3 ms·
A future where machines displace most of what we currently think of as blue collar workers is a future where most of the things blue collar workers currently pr
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
A future where machines displace most of what we currently think of as blue collar workers is a future where most of the things blue collar workers currently produce are much, much, cheaper than they are now. This author worries whether blue collar jobs will pay "subsistence" wages. They will, because the cost of subsistence [and indeed, the cost of a fairly satisfied life] will be lower.
This was the entire thesis of the neoliberal project. Over 30 years of implementation, it has never once come true for basic subsistence goods.
Rent is not cheaper. Health-care is not cheaper. Energy is not cheaper. Food is only slightly cheaper.
The primary good that has become massively cheaper is electronics.
- learc83 14y ago>Health-care is not cheaper. That's not a fair comparison. Modern healthcare is not cheaper, but healthcare equivalent to what was available a generation or 2 ago is. >Food is only slightly cheaper. Food has pretty steadily been declining as a fraction of disposable income. It would be declining even more dramatically if it weren't being offset by an increase in eating outside the home.
- potatolicious 14y agoWell, yes, but that itself is an example of how the theory fails - it assumes that the bar for "subsistence" never moves. By all measures we are much better off than the average peasant in the Middle Ages, and their lifestyle is now incomprehensibly cheap. But that's not where the bar is at. Ditto energy - the amount of energy a poor person can consume is astronomical compared to that of a poor person even 100 years ago - but that bar hasn't stayed still either. You don't take a horse-drawn buggy to work, and most people have an expectation of keeping warm in the winters without huddling around the stove. I will agree on the food part - we have shown consistently that food cost, as a proportion of income, is at some of the lowest it's ever been, and a massive improvement over a century ago. This has been a clear win - but if you think about it, this is hardly a surprise. The bar for "eats well, not hungry" doesn't move very much over the decades.
- justincormack 14y agoMost of the housing and transport costs are due to the extreme inefficiency of working arrangements which telecommuting is disrupting.
- Joeri 14y agoTelecommuting requires management processes that facilitate it. Until they automate management telecommuting is not going to dominate, because the average manager doesn't perform well enough to manage remote workers effectively.
- justincormack 14y agoI don't think management is going to be automated per se, it is just going to continue to be a declining amount of employment, which it has been for a while, as communication gets more efficient. But also arguably the large firm is inefficient, as it is run on more dictatorial rather than market lines. Also outputs like code are creating a whole way of measuring output thats more useful than most office environments. Telecommuting in the form of outsourcing to low wage countries is efficient enough to work for many cases too. So these things might happen sooner than anyone expects.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoWell, yes, but that itself is an example of how the theory fails - it assumes that the bar for "subsistence" never moves. If we redefine "middle class" upwards to mean flying cars, robot servants and solid gold toilets, then we are all poor. That doesn't mean life hasn't become dramatically better over time, it just means reality has failed to keep up with our moving goalposts.
- greggman 14y agoIt seems like energy may soon be able to be removed from your list. Solar and new battery tech could easily make energy nearly free. Robots might help bring down health care costs the same way that LASIK is now relatively cheap compared to what it once was. Food should be cheaper. It's not because the government props up the prices. That leaves only rent. Arguably rent is only high in desirable places. So I'm not sure it's universally true that rent only goes up.
- tomjen3 14y agoOf course rent is not cheaper, because there is only so much land in attractive locations -- and because appartments have things that wasn't available 20 years ago. Health-care cannot really be compared because it is not subject to free competition. If it had been, basic care would have been massively cheaper. Energy is cheaper, you are just not seeing it because China is using so much of it. Food is cheaper -- but you are eating larger portions of it, more meat and better cuts. Of course electronics have gotten massively cheap, as it is not limited by government, or geography and the primary expense is the production facilities, rather than the actual product.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoBut that's my point: living expenses are not dictated by the supply and demand curves of perfect markets, with perfect competition, perfect information and zero transaction costs. The real world doesn't work according to Econ 101. As a result, what were supposed to be gains in production efficiency resulting in lower prices with higher supplies all-around have instead resulted in somewhat lower prices, but much higher economic rents. We're partially seeing a capitalist crisis of overproduction, but we're also very much seeing a reversion to a feudal economy based on rent-extraction and financialized ownership of entire labor outputs.
- tomjen3 14y agoAh, but that is not the way it has to be.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThen how do we fix it? It's the question of the age.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoRent is set through competitive pricing. If suddenly the wage floor fell out of the service industry then rents would fall too. This is economics 101.
- dredmorbius 14y agoYes and no. Among the problems with rent are that there is a low level of switching between owner-occupied and rental housing in many markets. In the case of condominiums, especially, HOA restrictions on renting out a property. This is also seen in REO (bank-owned) housing, in which what could be offered as rental units are kept off the market to support both higher rental rates and housing prices, largely as a hedge to support bank asset valuations (and maintain bank solvency).