5 ms·
FBI Documents Reveal Secret Nationwide Occupy Monitoring
- nakedrobot2 14y agoHow much power do these scary bureaucratic agencies FBI, CIA, NSA actually yield in comparison to our elected politicians, anyway? Do they have any real accountability?
- pyre 14y agoThey answer to the President, and partially to Congress (as they hold the purse-strings). How much they answer to the President is anyone's guess.
- mtgx 14y agoNo, not really. If they are in danger of having a lawsuit against them, they can usually just brush it off with the "state secrets" privilege, and if they are actually found guilty of doing illegal things, well...nothing happens to them. The worst that happens is that they need to change their methods, if that. Now, if they get themselves in a sexual scandal, they are expected to present their resignation immediately. Because obviously that matters much more than doing something unconstitutional.
- w1ntermute 14y agoIs anyone surprised at all by this? It's not like this is new or something. Despite the various documented incidents of physical violence and intimidation inflicted by law enforcement officers on Occupy protesters, it comes nowhere near the sorts of horrors suffered by protesters during the Civil Rights Movement, for example. Especially in the South, where protesters were often being attacked by the police.
- derekerdmann 14y agoOf course they did. Let's ignore for a moment that protest groups (like PETA) are usually considered some of the highest risks for terrorism; it would be irresponsible of the bureau to take the protest at face value and assume they have completely peaceful intentions.
- dalke 14y ago"irresponsible ... [to] assume they have completely peaceful intentions" Who is the "they" here? Protest groups in general? Or just PETA? You seem to be painting all protest groups with a single color. There are oodles of protests groups in the US, ranging from anti-red-light-camera groups, anti-computerized-voting-machines and anti-waste-in-local-government to anti-abortion and anti-pot-prohibition to boycott-Israel, anti-nuke, and anti-anyone-who-isn't-white. Some of these have national scope. Are all of them in the highest risk for terrorism? Assuming there were enough resources, would it be irresponsible for the police if there were a few protest groups which they did not monitor and/or infiltrate? If the police hear of a group planning to protest the high sugar tariff, with organized demonstrations in DC, Hawaii, and Florida, should they monitor the group on the assumption that it's "one of the highest risks for terrorism"?
- neumann_alfred 14y agoIt's people actually peacefully protesting injustice and corruption that scare the powers that be. A bunch of rowdies can be arrested or shot easily and to the relief of many. Old and young people singing songs and what not, that's much trickier. Ever read War Is a Racket? What makes you think Wall Street has peaceful intentions? What makes you think Wall Street doesn't cause a lot of death? What makes you think it's reasonably to project that evil on those who protest it? No wait; do you think, at all? Your bit about "the highest risks for terrorism" makes me wonder. Also, why bring up PETA? Why not bring up all the wonderful people who protest a lot of evil shit and make the world better; there is no day without that happening. You make it seem like all protest groups are out to destroy, which makes it rather obvious you wish they were. Would make it seem less crappy to, you know, not be out there protesting. Since protesters are potential terrorists (not my words, that's what you basically said), people who just sit at home are basically like the firefighters of 9/11 and the armed forces combined, but with a healthier lifestyle and pets 'n shit. Yes, I'm at the border of flamebaiting, mod me down. This self-righteous stating if BS ("are usually considered some of the highest risks for terrorism" -- by whom? that's like "some people say", the staple of any hit piece) really really ticks me off. And I'm not even American, I'd be breathing fire otherwise.
- 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoWhat kind of idiocy is this? This is the FBI's job -- to monitor both foreign and domestic groups of national scope that might present some kind of threat to civil order. They're not like the fire department, where they sit around waiting for something to happen. They're supposed to get out there and get proactively involved in all kinds of things from white supremacists to greens. As a libertarian I enjoy a good rant about state security as much as the next guy, but I prefer to do so from an informed position. There's enough real things to worry about without going on about the FBI doing what they're supposed to be doing.
- gimbuser 14y agoYou Sir are very sensible, good someone actually thinks twice before going down with hysteria about "yet another big brother"
- pyre 14y agoYou are both missing the plethora of articles about how every breaks at least 3 federal laws a day (unknowingly). We are rapidly approaching a state where everyone is a criminal, and all it takes it putting your life under a microscope to cart you off to jail. If the FBI are creating a file on everyone that goes to a protest, then fewer people will be willing to go to protests to avoid having their life under the microscope. This has a chilling effect on a free speech. [Note: This is the result of a system in which very few people are looking at the bigger picture, rather than a system of some 'elite evil masterminds.' Also, no one in power is incentivized to fix it.]
- cstejerean 14y agoWill a jury of your peers convict you for one of these things that supposedly everyone is violating?
- pyre 14y agoMany judges will not allow mention of jury nullification[1] in court. The jury is instructed at as long as you broke the law, they must find you in violation. There's also the fact that you went through a trial that counts against you, even if it shouldn't count against you. Even being accused of a crime is a crime in and of itself in the court of public opinion. Being accused of paedophilia is an extreme example of this (i.e. doesn't matter if you are or not, the claim makes you 'tainted' and people will always wonder). [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification
- dquigley 14y agoThe presumptuous labeling is definitely questionable, but the coordination and communication seems applaudable.(for a government organization) If there was a movement of people planing to protest Google or Facebook, I would expect the FBI to warn them if they had solid information it was going to happen. In fact if they were aware of large scale protests again an all but convicted child killer, they still have a responsibility to inform and protect. We protect criminals and saints equally in this country. Second in my mind there is no question that on both "sides", police and protesters, individual people broke laws. Protests bring out the worst in some of the police officers under pressure and some of the protesters. So the FBI and the agencies they coordinated with would have been failing at their job to not monitor and report in an effort to protect the employees of the businesses. You might not like the protection big banks got but they should receive it. Just like the most heinous criminal receives a lawyer to defend themselves, access to protection from danger (vigilanties), etc So if we can step the emotions back a bit and use a critical eye on both sides of the protests I think we will see a FBI that jumped to conclusions but did their job. And finally, I find it surprising in a start up forum that promotes agility and a lack of bureaucracy as the ideal that we are so quick to suggest more of it to an already bureaucratic, slow government.
- aj700 14y agoSome are, I see, already mocking the ideological presumptousness of this, from a law enforcement agency. Gee Mulder, there's also this report of blah blah blah. Well, why is PREVENTING some citizens from changing the ALWAYS "pro-business" status quo their job? Socialism is coming anyway (not the socialism-for-the-rich-kind), esp if you consider socialized medicine to be a trojan horse of socialism. The reason America fought socialism is not that it was bad, it was that it was foreign (Soviet domination) and undemocratic in that form. Via democracy you can have it any time you vote for it, and even press mogul Republican billionaires can't stop you. (See my record.) I never comment these days anyway, since I worked out that this is not a board of intellectuals (and I allow that there are conservative intellectuals), it is a board of (inherently capitalist and "selfish") Silicon Valley VCs and startup people. And here come the some people to argue with me, and some Randroids among them.
- mikegioia 14y agoThis is interesting. Are you saying socialism is coming because of a current trend in policies the US population is voting for, or because of a different reason? I'm legitimately curious.
- lostlogin 14y agoSurprised no one has posted this, it's a Rolling Stone article about Anonymous hacks that touches on Occupy movement monitoring. A good read if you have a minute. http://m.rollingstone.com/entry/view/id/34125/pn/all/p/0/?KSID=771c39799bd7b9021608ce0d5ecf23aa&ints_viewed=1 http://m.rollingstone.com/entry/view/id/34125/pn/all/p/0/?KS... Edit for bad link.
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoFor those of you that think the FBI is doing a wonderful job by doing this, I suggest looking up Brandon Darby and decide if that was tax dollars well spent and good government.