5 ms·
GamersNexus and LG: Or why rooting your TV is a bad idea
- badsectoracula 2mo ago> If he can demonstrate someone remotely jailbreaking your TV, or flipping on those settings without you knowing or doing anything to your TV, that would be a far more damning issue, in my view. Do you actually want a channel with 2.66 million subscribers to show how to get remote access to TVs used by millions of people? :-P
- Krutonium 2mo agoI'm pretty sure they DID mention that they can remotely flip settings. So that's a thing for sure.
- jaimex2 2mo agoThat would be against Youtubes terms, the video would get pulled.
- Arcuru 2mo agodemonstrate != explain?
- supriyo-biswas 2mo agoThey do show using https://github.com/raws0kil/jsbro-autoroot https://github.com/raws0kil/jsbro-autoroot to get root access. For anyone interested, that pointer is enough, I guess.
- m4rtink 2mo agoYeah, why not ? LG should make their stuff secure (by not shipping bloat and spyware), so it is on them.
- bob1029 2mo ago> What am I meant to take away from this? If you look at other IoT devices, they’re going to show the same thing. But here it’s presented as bad. Why? The influencer economy is a bit soaked these days. You need to crank up the stakes to keep the viewer's attention.
- Retr0id 2mo ago> If you root or jailbreak your devices, you've, by their very nature, broken their security. > If he can demonstrate someone remotely jailbreaking your TV, or flipping on those settings without you knowing or doing anything to your TV, that would be a far more damning issue, in my view. There are ways to remotely jailbreak LG webOS TVs without user interaction, using the same (or similar) vulnerabilities you use to root your own TV voluntarily. The main reason tools like https://rootmy.tv https://rootmy.tv are prefixed with disclaimers and require user interaction is because we're being courteous, not because they're technically necessary. (source: I own the rootmy.tv domain)
- froddd 2mo agoMost of what I’m reading on rootmy.tv says the vulnerability it exploits has been fixed. So, if one were to keep software up to date on their TV, there is an improbably small chance it can actually be remotely jailbroken — am I reading this right?
- Retr0id 2mo agoThe specific vulnerabilities exploited by rootmy.tv have been patched, yes, but there are plenty more unpatched vulnerabilities remaining. There are also more up-to-date rooting tools beyond rootmy.tv. The security posture of webOS is absolutely terrible, at least, it is in the way LG deploys it.
- rickdeckard 2mo ago> The specific vulnerabilities exploited by rootmy.tv have been patched, yes, but there are plenty more unpatched vulnerabilities remaining. But vulnerabilities that can be remotely exploited without user interaction (CVSS grade 9-10)?
- Retr0id 2mo agoYup. I'm sitting on one that doesn't even require an internet connection, only RF down the TV antenna input. I'm waiting for my model to go EOL before I release it.
- rickdeckard 2mo agoThanks for the write-up, it reflects my own impression of the video. The video is quite a mixed set of topics mangled together, which is a pity because IMO a cleaner separation would be more beneficial to get the point across. They should have decided to set the focus on a specific area and then present every finding around that, i.e.: 1. The Ad data-collecting platform TV-manufacturers are operating, what data they collect and how they use it. 2. The vulnerabilities of the OS in a SmartTV, and the potential issues to exploit them for malicious purposes. 3. The general behavior of the device when connected to your network, with features like voice control, App control, Smart Home etc. enabled, and how it may expose information about yourself. All the points and scenarios in the video might be valid, but they jump between those scopes and imply that its all the same, weakening the whole investigation. If I'm LG and forced to respond to this, I can easily focus on dissecting the voice-input topic as a mere demonstration of the feature and how rooting the TV beforehand just showed the local process of handling it, steering the narrative away from the (IMO) much more important topics...
- jeffbee 2mo agoYeah if GN wants to keep my attention on this topic they need to edit out all the stuff about normal Wi-Fi stack behaviors and normal local device discovery behaviors. They didn't need to pad their feature-length video with these non-issues.
- rickdeckard 2mo agoAnd how they asked the device for voice-input for a websearch via the UI, and the device proceeded to perform voice transcription, filling the searchbox with everything that was said...
- rcxdude 2mo agoThey are pretty infamously overly verbose.
- bakugo 2mo agoGN has sadly been trending towards overly long, rambly clickbait videos in recent years, in line with the rest of Youtube. Most of their videos could easily convey the same information with a third of the length. It's unfortunate, because they're one of the few voices speaking out about issues like this.
- LoganDark 2mo agoThey rooted the TV to study it. They're not saying you're in sudden danger of attackers rooting your TV and running commands over SSH. They're saying there's evidence that certain data is collected when you wouldn't want it to be, and there are any number of potential vulnerabilities that could provide hackers access, on top of LG potentially having access as well which you also probably wouldn't want.
- p0lychromatic 2mo agoThey still run the audio recording manually through SSH and then claim that your TV is spying on your private conversations "silently". Otherwise, they start a voice command service (clearly displayed on the screen) and then say your TV is recording on your conversation. Like duh, of course my TV starts recording voice when I use voice commands. And of course you have to trust LG with their TV and (not) having access. That same logic applies to every different company.
- headsman771 2mo agoI don't think you paid very close attention. They clearly showed it transcribing audio when the TV was "switched off". And they weren't "running audio recording through SSH", SSH was just incidental to watch the audio recording and transcription that was happening.
- fulafel 2mo agoSeems incoherent. What exactly is the bad idea and why? Are they rediscovering "don't run stuff needlessly as root"?
- p0lychromatic 2mo agoThe bad idea is that by rooting, you can (of course) turn your device into a 24/7 surveillance device that sends voice and video data everywhere. That does not mean that LG does all that by default.
- nokeya 2mo agoBecause of course it does. You are fighting the wrong side, they should proof they are good, not you defend them.
- m4rtink 2mo agoYeah, it is insane a fully open source firmware with reproducible builds is not a minimum standard for something as sensitive as a modern smart TV.
- p0lychromatic 2mo agoIt is not the minimum standard for computers. Why should it be for TVs?
- m4rtink 2mo agoIt should be the minimum standard everywhere.
- t_mahmood 2mo agoYou're just jumping around a single point about rooting, whereas the video shows it's logging all the devices, with their ip, name, even detecting someone being in a Teams call. And you are as with the article, trying to sidetrack all of it by focusing on rooting.
- ChrisArchitect 2mo agoRelated: 216M Spy TVs – The LG Smart TV Problem [video] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49592375 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49592375
- lovich 2mo ago> Now, what he’s showing can be pretty scary. I wouldn’t want any attacker to be able to record me without knowing. But it’s important to remember the context here: earlier in the video, Wendell rooted the TV. He has full access to everything on it. To run those commands and programs, he had to log into WebOS via SSH and run them on the device. He didn't show remoting calling those commands, nor was this done on an unmodified device. > If you root or jailbreak your devices, you've, by their very nature, broken their security. If he can demonstrate someone remotely jailbreaking your TV, or flipping on those settings without you knowing or doing anything to your TV, that would be a far more damning issue, in my view. What is this authors point? LG doesn’t need a root exploit to get this info because they made the fucking thing. I read the article and then grepped for “Texas” to see if I missed it. The author never mentions the fact that this data collection was only found out initially because of a Texas government lawsuit that LG settled on by agreeing to give “informed consent” to users about data collection and then the warnings started popping up in unexpected places. Is the author arguing that jailbreaking your device to find out what the manufacturer can do to gather data on you is dangerous because I don’t know, questioning your corporate overlords is bad or something?
- p0lychromatic 2mo agoSome attacks shown on the video (like the "silent" voice recording) are initiated by the people in the video manually running those commands via SSH. This is the major issue with this video: It mixes stuff done by LG (ACR) with stuff done via rooting (audio recording). And now people think LG is 24/7 recording your conversations and uploading them somewhere. This has not been proven.
- newsclues 2mo agoFresh account defending a corporation.
- p0lychromatic 2mo ago1. Ad hominem. 2. No, LG is not perfect here and their TVs are bloated as fuck and they do questionable things privacy-wise. However, that still does not mean that they listen on every conversation, as shown in the video. That nuance is important if you value good journalism. Otherwise if we're just our here throwing random allegations because "corp bad", might as well say LG 's TVs are turning the frickin' frogs gay.
- taylorfinley 2mo agoThis reads like a PR crisis management firm planted article. it probably isn't, but it reads like one. It muddies the waters with vague implications and suggests we cannot infer anything from encrypted packets. If your screen is showing content sourced over HDMI and the packets are heading to the ACR endpoint, I think it's safe to infer HDMI is being ACR'd.
- adithyassekhar 2mo agoI think the author took the wrong message from the video. His arguments are all - yes everyone does this not just lg; :) - yes it can be used to track the user; but unless you literally go into lg ads hq, you can’t say they don’t - they rooted to trigger this; well the os and system apps don’t need root, we need it to observe. If the author is here please consider these as the reasons to why an LG customer would be mad. - They did not knew LG has an ads subsidiary, whose CEOs and executives constantly go on investor meetings claiming “they own the glass”, “they own the living room”, “they own the network and devices” in the “lg household” - if the above was said by lg tv division it would have still stung less. This was said by an ad company they didn’t knew existed nor did they agree to be associated with when they bought a home appliance. Stop focusing on the technical details, look at the larger picture.
- rickdeckard 2mo agoI agree with the author, the point is that the way the video and the overall research was done, the entire message was diluted too much. There is substance in what they did. But they should have worked with an actual journalist to frame this properly and create pressure on the overarching topics. If a TV company (LG or ANY of the others who have Ad-subsidiaries) needs to respond to this video, they can easily reframe the whole topic. The most blatant example is that they demonstrate in the video that this TV, which has a built-in microphone for voice-control, that can be switched off with a mechanical switch: 1. Will record your voice when you ask it to transcribe your input to a textbox 2. Will process your voice to create this text it shows, as visible on the logs of the rooted OS 3. Will SHOW you that it's transcribing your input on the screen. This is weakening the whole story. -- In HN-terms: It's a constant-power, constantly-connected IoT-device with lots of sensors and huge compute-power, located in the center of your home. There are big topics around this that deserve a huge spotlight, which apply to ALL TV manufacturers: a. What data is actually being collected about the user, and what is done with this data? b. How well is security handled on the TV to ensure no malicious usage? Repeatedly jumping to the conclusion during the video that LG specifically is collecting ALL this local data to spy on you, without clear evidence, this just gives LG an easy way to respond and every other vendor enough room to distance themselves from the whole story.
- pmlnr 2mo ago> If you root or jailbreak your devices, you've, by their very nature, broken their security. Wow. Please stop spreading things like this. Not having root means not owning a device you paid for and have in your home.
- p0lychromatic 2mo agoI know people here do not want to hear it, but it is a very two-sided sword. Of course root allows you to tinker with your device and make it run what you want, but: - Rooted devices make devices unpredictable. As shown in the video: How do you trust that your hotel/AirBnB is not using root on _their_ TV to use its microphone to spy on you? Or actually records your video output (instead of "just" ACRing it)? - Re-selling: How do you know that TV you bought is untampered? How do you know it does not have software with malware installed that steals your credentials?
- armadyl 2mo agoHonestly in a lot of cases people here are too ideologically blinded to see the logic that you’re laying out. It’s the same mental gymnastics that let many here praise something like GrapheneOS yet turn around and screech over it not allowing root which is nearly central to its entire security architecture. But in this case… I don’t know. The OEM is so actively hostile you might be better off just taking the risk with root if you must purchase it at all (and physically removing the radio/microphone hardware not being an option).
- mort96 2mo agoWait who are these people who praise GrapheneOS but complain about it not allowing root? It sounds like you're conflating two groups of people
- armadyl 2mo agoNo, go to any large GrapheneOS post on here and you’ll inevitably see comments asking why they can’t have root and why it needs to be so strict, why can’t they have everything with the feature set of GOS + root. I’m sure in my comment history I’ve argued with people here over this.
- rbanffy 2mo agoNow I want to build a cluster of rooted WebOS TVs. I always say any serious computer needs blinkenlights and a smart TV has literally millions of them.
- nalekberov 2mo agoAnyone who uses GenAI for content creation, isn't worth my time. My rationale is simple: If I wanted to, I could have asked "AI" to generate that content for me, when I am spending my time consuming your content, I expect to get something unique.
- hypfer 2mo agoSemi-OT, possibly interesting: Maintaining enemy lists like the one of Drew linked there has been illegal in Germany since 2021 as part of the government's (very necessary!) efforts against hate crimes and right-wing extremism. Or at least that's my understanding of the law there. Maybe it's exempt based on technicalities. In any case, I can in many cases emotionally relate to why he is doing that, but.. oof.
- wewewedxfgdf 2mo agoI'll save you the time and effort trying to work out the point being made: GamersNexus did an investigation which may overstate the privacy threat posed by LG smart TVs.
- hdgvhicv 2mo agoWell as I do like saving time I’m certainly it going to watch an hours long video about someone installing their own software on a computer and doing things with it. If they had shown what a normal LG collects that would be fine. If they rooted it to install a new root certificate so they can MITM traffic and see what’s actually been sent that would be interesting. From what I read it’s “you can use a Turing complete computer with network and microphone access to do things”. I mean sure. What I want to know is what does it actually do I would love smart TVs to have a “no smart functions” option, and I know that they don’t because that’s part of the ad tech economy so beloved by HN. What I want to see is what does it actually do and perhaps how can it be blocked technically. Maybe it’s in the video, but videos are terrible ways to communicate this, and it seems to be mainly breathless nonsense and possibilities.
- Havoc 2mo agoI’m convinced the only thing saving us from hardware manufacturers security incompetence is NAT
- pid0x17 2mo agoI am still somewhat new to networking concepts (currently reading Computer Networking: A Top Down Approach by Kurose & Ross), and as far as I understood, most IPv6 networks don't have a NAT, or did I misunderstand? If that is the case, that means homes using IPv6 have globally routable IP addresses for their connected devices, right? Would the router's firewall protect it if it denies incoming connections?
- liveoneggs 2mo agoYeah you just need to remember to login to your totally-not-corrupt ISP's definitely-easy-to-use firewall manager app and setup your firewall rules to prevent hostile governments from using your microwave as a passive listening device, which they sell back to your own government for probable cause, to arrest you for cooking the wrong brand of popcorn.
- mococa 2mo agoReading this, I do not have a LG TV, but I have 3 LG AC connected to WiFi… Ouch
- cassianoleal 2mo agoSo, why is it a bad idea?
- laylower 2mo agoWhy is this a post even? What is it that the author is trying to say or take a view on? They literally write "Now, I’m not going to claim to be a network expert. I may be totally off-base, but what? Reverse DNS? I don't know what this means." The findings are a smoking gun already. The bar shouldn't be a video of an NSA agent or someone from LG listening your everyday life. I don't doubt this happens but we shouldn't expect gamernexus to be able to prove it. Jesus some people with their whataboutism and nihilism.
- VCFundedGenYer 2mo ago> If you root or jailbreak your devices, you've, by their very nature, broken their security. Yeah no this is just incorrect. There's many cases where jailbreaking actually fixes issues when a vendor abandons the platform. It also enables usefulness for a product long after it's been EOL'd.
- hoherd 2mo agoIn the current season of LLM driven security research, this is even more important. There are a LOT of EOL devices sitting there unpatched, vulnerable to the growing number of vulnerabilities. We can either stick our heads in the sand, we can demand the ability to update the vulnerable software on the hardware we bought, or we can exploit the CVE ourselves (collectively, as a community) and introduce CFW for the vulnerable devices. The main thing I'm taking away from this LG thing is that I'm going to root my TV as quickly as I can with whatever CFW will get rid of this surveillance capitalism atrocity attached to the wall in my family room.