4 ms·
This has got to be one of the dumbest fucking things I've ever seen. Its only real point is that commodity-based currencies and deflations weaken government.
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
This has got to be one of the dumbest fucking things I've ever seen. Its only real point is that commodity-based currencies and deflations weaken government.
Furthermore, its idiotic praise of societal-level saving is pure nonsense. My income is someone else's expenditure, my credit is someone else's debt. Money can obscure this fact, not alter it. In order for me to save, someone else must spend.
Do they have to spend beyond their means and go into debt or reduce their own savings for me to save? Well, that's where the issue of money comes in.
If we have a standard-issue modern currency, ie: slow but steady rate of inflation targeted by a central bank, then some amount of new money enters the economy each year. As long as total new savings in the year don't exceed this amount, then and only then can everyone save at the same time.
In a gold-backed inherently-deflationary currency without fractional reserve banking or government fiat to create inflation.... all savings is zero-sum. Such a currency is indeed inherently deflationary, and the deflation spirals as those who can actually afford to save come to own larger and larger portions of the total bullion supply -- which they are of course saving!
You end up with only one way to put aggregate demand back into the system: credit. Which is exactly what has happened to our real societies in the past three decades of anti-inflationary, anti-labor public policies! Problem is, that makes the deflation truly become a crisis, because even a 2% annual deflation is in fact an extra 2% interest compounding on any and all nominal debts.
Deflation is bad for the same reason inflation is bad, namely that an unexpected change in currency value alters the real terms of almost all business contracts ex post facto. But deflation is also distinctly bad for another reason: once it kicks in, there is no incentive for net creditors/savers to engage in any real production of anything. Their biggest incentive becomes the generation and continuation of nominal debts (whose real value accumulates a deflation bonus). Worse, as the deflation happens and alters contracts ex-post-facto, people's debts become unpayable. So now the creditors go bankrupt too, and the only people left safe are the savers who literally stored physical bullion in a physical location. Anyone with so much as a bank account finds out they were actually a creditor, and are now completely fucked.
Deflation is a wet dream of survivalist "gold, beans, and ammo" nutters, and the world's worst preventable nightmare for everyone else!
- kiba 14y agoAnd who will survive if nobody produces anything for anybody to consume or horde? Imagine that the farmers of the world decided not to produce anything for us to eat and instead only horde stuff.
- josephlord 14y agoPeople would spend for food but save as much money as possible making the economy contract with demand in a depression. Hopefully the government would turn on the printing presses and step in as spender of last resort before the food ran out.
- jerguismi 14y agoPeople probably wouldn't do anything else than just buy that food, and wait for the world to end? LOL
- josephlord 14y agoOversimplified. This is an HN comment not a Economics paper. Discretionary spending reduced, borrowing falling leads to deflationary cycle with shrinking economy unless action is taken. I thought it would be obvious I didn't mean absolutely all spending will stop.
- josephlord 14y agoUp voted. Would add that in a deflationary environment no one will want credit so really you have to print money and give it away (or just print it and spend it).
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoOr you'll have to allow some form of fiat currency as an alternative currency. Or you'll have to more-or-less allow the entire real economy to collapse as the exponentially dropping remnants of actual aggregate demand become utterly unable to facilitate, or rather justify, real trade. One last point: deflation always favors whoever, in a transaction, is the creditor/seller. In a certain sense, this is not only economically harmful but morally unfair. After all, if I pay a contractor $150k to build me a house (assume I own the land and we're only paying for construction), what I'm really doing, underneath the illusion of money, is trading my skills and property (program code, raw building materials) for his skills and property (architecture, construction, use of his materials and tools). In theory, this can and should be modeled as a spot-trade of my stuff for his stuff with no unwanted side-effects. But once we get money and its time-value (deeply affected by deflation) involved, then one of us has an automatic advantage over the other based on the currency value when the work is done and when the payment is made. If the currency is deflating, even predictably, then whoever gets paid has an automatic advantage over whoever does the paying. An arbitrage opportunity across time has appeared solely because we involved currency.