4 ms·
Intel's problem is the technology, it is their business practices. ARM is all about customization, and Intel is about commodity motherboards. Intel has restri
by protomyth 14y ago
Intel's problem is the technology, it is their business practices. ARM is all about customization, and Intel is about commodity motherboards. Intel has restricted every item that might give one PC manufacturer an advantage (e.g. no custom chipsets).
- ajross 14y agoThis is missing the point. The third party chipset market died off for exactly the same reason that you posit: all the features that were in the "chipset" are now in the SoC. So what you seem to be saying is that ARM only makes CPU cores (and now a GPU, I guess), so there's a wide market available for NVIDIA and Qualcomm to enter to provide a complete SoC. Intel, on the other hand, makes CPU cores, and GPUs, and display controllers, and DRAM controllers, and USB controllers, and PCI bridges, and audio hardware. And they put all that stuff on a single chip for their customers. ... and somehow you're spinning this as an advantage for ARM Ltd.?
- protomyth 14y agoNo, the third party chip chipset market died because Intel killed it. NVIDIA had a superior chipset with a better GPU and Intel stopped them. Intel wants commodity production of a very limited number of designs. Intel doesn't want customizations that can be offered by other companies. Intel wants Intel's GPU not a choice of NVIDIA, S3, ARM, and soon AMD/ATI. Intel wants to ship "Phone Motherboard 1", etc. Its an advantage because ARM lets other companies play and Intel won't.
- ajross 14y agoThis is still spinning. What you're saying is still isomorphic to: ARM has an "advantage" because it's a smaller company with fewer product offerings and no ability to fab its own chips. That's just insane. ARM Ltd. (the company) is successful in spite of these facts, not because of them. Maybe what you're really trying to talk about is the "ARM ecosystem", where the big mix of players has a market incentive to try new stuff. And there you might have a point. But it's certainly no disadvantage to Intel specifically -- every one of those players wants to be doing what Intel already is (Apple is very close already, with their own CPU core and SoC design).
- Tloewald 14y agoThe point of the article is that intel has been disrupted by ARM. You can disagree with this or not, but all these points are kind of irrelevant. People making mobile devices care about power efficiency, and Intel is behind for another year or two. Worse, even if it catches up it needs to compete with ARM's business model which cannot support Intel's revenue model. The point is that ARM allows — as you say — anyone make their own SoC and drain the profits from Intel's pool — they're not going to give that up unless Intel offers some incredibly compelling advantage, and it's not clear what that might be.
- cube13 14y ago>The point of the article is that intel has been disrupted by ARM. Has it? Intel is a much smaller part of all CPU's sold, that's true, but it's also true that the market for CPU's has increased exponentially in the last few years. The places where Intel is losing is places where they have never actually competed in. A decade ago, if you were looking for a low-power CPU for a mobile device, you sure as hell weren't looking at X86. You were going with an ARM solution. That hasn't changed, but the market for those CPU's has grown incredibly.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoThe difference is, a decade ago something like this couldn't exist: https://www.google.com/intl/en/chrome/devices/samsung-chromebook.html#specs https://www.google.com/intl/en/chrome/devices/samsung-chrome... And it should scare the hell out of Intel.
- Klinky 14y agoIntel actually did license ARM tech at one point with their XScale chips. It also wouldn't matter if they never competed in the phone market before, because the phone and tablet market is eating away at the desktop/laptop market already. People are probably more likely to want a flashy new phone or tablet, than upgrade their desktop or notebook.
- marshray 14y ago
- csense 14y ago> Intel wants Intel's GPU not a choice of NVIDIA, S3, ARM, and soon AMD/ATI. I haven't seen any sings of Intel trying to push their GPU's into ATI/NVidia's niche market (gamers). NVidia and ATI (now AMD) GPU's have always had their strongest consumer base among gamers [1]. Intel GPU's have never been in the same class as their contemporary NVidia/ATI cards on any measure -- triangles per second, texture bandwidth, gigaflops. Intel also generally uses shared-memory architecture, which means their memory bandwidth is limited and contends with the CPU. Intel's GPU's are focused on being a low-cost, low-power, on-board graphics solution. As long as they can run a 3D UI and play HD video, they're not going to push the performance envelope any more, for the good and simple reason that they don't want to incur additional manufacturing cost, chip area, design complexity and power consumption for features that are irrelevant to non-gamers. [1] By "gamers," I really mean anyone who's running applications that require a powerful GPU.