4 ms·

Loved it. That's exactly what AI should be used for. Something that would take us one month at least, full of bugs, AI now delivers in less than a day, ready to

by Kuyawa 1mo ago

Loved it. That's exactly what AI should be used for. Something that would take us one month at least, full of bugs, AI now delivers in less than a day, ready to ship This is the essence, AI is a super power, the world is ours

ricardobeat 1mo ago
Something that would take us one month at least, full of bugs, AI now delivers in less than a day, full of bugs
krapp 1mo ago
>This is the essence, AI is a super power, the world is ours Don't me overdramatic. The guy who made Flappy Bird did it in a weekend without AI. A simple game like this wouldn't be difficult in any modern framework. That it can be vibe-coded in less than a day isn't really much value.
- michaelteter 1mo ago
  It now exists. It did not exist before I “made” it. For me it has value, because it is something I wanted to play.
tom_ 1mo ago
Well I dunno, man, this looks like the sort of amusing prototype I'd expect to take a couple of days - though not to understate the value of getting it in 4 hours (and probably with less than 4 hours' continuous effort from the human). Iteration time is an important factor! (Regarding the parting shot, I find myself once again, for the numerousth time, reminded of this curious lobsters comment that I'm having difficulty forgetting: https://lobste.rs/s/omq8rt/vibecoding_gets_emacs_patch_rejected#c_oa5cks https://lobste.rs/s/omq8rt/vibecoding_gets_emacs_patch_rejec... - perhaps not quite entirely directly germane here, I don't think, but, still, somehow, not quite entirely directly not.)
- karthink 1mo ago
  > Once the user is sufficiently (l)ionized, they're no longer receptive to neutral positions. Every step in this argument (particularly this one) seems tenuous at best, and in need of citations.
  - deleted 1mo ago
    [deleted]
  - tom_ 1mo ago
    Let us hope that the poster happens to see this, and is moved to comment, so they can address your points.

by Kuyawa 1mo ago

ricardobeat 1mo ago

Something that would take us one month at least, full of bugs, AI now delivers in less than a day, full of bugs

krapp 1mo ago

>This is the essence, AI is a super power, the world is ours Don't me overdramatic. The guy who made Flappy Bird did it in a weekend without AI. A simple game like this wouldn't be difficult in any modern framework. That it can be vibe-coded in less than a day isn't really much value.

michaelteter 1mo ago
It now exists. It did not exist before I “made” it. For me it has value, because it is something I wanted to play.

tom_ 1mo ago

Well I dunno, man, this looks like the sort of amusing prototype I'd expect to take a couple of days - though not to understate the value of getting it in 4 hours (and probably with less than 4 hours' continuous effort from the human). Iteration time is an important factor! (Regarding the parting shot, I find myself once again, for the numerousth time, reminded of this curious lobsters comment that I'm having difficulty forgetting: https://lobste.rs/s/omq8rt/vibecoding_gets_emacs_patch_rejected#c_oa5cks https://lobste.rs/s/omq8rt/vibecoding_gets_emacs_patch_rejec... - perhaps not quite entirely directly germane here, I don't think, but, still, somehow, not quite entirely directly not.)

karthink 1mo ago
> Once the user is sufficiently (l)ionized, they're no longer receptive to neutral positions. Every step in this argument (particularly this one) seems tenuous at best, and in need of citations.
- deleted 1mo ago
  [deleted]
- tom_ 1mo ago
  Let us hope that the poster happens to see this, and is moved to comment, so they can address your points.