5 ms·
Objection. Assumes facts not in evidence [1]. I don't like the TSA, and I'm not friends with anyone who does, but that's because I live in a strange bubble, sur
by luu 14y ago
Objection. Assumes facts not in evidence [1]. I don't like the TSA, and I'm not friends with anyone who does, but that's because I live in a strange bubble, surrounded by academics and engineers. Most people don't have a problem with the TSA.
Here's what happened to me the last time I went through a TSA checkpoint:
I opted out. The TSA agent made a snide remark about about me being separated from my belongings, which I'd already put on the X-ray conveyor belt [2]. Then, I was forced to wait about half an hour until an agent was free [3]. There were TSA agents standing around, not doing anything, but, those people, apparently, can't do pat downs.
When an approved agent was finally free, instead of cordially walking me over to the pat down area, he shoved and body checked me to get me to move. After the perfunctory patdown, he pointed to my luggage and said I could go get it. He then stepped in front of me as I started walking towards it and gave me one last shove, away from my luggage.
So, do I like the TSA? Of course not. I have practical and philosophical objections to their process, and perhaps 20% of the time when I opt out, I'm treated like human garbage [4]. But, most people don't have any weirdo academic objections, so they go through the regular process and everything is fine, 99% of the time. Sure, they have to to the airport half an hour earlier now, but that's a small price to pay for what they see as protection from terrorists.
[1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/tedreed/2012/08/09/surprise-gallup-poll-people-think-tsa-does-a-good-job/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/tedreed/2012/08/09/surprise-gall...
[2] It's a bit like being threatened by the mafia: those are some nice things you have there. It would be such a shame if anything happened to them while you're away. This was sufficient to keep two couples, who initially decided to opt-out, from actually opting out.
[3] https://twitter.com/someben/status/274976070271377409 https://twitter.com/someben/status/274976070271377409
[4] It's like walking into a random replication of the Stanford Prison experimenter [5]. Will the guards be aggressively unpleasant? Maybe!
[5] http://www.lucifereffect.com/about_content_extensions.htm http://www.lucifereffect.com/about_content_extensions.htm
- graeme 14y agoBut what did the poll say? Liking an agency and thinking its effective are two different things. It's like asking: is abstinence effective for preventing stds? And then inferring that people prefer abstinence to condoms.
- crusso 14y agoLiking an agency and thinking its effective are two different things. Efficacy isn't as useful as how an issue plays on the emotions of voters.
- bishnu 14y agoReally? A single Gallup poll is "evidence" now? [1,2,3] [1]http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/10/18/gallup-vs-the-world/ http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/10/18/gallup-v... [2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/17/gallup-poll-race-barack-obama_n_1589937.html?utm_hp_ref=@pollster http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/17/gallup-poll-race-ba... [3] http://andrewsullivan.thedailybeast.com/2012/10/rasmussen-and-gallup-vs-the-rest.html http://andrewsullivan.thedailybeast.com/2012/10/rasmussen-an...
- mtgx 14y agoWhat wasn't a surprise is that the poll appeared just before Congress has to decide TSA's budget for next year. I've seen a few other highly complimentary articles on TSA these past few days, too - all appearing all of the sudden. A little suspicious, isn't it?
- codex 14y agoI'm a bit confused: the poll was released in August. That said, the final budget negotiations for the first half of 2013 (which included the DoHS) weren't concluded until September. Is that what you mean?
- MartinCron 14y agoSomeone shoves you? That's assault. Did you think of reporting the incident or pressing charges? Serious question.
- mistermann 14y agoThe problem with that is if you run into the wrong guy it might get you killed.
- chadillac83 14y agoI think that seems a bit extreme. I've opted out of nearly every flight I've been on (unless crunched for time due to traffic of crazy lines or something) and I've never been treated like this, I'm not defending the TSA, I'm just saying this isn't "normal". Sometimes they'll make you stand around and wait, the shoving and the intimidation has never occurred. Making the jump to the idea that a TSA officer has a weapon, or can "issue a hit" is absurd. edit: Also, the most shocking part of the whole ordeal is usually the looks from the OTHER people in line, like they think you're going to be killed or assaulted, or "why don't you just cooperate, it's easier". That's the part that really makes me sad.
- driverdan 14y agoRight. Complaining about a TSA agent (who isn't law enforcement) shoving you is going to get you killed. Hyperbole like this helps no one.
- MartinCron 14y agoYou should even be able to complain about being assaulted by people who are law enforcement without fear of fatal retribution.
- mistermann 14y agoI was talking about if it escalates to the police being called. Would you have us believe there have been no mysterious deaths of people after being taken into police custody? Note I am not saying you are likely to die, I am saying it can and has happened.
- tptacek 14y agoWhen we think about statistics about support for the TSA, it's important to note that the majority of Americans don't travel by air at all in any given year.
- js2 14y agoCounterpoint: I have opted out over a dozen times at a variety of airports (RDU, SJC, SFO, BUR). I've never been treated with anything but professionalism, and I dare say, politeness. I was asked why I was opting out by the TSA officer performing my pat-down at BUR who seemed personally curious more than anything, but otherwise it's been perfunctory. I've never had to wait more than a minute or two at most.
- jamesbritt 14y agoThat's been my experience, more or less. Worst I could say is that mostly they don't seem enthusiastic, and on one occasion one guy seemed annoyed that I did not understand some vague instruction about either staying put or not. But each time they ask me if there are any sensitive areas, each time I tell them, "Yes, my nuts", and each time they been respectful of my junk. They really could do better about keeping people with their stuff that's been passed through the X-ray machine, but overall they seem to appreciate that you want to keep an eye on it.
- jvrossb 14y agoMy experience as well. I travel a lot and never had an issue with the TSA.
- driverdan 14y agoWhat airport was this at? Did you report this incident to his supervisor? Did you complain when it took more than 2 minutes to get someone to do the pat down? I've had about 20 pat downs in many different airports. I've never had to wait more than three minutes for someone and everyone has always been professional and courteous. As much as I hate the TSA and complain about them, the airport staff has been nice and helpful. In two or three cases they went out of their way to help me, beyond what I expected. Edit: I should also add that I'm a middle class white male who looks "respectable". I'm not going to experience the discrimination some minorities may endure so take that for what it's worth.
- lostlogin 14y agoYou say that 99% of the time it's fine. If you go through the back scatter thingy, I'd say that 99% is a hopeful assumption. They are likely unsafe, and some small subset of people scanned may end up quite sick.
- robbiep 14y agoAre you making this up, ill-informed or do you not understand physics and radiation? I do not mean this as offensively as it will ultimately be read, so apologies These scanners exposé you to less than 1/200th the radiation dose of a standard plane flight, and between 1/200th and 1/400th of a standard chest X-ray. Yes, ionising radiation can cause cancer. But your chance of getting cancer anyway is 1 in 2.4. I have no love of excessive security measures, and I personally don't think that we should ever unnecessarily cause people to be exposed to radiation, especially when other methods can do the same job without radiation, and even moreso when the efficacy of the scanners is unproven. But I have a particular dislike of the psychogenic claims that arise around technologies that posit to do this or that, when the action of the machine or technology in question is noninvasive and especially when the action is not substantively different from normal daily exposures that every human receives anyway Refs: standard CXR 2.4x background radiation Backscatter Imaging 6-7% of a days background radiation (0.25 microsiverts per 'scan =1.5hrs @ background radiation or 2 minutes of an airplane at altitude) Abdo CT: 2.7 years BG radiation - http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/219970.php http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/219970.php - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backscatter_X-ray http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backscatter_X-ray
- seehafer 14y agoWould you take your same condescending tone against the 4 UCSF medical school professors who raised concerns about the backscatter x-rays? [1] Their contention is that the argument that the backscatter x-rays are 1/200th of the dose you get from cosmic radiation on a flight is invalid, as the backscatter x-ray is specifically designed to direct the radiation to a very thin layer of surface tissue, whereas cosmic radiation is distributed throughout the entire body. Yes, these professors were refuted by other UCSF radiology professors [2], but the science will not be settled until an independent study is conducted of the machines given the context of their potential for misuse and mis-calibration by individuals who are not radiology technicians. So if you don't want your comment to come off as offensive, perhaps it would be wise to not start off with "Are you making this up, ill-informed or do you not understand physics and radiation?" [1] http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ostp/ucsf-jph-letter.pdf http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ost... [2] http://blogs.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2010/11/tsa_scanner_controversy_ucsf_r.php http://blogs.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2010/11/tsa_scanner_cont...
- grecy 14y ago> When an approved agent was finally free, instead of cordially walking me over to the pat down area, he shoved and body checked me to get me to move. After the perfunctory patdown, he pointed to my luggage and said I could go get it. He then stepped in front of me as I started walking towards it and gave me one last shove, away from my luggage. Sounds like you're describing the dystopian future we read about and see in movies.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]