3 ms·
I think that may be a hint that he's blaming the wrong things: it's pretty strange to blame the U.S.'s social-welfare system for the country's disparities, when
by _delirium 14y ago
I think that may be a hint that he's blaming the wrong things: it's pretty strange to blame the U.S.'s social-welfare system for the country's disparities, when the U.S.'s social-welfare system is so stingy. Social Security is not why the older generation has so much more money, because it's pretty impossible to get rich off a social-security check in the first place (I know elderly who live off social security, and they live at a subsistence level). The well-off older people with huge retirement accounts got them from the private sector and the stock market.
What's changed is that the '60s-'90s economic/employment situation is probably not going to repeat itself. My dad had basically a guaranteed-for-life job once he got a college degree, and a generous defined-benefit corporate pension, neither of which really exist anymore. And if you didn't go that route, you could apprentice in a skilled trade and also have a good middle-class job.
- 001sky 14y agoThe most ossified countries are the ones with the most expensive real-estate (places like urban italy, japan) where the birth rate collapses because the young cant afford to raise/support urban families. The US is now entereing that phase. The older generations are grandfathered (excuse the pun) into cheaper asset bases (10x incrrease in housing pricing in 40 years, etc) so even if they are not making $$ income they are controlling the much of the critial assets. Gen Yxz etx are just increaing their asset values (through externalities) by being young and hip and beautiful and in the neighborhood. That kind of think. On the other hand, the income streams of the younger generatonis look much more like annuity than perpetuity. Iven if you make nice earning for a couple of years, housing/college debt is predicated on 30-50 years of consistent earnings. The consistency of any person X earnings today is pretty unlikely to persist. Even a successful person can be made obsolete in a 5 yrs timespan (say--company is sold, market changes, etc). This is thus leading to entirely odd outcomes as there is a mis-match of earnings/liabilities for personal balance sheets for teh yound. ie, moving jobs/et vs massive debt it takes to run housefold/pay for future kids school, etc. Its also an equity problem for texes. one or two good years get taxed and two or three lean years later, you lost a bit chunk of earnings to takes. if you had smooth earnings, you would pay lower taxs, etc. whereas the older generation is sitting on tax-free capital gain on housing, so low income/low taxed, yet they are conrolling massive asset value. This system is what killed japan culturally. zero percent interest rates will do that to you. so the future looks bright if you think the lottery style outcome is a good one to play, but on average it is losing bet except for those selling tickets.
- jf271 14y agoJust look at the US tax code to figure out why most of the money in the hands of old white people. The tax benefits of IRA/401K accounts really favor people who have the guts to cut back on consumption and save over the years.That is all money that didn't get spent. Some say it increased the savings rate but did the increased savings really help the country?