3 ms·
Copyright assignment has a major purpose that is not acknowledged in this article. In some jurisdictions (I know that this used to be the case in the state of
by btilly 14y ago
Copyright assignment has a major purpose that is not acknowledged in this article. In some jurisdictions (I know that this used to be the case in the state of New York) it is the case that, by default, all software produced by employees who are software developers belongs to the employer, whether or not that software was developed on personal equipment, away from the office. In those jurisdictions it is also the case that many programmers who labor under this oppressive legal regime are entirely unaware that their time is not truly their own. They may therefore contribute to open source projects, and claim licensing on software, that is not truly valid.
The FSF copyright assignment process stands as a guarantee that GNU software, at least, will never encounter any issues based on these legal facts. You may use GNU software with assurance that the legal status of that software is very, very clear.
What about the rest of us? Well there is a defense for copyright infringement that basically says, "I relied on reasonable assurances that I was not, in fact, infringing." That covers your past infringement. But not necessarily future offenses. But the risk is still low. As a practical matter, companies rarely sue over this type of issue, and if they do, they generally have little interest in suing every innocent bystander who accidentally infringed. So many may find the risk acceptable.
But Stallman is an absolutist. He wants absolute guarantees. And copyright assignment helps him get there.
Please note that I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice.
- davidw 14y agoIt's worth noting that the ASF also requires copyright assignments.
- DannyBee 14y agoNo, AFAIK it requires copyright licenses given through a contributor agreement, which are not the same.
- dalke 14y agoI can confirm that it's a Contributor License Agreement: http://www.apache.org/licenses/#clas http://www.apache.org/licenses/#clas > Except for the license granted herein to the Foundation and recipients of software distributed by the Foundation, You reserve all right, title, and interest in and to Your Contributions.
- davidw 14y agoOops. My recollection was of paperwork but I got the nature of it wrong.
- nkurz 14y agoI'm not sure if it's as straightforward as this. There are two routes in for ASF software, the CLA you refer to, and the SGA for existing code: http://www.apache.org/licenses/software-grant.txt http://www.apache.org/licenses/software-grant.txt I've signed the SGA for some code, but still have trouble parsing the details. There is language in the preamble that "Licensor owns or has sufficient rights to contribute the software source code and other related intellectual property". I'd think that "contribution of code" is more than just a shared license. But in the actual clauses, only a "non-exclusive, worldwide, royalty-free, irrevocable" license is mentioned. Based on the discussion at the time, I presumed I was signing a grant of ownership of code. And the the NOTICE within the project says "Copyright 2010-2012 The Apache Software Foundation", which implies the ASF claims ownership. But I'm not sure of the basis of this claim. Do you have more insight?
- DannyBee 14y agoNon exclusive means it is not an assignment. Copyright assignments are exclusive, and you need to own at least one copyright right exclusively to sue. They also must be clear assignments to be effective. At least every ASF agreement I have seen was a license, not an assignment As for notice, you should ignore notices, they have no real meaning anymore. If they are wrong, they are just wrong, it does not give you any rights by putting your name on code you don't own copyright to. Additionally, for collective works, valid notice for one serves as valid notice for all owners.
- nkurz 14y agoI appreciate the response. While I agree that there is no assignment currently present in the CLA or SGA, the preamble makes me think it once did have one. Searching deeper I do find that the ASF _requires_ you to list the Apache Foundation as the copyright holder: http://apache.org/legal/src-headers.html#notice http://apache.org/legal/src-headers.html#notice As for for the legal role of the NOTICE file, I think there may be more complexity than that. Here, for example, we find Lawrence Rosen and Roy Fielding (among others) discussing what must go in NOTICE instead of in LICENSE: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/LEGAL-62 https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/LEGAL-62
- DannyBee 14y agoContributor license agreements take care of this issue, there is no need for assignment. The only legal reason for assignment is that it is a prerequisite for suing in court. Otherwise, only the actual code author could sue, not the project it was contributed to. Basically, assignments do not fix the issue you are raising any more than standard contributor agreements. I am an ip lawyer, but this is not legal advice