5 ms·
Previously submitted and seriously doubted: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4889266 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4889266 In that thread[0] revelati
by ColinWright 14y ago
Previously submitted and seriously doubted:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4889266 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4889266
In that thread[0] revelation[1] said:
At perfect efficiency, this seems to give you about
55mW for a hour, if I asked Wolfram correctly (for
20kg lifted one meter) - [2] - So probably a hoax.
[0] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4889426 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4889426
[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=revelation http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=revelation
[2] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=20+kilogram%E2%80%90force+meters+in+milliwatt+hours http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=20+kilogram%E2%80%90for...
- tonyarkles 14y agoIf you read some of the followups and tweak the math a little bit, it works out reasonably well. Instead of 20kg and 1m, 20lb and 2m, which comes out about the same (49.42mWh). If you have to lift it every half hour, that's 100mW for a half hour. That's more than enough power to get a useful amount of light out of an LED. For example, this LED uses 68mW https://www.sparkfun.com/products/531 https://www.sparkfun.com/products/531 and is marketed as "so bright that it hurts to look directly at them"
- duskwuff 14y agoThat's assuming a perfectly efficient dynamo and no mechanical losses. (Which are both huge assumptions.)
- icoder 14y agoExactly, and since they state that they think they can make it twice as efficient, that would mean they run at max 50% now.
- duskwuff 14y agoI suspect it's even less than that. A fancy (= expensive!) bicycle hub dynamo has an efficiency of about 70%, and that's assuming that it's operating at peak efficiency, and that there are no additional mechanical losses in the lamp.
- ars 14y agoIt's hurts to look at it because it's focused into a very narrow beam. Very bright sure - in one tiny spot, and totally useless to illuminate a room. They even include a photo of the beam pattern - it's almost as focused as a laser. (You can tell on an LED by looking a the top - round tops are focused, flat ones spread out.)
- tonyarkles 14y agoThat's fine! It's enough to read a book or do homework after the sun sets. We're not talking first-world style lighting; we're talking about a $5 light that is better than sitting in the dark because you have no electricity and ran out of kerosene to burn.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- libria 14y agoIt depends on the type of LED. Back when I was playing with them, Luxeons had a 180 degrees beam pattern while Crees were 70 degrees and neither had a built in lens like the cheap ones do (they used some kind of gel cover). They really should consult some lighting experts or flashlight junkies to get the best bang for the buck.
- pdonis 14y agoUm, please read the entire previous thread before dismissing this as a hoax. As you can see from a number of posts that I and others made there, the light is comparable to a kerosene lamp, which is what it's intended to replace. It is not, of course, comparable to the kind of light we in developed countries are used to, but that's not what it's intended for.
- ars 14y agoUsing the numbers above and the typical LED efficiency you get 5 lumen of light per half hour ASSUMING perfect mechanical efficiency. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=20+kilogram%E2%80%90force+meters+in+milliwatt+hours+*+%2850+lumen+%2F+w%29+%2F+.5+hour http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=20+kilogram%E2%80%90for... A simple wax candle produces 11 lumen. And there is no way you will get anywhere near perfect efficiency. So at best, this will product maybe 1/3 of the light from a candle. If you directed that light into a small spot, it could be useful, but of course it's a large device and you can't do that. If you illuminated a room with it it would be enough to walk around and not crash into things, but not enough to read. Another comparison: Assuming a 2 meter by 2 meter room (which is tiny), this would produce 1.3 lux (again, assuming perfect efficiency). Moonlight produces betwen .25 and 1 lux. So at best, with reasonable efficiency, and assuming a tiny room, this is comparable to moonlight under a full moon. Can you read in moonlight? Go try.
- pdonis 14y agoBut you can adjust the ballast weight and the height; instead of 20 kg over 1 meter, how about 30 kg over 2 meters? That's a factor of 3 difference.
- rorrr 14y agoHow many people can lift 30kg 2 meters up? How about doing it continuously? You're also forgetting that it require human energy to power it, which requires food, which is usually more expensive than batteries or gasoline or kerosine.
- retube 14y agowell here's the agency behind it... pretty elaborate if it is a hoax: http://www.therefore.co.uk/our-work http://www.therefore.co.uk/our-work
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI don't think its a hoax (I commented in the previous thread, initially skeptical but we worked out the math) It may not be as useful as someone might like, which is to say you won't get a lot of light out of it. But unlike the candle example all of the light will be going roughly one direction. Think 'keychain LED flashlight' kind of light. So in a place that literally has no light, it will be helpful. That last door in the dungeon, your village storage hut 30 miles from the nearest town on moonless nights. If you don't mind running the generator faster you can get brighter light for less time. I took apart one of these [1]: http://www.amazon.com/FR160B-Microlink-Self-Powered-Weather-Flashlight/dp/B001QTXKB0/ http://www.amazon.com/FR160B-Microlink-Self-Powered-Weather-... which is Grundig crank powered radio/siren/flashlight. Its pretty bright, and you can power the LED off the internal generator directly. In fact if you were handy with some shop tools you could probably build your own version of this light with just this radio thing and mechanical connection between the crank and the weight. (You would leave the flashlight set to 'on') You wouldn't get 30 minutes of light, more like 2 minutes. But conceptually the idea is the same. I like the design ethos of the 'clock' style energy source (I've got a grandfather clock that you wind by pulling up the weights on it). I expect in a nominally lit urban environment it will provide little benefit. But that doesn't mean I believe it will be useless in all environments. [1] I've now received 3 of these for 'free' (one as a conference giveaway, one came in a kit of earthquake supplies, and one was added into a garage sale purchase of other stuff. They kinda suck, in that they break pretty easily and once they do they don't work (internal wiring breaks). So finding a broken one shouldn't be all that hard if you're looking to experiment.