4 ms·
I've always believed this to be true. They do it in US, too, and probably in a few more countries like India and Saudi Arabia, and maybe some African ones, too
by mtgx 14y ago
I've always believed this to be true. They do it in US, too, and probably in a few more countries like India and Saudi Arabia, and maybe some African ones, too - and possibly even UK. It's just too bad they aren't going to come out and admit it, and say which governments asked them to do this, and how many requests for people's logs have they received - the way Google does it. As a company that's supposed to be beholden first and foremost to its users, that's the least they could do.
This is why to me Google is still a much more trustworthy company than Microsoft. Microsoft with all of this and all of their hateful campaigns against competitors, and hiring other companies in secret to throw dirt on others either in public or to convince politicians about something. It's just a much shadier company. I wish they would change. But I'm not seeing that happening anytime soon, at least not until Ballmer, the "salesman", is out and they get a much different CEO with different kind of thinking and ethics.
- EwanG 14y agoGiven that we know that at least in the US (and probably in the other countries you have mentioned as well) that the government has a special tap into AT&T, Verizon and others, I'm not sure why Skype is being singled out. We have long since passed the point where we all need to keep in mind Eric Schmidt's somewhat ironic "If you aren't doing anything wrong, you have nothing to hide" comment. Which I would argue puts him in much the same boat as Ballmer in this instance.
- joering2 14y agoI think Schmidt still does not see anything wrong with his statement, because if the government is the one to say whats wrong or right, then they shall have access to all and any of your information as soon as they say "its wrong to [insert anything you do here]". Couldn't help adding for those who are not aware: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- Rastafarian 14y ago"a company that's supposed to be beholden first and foremost to its users" - it's only supposed to if you're stupid enough to believe the PR talk. Generally Microsoft is as trustworthy as Google and any other big corporation (i.e. not much, when it comes to power struggle - which is what privacy is all about).
- muro 14y agocitation needed edit: Don't they all follow what they say in their TOS? Are the TOS the same? (I don't know, maybe they are)
- mtgx 14y agoI don't think Google is an order of magnitude more trustworthy, but enough to matter - for now. The way Google would be an order of magnitude more trustworthy to me, would be to implement OTR and ZRTP in Google Talk and Hangouts, and to allow private-key encryption for Gmail and Google Drive, done from inside the browser. And of course these options should be right there for you to see when using the service, not buried in deep levels of settings. And they should be on by default, unless there's a technical or UX reason why that's a big negative, like for encrypting e-mails. But for all the other services it should be okay to set encryption on by default. If you had an option to do so from inside the Gmail client, encryption would become much more mainstream. Techdirt [1] and ArsTechnica [2] had some good articles about it, although I disagree with TechDirt that they should offer "key management" for users. That would defeat the purpose - unless it's guaranteed to only be done by the browser, locally, and they wouldn't have access to that, and it could be easily verified that they're not lying. I think they sort of do this already for the master-password in Chrome. I don't think these encryption options would hurt their ad-revenue much, and besides - I don't think Google, Microsoft or any other company should scour through my private messages to make their ads more relevant. I don't care how "anonymous" or secure they make it. It's okay if it's public data - but private data? No. Definitely not. [1] - http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20121218/16095921431/why-google-should-encrypt-our-email.shtml http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20121218/16095921431/why-go... [2] - http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/12/op-ed-a-plea-to-google-protect-our-e-mail-privacy/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/12/op-ed-a-plea-to-g...
- Rastafarian 14y agoIMHO they would never do that and you're just being naive ;) Encryption in the browser would mean no targeted ads, less profit for shareholders, problems with the government. Again IMHO the reality of today is governments and big business are controlled by a very few people, working against the interests of the masses - i.e. a huge conspiracy.
- rickmb 14y agoI don't believe Google is any better. The confrontational way Google treats countries that actually try to protect their citizens rights and privacy against Google's invasive practices has me believing more and more that Google is just opportunistically waging a "governments bad, Google good" PR war, rather than actually displaying any ethics. BTW, Google is an advertising company for which the users are the product, not the client. They are in no way "beholden to its users". That would apply to Microsoft, but not to Google. In the long run, I prefer Microsoft's often clumsy and transparent nastiness over Google that actually tries to make people believe it's a force for good.
- vibrunazo 14y ago> countries that actually try to protect their citizens rights and privacy O.O > Google is an advertising company And Microsoft is trying as hard as they can to be one. Google doesn't put ads on their OS, Microsoft does on it's OS that you already paid for. Aren't they treating you as a paying product then? > transparent Oh, c'mon. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Penn http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Penn
- onlyup 14y agoWhich ads do MS put on their OS? There are ads in some apps on Windows 8. Is that what you mean?
- pdonis 14y agoIn the long run, I prefer Microsoft's often clumsy and transparent nastiness over Google that actually tries to make people believe it's a force for good. I prefer neither. I don't use Windows except when forced to (at work), and I don't use any Google services except basic search and Google Maps (with all possible privacy filters in place).
- jb17 14y ago> countries that actually try to protect their citizens rights and privacy Haha. I assume you're talking about Germany. Hahaha.
- JshWright 14y ago>As a company that's supposed to be beholden first and foremost to its users, that's the least they could do. They are legally required to be beholden to their shareholders, not their customers. Most of the time that overlaps, but the times where it doesn't (e.g. expanding into Chinese market = good for shareholders; the monitoring required to do that = bad for customers), the shareholders win.
- dpeck 14y agoI'd wager that Microsoft is beholden to their biggest users. Can't find the numbers anywhere, maybe someone with better search-fu than me can, but public sector sales have got to make up a huge percentage of MS revenue.