3 ms·
People rip off fonts all the time, and many of them do it for major commercial projects. As someone who does pay for fonts legally, and who makes his own livin
by Silhouette 14y ago
People rip off fonts all the time, and many of them do it for major commercial projects.
As someone who does pay for fonts legally, and who makes his own living creating knowledge works, I find this intensely annoying.
But I've still never heard of a single project being undermined or seen anyone suddenly change their branding as a result of a lawsuit about font usage rights. For a start, if the font is being used to generate graphics or for anything in print rather than embedded electronically, you'd have a tough time proving any kind of infringement in jurisdictions where the design of a font isn't subject to protection.
Frankly, I don't believe that most small type foundries have the will, the time or the money to go after anything but large-scale, flagrant infringement anyway, any more than my company would realistically go after a client who didn't pay a small invoice. Whatever protection the law theoretically affords, in practice the overhead of exercising your rights are greater than the benefit you stand to gain by doing so. Pragmatically, your best bet is not to work with people who are likely to rip you off, which you can do by working with nicer people or by reducing the incentive for less nice people to screw you over.
- tptacek 14y agoPoint me to a project you think (a) lots of people would have paid attention to and (b) is using typefaces that they haven't bothered licensing.
- Silhouette 14y agoAre you serious? Half the design agencies in the universe seem to have a massive stock of fonts that they once bought for one project (if that) and never deleted, copied onto their servers where any of their designers can use them for any new project, with little if any control or auditing going on. You claim that there is a bogeyman out there who will come and sue infringers, but it seems to me that this is the rare exception rather than the rule. Ironically, the last case I heard about was HADOPI, the French anti-piracy watchdog, which got caught with its pants down almost immediately over the font it was using for its logo. You seem to be living in this HN dream world where all projects are high-value and all clients are high payers. If you want to argue that font licensing works effectively in that market, sure, maybe it does. But most of the design world isn't like that, and the current copyright/licensing regime for fonts is doing precious little to promote their use in the rest of the industry.
- tptacek 14y agoThat is exactly what I'm arguing: that font licensing works effectively for the high-value projects the foundries target. And if you don't think what you're building has the potential to be high-value, why are you working on it? You don't seem to get it: it is a perfectly sane business decision to choose your client base. Most of the foundries haven't chosen "random web apps". They're probably smart to make that decision, given the fact that most of the people who make "random web apps" don't really value typography. How I know that is, they bitch loudly over pricing that is a tiny fraction of what the foundries real customers routinely pay.
- Silhouette 14y agoThat is exactly what I'm arguing: that font licensing works effectively for the high-value projects the foundries target. Well, OK, I'm not disputing that. But this discussion isn't about those high-value projects, it's about using fonts in native apps. And if you don't think what you're building has the potential to be high-value, why are you working on it? Because not every project in the world has to be Google or Facebook. I think your definition of high-value is probably a lot higher than what many people would consider a successful project, assuming the project is even being done for profit in the first place. You don't seem to get it: it is a perfectly sane business decision to choose your client base. I get that just fine. It's just that you seem to be the only person in this entire discussion who is talking almost exclusively about high-end projects, while the rest of us seem to be generally agreeing that the current state of type licensing is not helpful for anywhere below high-end.
- tptacek 14y agoYou're beating a straw man. I'm not saying you have to be shooting to be the next Google.
- Silhouette 14y agoBut your entire argument seems to be that font licensing is working just fine for high-value, high-end customers. The rest of us are talking about what is holding back typography in apps and how the current licensing regime isn't promoting the use of better fonts in that context. It's right there in the title of the discussion.