5 ms·
I think if one is going to have a war or be at war, it's reasonable to use a method which tries to minimize 'friendly' casualties first and e'enemy' collateral
by mc32 14y ago
I think if one is going to have a war or be at war, it's reasonable to use a method which tries to minimize 'friendly' casualties first and e'enemy' collateral damage second. Ie. does it reduce 'friendly' casualties? Does it reduce collateral deaths on the other side? I think the answer is yes to both.
I think drones reduce both and as such are a good thing, if one is going to be at war. Recall how in VN the VC suffered 2million casualties? Lots of that was due to collateral damage. Or in Afghanistan how the Russians decimated the enemy? That's traditional warfare.
The issue with remoteness and 'coldness' is an attempt to make this approach less palatable (appeal to some kind of war ethics?) on the other hand, if we were sending personnel on foot (a la vietnam) and people (soldiers) were dying by the dozen daily, people would feel aggrieved too (naturally).
Therefore I think what people should protest is 'war' not just a 'kind of war' because, to be honest, this new kind of war, if there needs to be one (and that's debatable of course), has its advantages over traditional (and that's becoming less traditional) warfare. It's less bloody and incurs less collateral damage is more targeted and effective.
So I think psychologically perhaps UAVs seem asymmetrical and unfair to a technological backward foe but realistically, they are at a huge disadvantage in traditional warfare anyway.
As weird as it sounds, I think UAVs are more effective and antiseptic than traditional warfare and thus 'better' as compared to boots on the ground.
- pyre 14y agoI think that the general fear is that war will turn into a 'video game' played by a bunch of people in a secure warehouse in middle America. This will remove the human aspect of what is going on at the other end of the controls, and we'll be less likely to get 'soldiers' doing things like questioning orders.
- Klinky 14y agoIsn't that already how war has been fought for most of the last century? The people making major decisions are rarely on the front line.
- pyre 14y agoThe "soldiers questioning orders" usually refers to the grunts questioning the orders of the higher-ups. You seem to be referring to generals making high-level decisions far-removed from the battlefield.
- Dove 14y agoI think that's a rather silly fear. If the targets on your screen were real people, would you not take the situation seriously? Or, let's put it another way. Bombers don't interface with targets personally; they're on the screen. Fighter pilots, too, for the most part. Artillery? Definitely. How about SAM operators? All they see is radar blips. Cruise missiles? ICBMs? People have to operate and launch those. How about an AWACS doing command and control? Their screens look like Starcraft with crappy graphics. Do any of these people see themselves as gamers rather than soldiers? I don't know any who do. The gravity of the situation comes from knowing that you're really involved in combat. Not from how good the graphics are.
- politician 14y agoThe Milgram experiment [1] showed that people who perceived themselves to under the influence of an authority will hurt other people when told to do so. The idea that soldiers are immune to this effect is irrational; in reality, this influence is probably a factor in their training regimes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment
- mc32 14y agoThis concern would affect all combatants --it's not something which would only influence drone pilots, so this objection is beside the point
- politician 14y agoThe parent's premise that drone operators will act humanely because "the people on the screen are real" has been shown to be invalid.
- Dove 14y agoNot at all. I said that there are already soldiers in the situation where their targets are lights on a screen, and they already treat the situation with the appropriate gravity. I claimed that drones wouldn't change that. Milgram proves too much. It should prove those soldiers callous as well, and they are not. Heck, it should prove any soldier callous, and they certainly are not. As I explained above, soldiers have training the subjects in milgram didn't.
- pekk 14y agoAs opposed to a 'video game' played by people sitting in cockpits very high in the sky.
- mayanksinghal 14y ago>it's reasonable to use a method which tries to minimize 'friendly' casualties first and e'enemy' collateral damage second That is a very broad statement. Would it apply to enemies using Chemical, Biological or Nuclear weapons? > people (soldiers) were dying by the dozen daily I don't think that you intend to, but it seems like you are counting only friendly casualties as people casualties. > asymmetrical and unfair to a technological backward foe Which would probably be all foes but one, if popular media is to be trusted with statistics. There is no country that spends asuch as US and that has been the case for a long long time I believe. So all foes are backward and hence a war, if the technology is the criteria of fairness, is going to be extremely unfair to them.
- mc32 14y ago>Would it apply to enemies using Chemical, Biological or Nuclear weapons? Not unless nuclear were reclassified as "reasonable". They also violate 'minimizing'. >There is no country that spends asuch as US and that has been the case for a long long time I believe. Yes but that's true irrespective of technology. I think UAVs allow for better targeting and hence smaller impact on civilians. >I don't think that you intend to, but it seems like you are counting only friendly casualties as people casualties. Unless we're discussing things theoretically, an entity waging war is beholden to its constituency, that translates into valuing ourselves over the other. None the less I meant in an overall sense so long as there isn't undue duress on the friendlies.
- deadbea7 14y agoThey don't reduce "enemy collateral damage", though. In fact, the collateral fatalities from drone attacks are one of the highest at 98%, according to some estimates [1]. Compare this to estimated civillian casualty rate of 60% in WWII [2] and around 50% in Vietnam [3] (distorted figures because anyone in a "free-fire" zone is considered the enemy). The intelligence for drone strikes are based on patterns, such as a party of men carrying guns or a group of unknown people plotting something. And so these strikes routinely -- and sometimes deliberately -- target wedding parties [4], funerals, and rescue workers [5], and children [6]. Add to this the psychological trauma of constantly living under the threat of drones [7], it is no wonder citizens of countries where these programs are carried out hold somewhat of a grudge against the US [8]. You can call it signature strike, or whatever you want, the fact is that bombs do not know the difference between combatants and women/children/civilians. They kill indiscriminately. So forgive me if I don't see the "advantage" of using drones over boots on the ground or see how they are "better". [1] http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/05/opinion/bergen-obama-drone/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/05/opinion/bergen-obama-drone/ind... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties [3] http://www.vn-agentorange.org/edmaterials/cost_of_vn_war.html http://www.vn-agentorange.org/edmaterials/cost_of_vn_war.htm... [4] http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-202_162-57448041/afghanistan-officials-claim-nato-air-strike-kills-women-kids-at-wedding-party/ http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-202_162-57448041/afghanistan-off... [5] http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/aug/20/us-drones-strikes-target-rescuers-pakistan http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/aug/20/us-drone... [6] http://tribune.com.pk/story/229844/the-day-69-children-died/ http://tribune.com.pk/story/229844/the-day-69-children-died/ [7] http://livingunderdrones.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Stanford-NYU-LIVING-UNDER-DRONES.pdf http://livingunderdrones.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Stan... [8] http://www.pewglobal.org/2012/06/27/pakistani-public-opinion-ever-more-critical-of-u-s/ http://www.pewglobal.org/2012/06/27/pakistani-public-opinion...
- Dove 14y agoIn fact, the collateral fatalities from drone attacks are one of the highest at 98%, according to some estimates [1]. I think you're confused. The relevant paragraph in your link says the collateral damage -- both civilians and unknowns -- is 2% at the moment. The civilian casualty rate has been dropping sharply since 2008. The number of civilians, plus "unknowns," those individuals whose precise status could not be determined from media reports, reported killed by drones in Pakistan during Obama's tenure in office were 11% of fatalities. So far in 2012 it is close to 2%. Under President Bush it was 33%. Conversely, the percentage of militants killed has been rising over the life of the drone program. The number of militants reported killed by drone strikes is 89% of the fatalities under Obama compared to 67% under Bush. I think that's fantastic news. A collateral damage rate of 2%, including unknowns "whose status could not be determined from media reports" is downright unprecedented in warfare. The statistics, taken together, say they're using drones more in regular combat than they used to, and getting better at confirming that the kills are accurate. That's great news, isn't it? There is a later paragraph that claims only 2% of drone strikes kill leaders. Maybe that's what you're thinking of? Since it began in 2004, the drone campaign has killed 49 militant leaders whose deaths have been confirmed by at least two credible news sources. While this represents a significant blow to the militant chain of command, these 49 deaths account for only 2% of all drone-related fatalities. I don't see how that's relevant, though. Is it somehow illegitimate to use drones on regular soldiers if it's tactically advantageous?