3 ms·

Ok, point being? Codeberg is a non-profit community that evolves and figures out where to move, all the time, this is the point of the association itself. Membe

Ok, point being? Codeberg is a non-profit community that evolves and figures out where to move, all the time, this is the point of the association itself. Members discuss what to do, then a decision is made, then new rules eventually apply, this is how the project moves forward.

jeremyjh 1mo ago
You said people were “riding the line”. They weren’t. Codeberg made up a rule that excluded eligibility for projects they were already hosting. Projects that were not illegal, indecent or dangerous. I can’t think of another time something like that has happened. They can do it, sure, but many had hoped they could be an independent host for all FOSS as GitHub deteriorates. They have disappointed those hopes, and we will have to look to others - like Codefloe - to carry that hope forward.
- xigoi 1mo ago
  GitHub is deteriorating primarily because of LLMs. I’m guessing Codeberg doesn’t want to end up the same way.
- embedding-shape 1mo ago
  > Codeberg made up a rule that excluded eligibility for projects they were already hosting What does "made up" mean? It was a decision by the actual members of the platform, you know, the actual people using it! Nothing "made up" about it. I think it's pretty clear you don't have an idea of what Codeberg is trying to be, nor do you have any interest in understanding, you just want to push this "Codefloe" platform for some reason. Codeberg make very public what the platform is for and yes, that'll change in the future too, as the world changes.
  - jeremyjh 1mo ago
    I'm sorry that phrase offends you so much that you have to resort to personal attacks. Why don't you respond to the actual substance? The reason I'm supporting Codefloe is written in the comment you are responding to. Codeberg is not interested in hosting all FOSS, and Codefloe is. That is the reason. Its very simple. It is pretty clear you are not making any effort at all to understand the problem people have with Codeberg's rug pull.

jeremyjh 1mo ago

You said people were “riding the line”. They weren’t. Codeberg made up a rule that excluded eligibility for projects they were already hosting. Projects that were not illegal, indecent or dangerous. I can’t think of another time something like that has happened. They can do it, sure, but many had hoped they could be an independent host for all FOSS as GitHub deteriorates. They have disappointed those hopes, and we will have to look to others - like Codefloe - to carry that hope forward.

xigoi 1mo ago
GitHub is deteriorating primarily because of LLMs. I’m guessing Codeberg doesn’t want to end up the same way.
embedding-shape 1mo ago
> Codeberg made up a rule that excluded eligibility for projects they were already hosting What does "made up" mean? It was a decision by the actual members of the platform, you know, the actual people using it! Nothing "made up" about it. I think it's pretty clear you don't have an idea of what Codeberg is trying to be, nor do you have any interest in understanding, you just want to push this "Codefloe" platform for some reason. Codeberg make very public what the platform is for and yes, that'll change in the future too, as the world changes.
- jeremyjh 1mo ago
  I'm sorry that phrase offends you so much that you have to resort to personal attacks. Why don't you respond to the actual substance? The reason I'm supporting Codefloe is written in the comment you are responding to. Codeberg is not interested in hosting all FOSS, and Codefloe is. That is the reason. Its very simple. It is pretty clear you are not making any effort at all to understand the problem people have with Codeberg's rug pull.