5 ms·
Fascinating to look back at the reactions from when I posted this 500 days ago. One person said: while this is a classic, my snark is thrashing against
by ColinWright 14y ago
Fascinating to look back at the reactions from when I posted this 500 days ago. One person said:
while this is a classic, my snark is thrashing against
its bonds. I could have sworn it said 'news' up there.
And another:
SENSATIONAL HEADLINE ALERT!!!
And that was it. No further comments to be had. Both those comments were downvoted, but even so, interesting that no one else commented, and very few voted for the submission.
For reference, the headline I used was:
Engineering pornography - underground
power cables gone wrong
... which I felt was more informative.
So on this submission, now even older, we have 16 comments (and counting) and 60 points (and counting). Has HN changed? I'm off to check some records ...
(pause)
A bit of hunting shows that this got at least one vote while still on the "newest" page, but it looks like it never hit the front page, which will part explain why it never got many comments or votes. Still, the tenor of the comments is interesting. I continue to learn.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoSo you are complaining that you didn't get the karma 500 days ago that wallflower got? Or are you just pondering the mysteries of stories getting picked up? I see it isn't the latter since in this comment http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4097127 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4097127 you indicate you've done research on that topic. So what are you saying?
- ColinWright 14y agoSo you are complaining that you didn't get the karma 500 days ago that wallflower got? Not at all. Karma is a proxy measure for something else, and since this submission proved "successful" by the karma measure, I'm happy to see that the submitter got the karma for it. Or are you just pondering the mysteries of stories getting picked up? In part, yes, exactly this, I see it isn't the latter since in this comment http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4097127 you indicate you've done research on that topic. I have, and continue to do so because I have, as yet, come to no definitive conclusions. The investigations continue, even if only in a sporadic fashion,as and when I have the time. So what are you saying? I'm saying that sometimes submissions fail to attract any attention, even if subsequent submissions achieve significant success. This is evidence that the current system is, by some measures, sub-optimal. I continue to investigate the dynamics (as best I can), and continue to work on something that I think will improve the situation. The dissonance between the comments there (even though downvoted) and the positive reaction here is also of interest. I thought I'd share that, hence my comment.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoWell in a very real way the system has to intentionally obfuscate the 'way to the front page' because being on the front page is so valuable, thus a target for manipulation. What I'm saying is that as soon as you find a fool proof way to submit something and have it show up on the front page, pg will 'fix' it so that you can't do that in the future just like linking the discussion in a blog post was 'fixed'. I typically read the site from an RSS feed, which means I see everything that is submitted that makes it to the rss feed, regardless of whether it is on the 'new' page or has fallen off. I don't know what percentage of folks do that. There are also 'super powers' for some users but those are for the standard sorts of things (like make sure a YC company looking for people gets to the front page for a while). Can you say more about what "improving the system" would entail?
- ColinWright 14y agoI'm not looking for a guaranteed way to get to the front page. I'd guess that most of the things that don't make it, deserve not to make it, in the sense that while they might be interesting, even if most HN people saw it, it wouldn't get many votes. My concern is that things that are clearly of interest (in the sense that they do eventually do get the upvotes in a subsequent submission) sometimes don't get noticed and don't get the upvotes they deserve (by some definition). Or something. > I typically read the site from an RSS feed, which means > I see everything that is submitted that makes it to the > rss feed, ... Do you apply some sort of filtering, or do you literally scan everything by eye? > Can you say more about what "improving the system" > would entail? My ideas are very badly formed at the moment, and I'd rather not try to put them in written form in an open forum. I wouldn't care if people stole them, I'd care more that they would look pretty stupid, because I couldn't explain them well enough. Yet.
- fusiongyro 14y ago> This is evidence that the current system is, by some measures, sub-optimal. Aren't you assuming the value of an article is a constant? In practice, context changes and the value of an article goes up and down. Maybe today is a slow news day and 500 days ago was very busy. I wouldn't expect your average article about (say) Scala to do equally well on the day Facebook has its IPO and some day nothing interesting happened on. A controversial article about gun control is not going to be perceived as having the same value the day after a big massacre as leading up to an election or on a boring day in mid-January.
- mhb 14y agoYou may also be intrigued by the comments from when it was posted 1677 days ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=193112 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=193112
- ColinWright 14y agoWell found - thanks.
- scott_s 14y agoAs what becomes popular on HN has a large dosage of randomness, I would not draw conclusions based on this one data point. There was an interesting study from a few years ago that investigated what factors make a song a hit. They seeded various songs with various levels of initial popularity, and their general conclusion was that popularity begets popularity. Hence, initial conditions matter a lot, and they are largely random. (And if anyone can find that study, please let me know. I have tried multiple times to find it, but I can't.)
- ColinWright 14y agoYes it does have a large dose of randomness, and I'm not taking this single data point. I have more data. Quite a lot, actually. And the challenge in the analysis is to find the factors that affect it, and then add the randomness to get the right results. To find the underlying behavior, even when the data are affected by randomness. It is kinda what I do, and that's partly why I'm working on it. I'm learning things as I go, both about the techniques and methods, and about the HN "community". Interesting study you mention - I've made a note both to look out for it, and to let you know if I find it. Thanks.
- safeaim 14y agoThese are the droids that are being referred to I think: http://www.princeton.edu/~mjs3/musiclab.shtml http://www.princeton.edu/~mjs3/musiclab.shtml "Experimental study of inequality and unpredictability in an artificial cultural market." This wiki article might be of interest too: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_effect_(sociology) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_effect_(sociology)
- hooande 14y agoIs this the study you had in mind? http://www.princeton.edu/~mjs3/salganik_dodds_watts06_full.pdf http://www.princeton.edu/~mjs3/salganik_dodds_watts06_full.p... I read about a similar experiment in the book "Automate This" by yc alum Christopher Steiner. They seeded a music website with unknown songs and it turned out that whatever was liked first benefited from the Matthew Effect. ie, people tend to like whatever is already labelled as "popular". Definitely an interesting study, but I fear we've gone far off topic.
- duaneb 14y agoA sample size of 2 is much too small to inductively reason.