8 ms·
Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror
- catshirt 14y agoa different implementation of the non-reversing mirror: http://www.truemirror.com/ http://www.truemirror.com/ bonus points: you can buy this one!
- leeoniya 14y agowas hoping for more technical details. maybe they're still going through the patent application?
- deutronium 14y agoHere's the patent http://www.google.com/patents/US8180606 http://www.google.com/patents/US8180606 but it doesn't mean much to me.
- Hopka 14y agoThis patent is not for the non-reversing mirror but for another type of mirror which was invented earlier.
- deutronium 14y agoOh sorry, yep, you're right
- andrewcooke 14y agoaccording to the wikipedia article it's a surface of micro-mirrors that work in pairs. so it's basically a pair of mirrors scaled down and repeated. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-reversing_mirror http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-reversing_mirror not very exciting really.
- shardling 14y agoI imagine the hard part is actually optimizing that array of mirrors.
- joshdick 14y agoNo, that is not what Prof. Hicks made. His mirror is a single curved piece. Source: I am a former undergrad research assistant of his.
- andrewcooke 14y agohuh. thanks. so that's the second type listed at wikipedia? or am i confused? perhaps you or he could fix / clarify the wikipedia article? i guess i could but it feels odd to do it third-hand...
- joshdick 14y agoI wish I could give you a link to one of Prof. Hicks's published papers on the topic, but I'm having trouble finding one that isn't behind a paywall. This seems like a nice introduction: http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/papers/physics-today.pdf http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/papers/physics-today.pdf If you have access to journals through a university, you could take a look at some of his papers yourself (His website is http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/ http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/). They're easy enough for a sophomore to recreate the results. (I know, because I did for an independent study with Prof. Hicks.)
- shardling 14y agoThe thing was around in 2009. This particular article is about an art exhibit that involves the mirror.
- phaet0n 14y agoFeynmann's great mirror story [1]. Try and solve the puzzle before watching the whole clip. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msN87y-iEx0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msN87y-iEx0
- jpdoctor 14y ago> When you look in a normal mirror, the image you see of yourself is in reverse. Funny thing: Mirrors don't reverse left and right. They reverse front and back. So this "non-reversing" mirror is actually mapping y to -y, x to -x (Where the mirror is in front of you in the z-direction. Curious. Edit: I believe tomerv below is correct: x is mapping to -x but y is kept the same.
- tomerv 14y agoIf you map both x to -x and y to -y (in addition to mapping z to -z), then you still get a reversed (chiral) image. From the pictures, it looks like it maps x to -x, but y is kept the same.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoDemonstration time: Write something on a piece of paper. Hold the paper up to the mirror. Now replace that with a transparent piece of plastic.
- pixl97 14y agoOb. xkcd http://xkcd.com/1145/ http://xkcd.com/1145/ See ALT text.
- tedchs 14y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrhYOYs5JrA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrhYOYs5JrA
- sliverstorm 14y agoI still don't intuitively understand how reversing front to back results in what we perceive as a left/right inversion.
- thejad 14y agoThis is pretty great!
- tesko8482 14y agoWant.
- naner 14y agoI'm having a hard time visualizing this. If I am standing directly in front of this mirror and slowly reach forward with my right hand until I touch the mirror, will my hand be touching its mirrored self?
- adamman 14y agoI'm guessing that the only way you could touch the mirror image of your finger is by doing so in the middle of the mirror. If you move the finger out toward the shoulder, I'm betting your arm would stretch off the mirror away from your body. I could be totally wrong though.
- dllthomas 14y agoLook at the cover of the book that the trick mirror is resting on.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mbq 14y agoIt seems this mirror is especially shaped to project the ordinarily reflected image in a reversed way, thus putting an object near it surface will break the illusion and show skewed but normally reflected image.
- dllthomas 14y agoWhich seems to be what is going on with the book cover, in the picture in TFA.
- jere 14y agoTry this with a metal spoon. If you bring in your right hand, it will be on the left side, but extremely distorted.
- jonknee 14y agoIt should be easy enough to simulate with a webcam.
- 0x0 14y agoI'd love to see a movie demonstrating what this looks like!
- ubercow13 14y agoHere's a pic http://www.newscientist.com/gallery/dn16585-amazing-mirrors/1 http://www.newscientist.com/gallery/dn16585-amazing-mirrors/...
- GIFtheory 14y agoThat links also mentions that his amazing 45 deg. FOV side-view mirror is banned in the US, because curved mirrors are illegal in the US. What the hell? Doesn't congress have anything better to do than shoot us all in the foot, repeatedly?
- Jun8 14y agoAnd he's holding MTW's Gravitation tome in the photo! BTW: Why do so few people pose with their favorite books (or holding any book) in profile photos, this was common when people had their portrats painted in the past. Has it become a turn-off?
- brianpan 14y agoBecause it's not quite the same holding a Kindle displaying cover art up to your face.
- pretoriusB 14y agoBecause most people don't read at all, or read BS (self-help books, how to succeed, cheap thrillers, 50 shades of gray...)
- jeremyarussell 14y agoHave you read fifty shades? I find that people like to bag on stuff they've never actually experienced first hand.
- jere 14y agoEmbarrassingly, I listened to a youtube video where a woman read the book aloud (I listened for about 30 pages). She ended up hitting herself in the head about a dozen times because the writing is that awful.
- rada 14y agoFifty Shades is pornography for women. IMHO that's the only reason everyone is clutching their pearls about the bad writing. Your typical male pornography storylines/cinematography are much, much worse - and yet they are typically spared the high-brow literary scrutiny.
- woah 14y agoYep, must be the patriarchy oppressin' again. The reason that 50 Shades of Grey is subjected to highbrow literary scrutiny, is that it pretends to be highbrow literature. Male pornography usually makes no pretense, being more along the lines of logjammin' "ich bin here to fix your kable"
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- eps 14y agoA video of this mirror in action would've been very helpful.
- raimondious 14y agoYou can simulate one of these yourself by getting a wide flexible plastic mirror (dimensions along the lines of 1:4) and bending it to be concave until you look undistorted. Looking into this bent mirror, if you raise your right hand, the hand on your left side in the reflection will move.
- jlgreco 14y agoPerhaps even easier is to secure two flat rigid mirrors at a right angle, like: /\
- salimmadjd 14y agoThis is probably a small array of double mirror. If you look at the images you see slight loss of light (a bit darker) on his none-reversing mirror. Which is probably due to the gaps between the arrays behaving a bit like a scrim in shooting sets. I think the invention will have some uses. For anyone who has tried to do anything that requires precision in front a mirror the reversing of the mirror is disorienting. I could even imagine mechanics who use a mirror to see what they are doing in tight spots be able to use it to coordinate their motion to put the ranch on the right nut when they are using a mirror.
- joshdick 14y agoNo, it is not two mirrors. What Prof. Hicks made is a single mirror. The linked article explicitly says this.
- prawks 14y agoCompletely disagree with the OP's idea of putting this in a rear-view mirror. One benefit of a rear-view mirror is that things that are on the right side of the mirror are to the right of you, and vice versa. This mirror would break that, unless I'm misunderstanding it. I'm interested in what applications this may have, if any really. I can see it working as a vanity mirror quite well, as then you can truly see yourself as other do. Aside from that?
- shardling 14y agoThe rear-view mirror mentioned by the article in passing is not a reversing mirror -- it's just supposed to be another example of this guy's expertise at fabricating mirrors, in this case to improve the field of view and to remove blind spots.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- duaneb 14y agoIs this not just a reflective lens? I.e. a quadratic surface? If it is, I just assumed people didn't use them because non-reversing mirrors are actually rubbish. There's a reason cameras reverse the image in software but transmit/store the non-reversed image.
- SethMurphy 14y agoThis would be great for giving myself a haircut, but not so much for shaving. Probably because it is more left to right than back to front. I also shave more often and have built up my muscle memory more.
- jere 14y agoAfter knowing the Feynman puzzle, I think this is probably more correctly described as a reversing mirror. If you look into a metal spoon, you'll see both X and Y reversed. So I'm wondering if you could make this mirror simply by only curving the horizontal part. That's kind of what it looks like in the photo. And if so, why didn't someone think of this early? It's quite obvious.
- eru 14y agoPeople thought of this before--just place two mirrors at a 90 degree angle. The guy's innovation is to make it very smooth.
- Thrymr 14y agoNot exactly new: http://www.truemirror.com http://www.truemirror.com
- joshdick 14y agoNo, that link is for 2 mirrors. What Prof. Hicks made is a single curved mirror. That is new. That is why his results got published and he was awarded a patent for it. If you had bothered to read the linked article, you'd already understand the distinction.
- Thrymr 14y agoI agree that it is a neat implementation. I just meant that the idea of a non-reversing mirror is not new.
- jonhendry 14y agoThe curved mirror exhibits distortion at the edges, which doesn't seem to be a problem with the two-mirror approach. Also the curved mirror doesn't present the image at full size, it appears smaller.
- joshdick 14y agoFor those interested in learning more about this, including the math behind the mirror's curve, check out Prof. Hicks's website: http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/ http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/
- Someone 14y agoRelevant part (http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/papers/physics-today.pdf http://www.math.drexel.edu/~ahicks/papers/physics-today.pdf): "As a second example, take the object plane and the image plane to once again both be at x = 1 and define T(1, u, v) ≡ (1, −αu, αv). As with the flat mirror of the previous example, the transformation scales the image plane, but be- cause of the relative minus sign in the y and z coordinates, the solution surface will not reverse an object as a conven- tional mirror does. The relative minus sign also means, alas, that no exact solution surface exists. I obtained an approximate solution surface confined to the rectangular volume x = 34 ± 1 cm, y = z = 0 ± 3 cm, and constructed a prototype mirror. With α = 160, the mirror’s field of view is wide enough that I could see myself in the mirror when it was held at arm’s length, as shown in figure 1. To achieve the appropriate ray paths, the mirror is saddle-shaped." So, this mirror only does its magic in a small volume; if you move your eye closer to the mirror or sideways, or even when you look at it with two eyes, the effect breaks. From cursory reading, I even get the impression that this mirror is also tailored to the positions and shapes of the objects being photographed. But as I said: cursory reading. Corrections welcome.
- DanBC 14y agoHe's looking for uses beyond art galleries. I'm reminded of "The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat" by Oliver Sachs. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Mistook_His_Wife_for_a_Hat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Mistook_His_Wife_f...)
- mistercow 14y ago>The precise manipulations change the directions light rays are reflected off of the surface in a manner similar to changing the angles of millions of tiny facets on a flattened disco ball, but decreasing the size of each facet until a smooth surface is achieved. Oh, so it's like a Fresnel lens, but it's a mirror instead of a lens. That's pretty clever. You get the non-reversing property of a curved mirror, but it's still flat. Edit: Another way of thinking of it is that it's a normal map applied to a real-world object.
- drcube 14y agoHow can he "invent" this? Hasn't it been known for years? It's the same principle as two mirrors at right angles, only instead of a corner, there is a gentle bend. I'm pretty sure I read about this in George Gamow's "One, Two, Three... Infinity".
- readme 14y agoI can't wait until these are on the market. I could save so much money on haircuts. (Assuming the motor-confusion doesn't happen when using this mirror, because the image is not reversed)
- lurkinggrue 14y agoI want one.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- DeCaMil 14y agoBreaking news.... HN abuzz with 2.5 year old story... Hick's work was published via New Scientist (http://www.newscientist.com/gallery/dn16585-amazing-mirrors http://www.newscientist.com/gallery/dn16585-amazing-mirrors) in February of 2009.