. They had raised ~ $1m for seed. I am guessing they didn't burn more than $1.5-$2m to fully scale one market and test what the unit economics look like at a small scale. Since they probably had $3.5-$4m in the bank and they chose not to scale to a few more markets, my guess is that either they really found a much better business opportunity, or they discovered that even at scale retention rate/LTV was low.
- biot 14y agoWebvan was a great idea too... if you were the consumer. Not such a great idea to run that money pit of a business.
- orangethirty 14y agoCherry was not a great idea. Had they done some research (well, the people who gave them 5.25 million dollars to waste away), they would have learned some very simple things. Disclaimer: I used to own and operate (as in also wash cars) a successful on-site car wash business. Closed it down because it was a pain in the ass to run. On-site car washing (or any other type of on-site auto service (YourMechanic guys should pay attention)) is very low on margins, and competition is tough. You have to compete with every 13 year old kid who wants to buy a new playstation game and will wash cars for $5. You will also have to compete with every other joe who will basically wash a car for a couple of bucks. So creating a solid customer list is tough. There are also logistics issues. Getting a group of car washers who are not complete and total fuckheads is impossible (I'd say its easier to win the lottery twice). Cherry tried to circumvent that by having sub-contractors, which in other words means giving some random joe $5 to wash some car. They only provided them with some basic equipment. If you have ever washed a car in the cold, you know that you need more than a fucking soap sprayer and a sponge. There is a lot of equipment needed to correctly wash a car in diverse weather conditions. Sub-contractors did not buy equipment because they were being paid shit. So, getting good employees is impossible, getting good sub-contractors is like finding out you have a rich uncle who died and left you money and that suddenly, every hot celebrity out there is hot for you. There is also the issue that people dont give a shit about cancelling an appointment 30 seconds before it is due. That plus rain, shady owners trying to blame you for "missing stuff", and people who smoke. Its just a shitty business to be in. The only people who manage to do something in that market are the professional detailers. Those guys do make some good money, but have to spend a shitload of time on a single customer, and cannot (in most cases) reliably duplicate their business in order to have any horizontal growth. The high end market is also very competitive and customer loyalty is very high. No Porsche owner will have some unknown detail his baby in order to save $50. Also, I so called this. This is one of those "investments" that makes you go "huh?". Edit: And here I was feeling bummed about wasting $600 on car washing equipment. 5.25 million bucks! Hell, give me $500k and I'll make Nuuton so awesome that people will say "Google? What is that?" :)
- tptacek 14y agoThe tone will turn some people off, but this is I think a really good comment, full of details about a specific business based on experience. Also, coming from consulting, I think I agree with you on the dynamics of subcontracting. People are going to think you're being hyperbolic, but a reliable stable of 1099 subcontractors you can bill out over cost is, fundamentally, free money. Consulting firms know this because staffing a consultancy involves accepting the sales-side risk and paying your team rain or shine. I get a little irritated every time I hear someone brag about a real-world business based on 1099 contractors working on a fixed schedule.
- frozenport 14y agoWhen I was 11 my neighbor paid me $7 to wash his car. Is this what Cherry was about?
- ryangilbert 14y agoI'm guessing their system will be in stores for the casual person to buy and to it themselves soon.
- tyrelb 14y agoI'm sure they didn't spend all the $5.25m on this business idea - and likely have lots left. I wonder how they came to the decision to shut it down and pivot - I think that's they key here that's missing...
- pebb 14y agoC'mon people! Let's give these guys a break. They had a vision for something great and they tried their best to make it happen. Not every business succeeds, in fact almost many fail. They had the guts, the vision and the nerve to be great.
- rhizome 14y agoYou should be commended for your backbreaking charity move there, but I'm not sure there was anything "great" about Cherry's goal. Was it really anything more than building a better lemonade stand?
- aheilbut 14y agoThey're going to pivot to an on-demand shoe shine service.
- ithcy2 14y agohttp://www.theonion.com/articles/bankrupt-dotcom-proud-to-have-briefly-changed-the,3686/ http://www.theonion.com/articles/bankrupt-dotcom-proud-to-ha...
- lotsofpulp 14y agoThe funny thing about that is that many of my friends and I would probably buy a cheese grater from Amazon.
- bifftannen 14y agoWhat really makes Cherry that special that it needed or received funding? There have been mobile detail services for years already. Was it the "startup" label? Plus, we really don't need more wasteful services. No way to collect and recycle the waste water for example. Car washes are just ugly wastes of a resource we don't have enough of.
- janejane 14y ago"No way to collect and recycle the waste water for example." - yeah, but there was no waste water from the wash. Cherry used a waterless carwash solution that actually worked pretty well. My husband was working for Cherry as a second job 3 days a week, and we're really sad to see it go. The money and hours were decent, and he thought it was better than being stuck in a coffee shop or something like that for a second job. He was solidly booked with customers on the days he worked, so I don't think Cherry folded for lack of customers. I also want to point out that not all Cherry car washers were social rejects who had no others options for work except for menial labor... my husband is college educated, we just needed some extra cash. I think the real crime here, which no one has brought up, is that Cherry gave ZERO notice to the washers that it was going to fold up yesterday. We got an email last night that it was over effective immediately. I'm glad it wasn't our only source of income, but even a weeks notice to get things sorted out would have been nice. FU Cherry!
- 2pasc 14y agoI agree that providing no notice was not great. How did your husband find out about Cherry and applied for this job?
- 2pasc 14y agoThe Cherry team comes from a pretty cool background with lots of ex-Yammer people. Plus demand was strong... So demand + strong team in a frothy market = why not give them $5.5M to see if there is something real there.
- gregpilling 14y agoDisclaimer: I have been in the automotive business for 23 years, not the tech business. I have to agree with @orangethirty comments on this page. There is not enough margin in the auto service business to let this succeed. I have known people that washed cars professionally in both small high-end detail shops and full-size car wash operations. The high volume car washes are staffed largely with people that could not get better jobs - felons, drug abusers, those with no education or other job skills. The small high end detailers were generally guys that loved cars and found happiness in polishing a Porsche for an afternoon. There was an old guy named Al that used to come by my office and spend an hour on my truck for $30. I don't know where he went, but I miss the service. You do the math on what his income was per year if he had to travel, pay for soap and supplies, and then only grossed $30 per hour. My math estimates that he couldn't be netting more than $25,000 per year. YourMechanic will also hit this same problem. They promise 30% savings and at-your-door service. This will run into the same issues. There is not 30% margin to cut at any small auto repair shop that I have ever dealt with. For those keeping track, I sold equipment to 200 auto repair shops over a ten year period. There are many car repair problems that are not fixable in the field. The bigger problem is that auto mechanics have the same rockstar ninja aspects as software. The rockstars simply will not be doing brakes in the rain, outside of your work in the parking lot. Why would they? They can earn $100K a year at a dealer, there is no way they are going to earn less in your parking lot. In worse conditions. In the rain. Ask the question in a different way. Would you prefer to work in a heated/cooled work environment with restrooms nearby, a break room, a place to wash your hands, specialized tools and equipment nearby, support staff to get your parts, queue up the next job, a counter guy to deal with the customer OR----- would you like to work in the rain, deal with angry customers, no restroom, not enough tools or equipment with you, doing jobs that become much harder because of location, etc etc all for 30% less money? You will not get any talented person to work for you. They have better options. Auto repair is very talent driven, especially any area that is hard like diagnostics, transmissions, or solving the problem that the last 3 shops couldn't figure out. You wouldn't expect to produce good code in a parking lot, would you? And then there is the classic problem of auto repair. Once you touch the car, the customer finds all sorts of things that YOU apparently did even though you didn't. Scratches, dents, missing items, the list is long and familiar to all.
- 14y ago
- hnriot 14y agoDumb idea, but that's the beauty of the free market, if you can talk an investor into giving their money then good luck to them. On the specifics of this idea, I wouldn't trust anyone in the carwash business because of the horror stories about it being the last resort fro felons, druggies etc. Do you really want those people going through your glovebox?