7 ms·
Are you sure about that? I understood it to be ruling that disallows you from buying abroad and importing. So if they moved production to Mexico, but then they
by MichaelGG 14y ago
Are you sure about that? I understood it to be ruling that disallows you from buying abroad and importing. So if they moved production to Mexico, but then they imported and sold it to you, it would not matter - you'd still have first sale. What you couldn't do is buy it in Mexico and bring it in yourself and sell it.
I'm against any erosion of first sale and believe all "grey market" stuff should be legal. Companies should find other ways to differentiate products rather than the meatspace equivalent of "region locks".
But let's be honest: this case isn't suddenly going to destroy first sale _within the US_.
- anigbrowl 14y agoRegion locks are not desired by copyright holders, but by the distributors in those regions who want exclusivity within their retail territory. Suppose you make a product and discover that someone in, say, Indonesia is faking and selling a counterfeit version. Are you equipped to sue them? Probably not unless you're a large global firm, so it makes more sense for you to sell your product through a distributor in that territory. Likewise, pricing is different because incomes and economies are different. You charge the price the market will bear in each territory. None of this prevents individuals from buying something for themselves overseas and taking it home to use. But it does prevent bulk importation, which parties to a distribution agreement are contractually required to combat.
- knightni 14y agoRegion locks are desired by copyright holders too, as it makes it easier to maximise incomes per region based on their ability to pay.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWell yes, that's why you enter into a distribution agreement with a wholesaler in that market if you can rather than sitting back and letting your stuff be republished for nothing.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>I understood it to be ruling that disallows you from buying abroad and importing. So if they moved production to Mexico, but then they imported and sold it to you, it would not matter - you'd still have first sale. The key word in that sentence is "they" -- who is "they"? Here's the problem: The copyright holder manufactures the product abroad and sells it abroad to a nominally unaffiliated distributor who then imports it into the United States. In theory the distributor is doing what would not be allowed -- importing the foreign product without a license -- but the copyright holder gets to decide whether or not to sue them. And they don't sue them, this one unofficial distributor with whom they have an unspoken agreement. They only sue you when you go to resell the used product, claiming it was never sold by the copyright holder in the United States. Maybe you could make some claim that the distributor had a de facto license based on the fact that the copyright holder implicitly allowed the importing to continue, but good luck proving it when they claim it was unsanctioned (and meanwhile they have a token official U.S. reseller with near-zero sales volume who sells at 5X the price, and a list of other unsanctioned importers who they've sued to shut down).
- schoen 14y agoYou should have a look at the gap between the Ninth Circuit's holding in Omega v. CostCo and the Second Circuit's holding here. :-) In footnote 44, the Second Circuit agrees that its own "decision may allow a copyright holder to completely control the resale of its product in the United States by producing its goods abroad and then immediately importing them for initial distribution" but says that this "does not affect or alter our interpretation of the Copyright Act".