5 ms·
I love that argument, because it completely ignores the reality of politics. Politics is a war with words rather than bombs, but if you limit yourself to alway
by tomjen3 14y ago
I love that argument, because it completely ignores the reality of politics.
Politics is a war with words rather than bombs, but if you limit yourself to always speaking the truth, you would be like a commander who never feigns an attack in one place to keep the enemy from attacking somewhere else -- in other words, a very poor commander.
I don't have any doubt that there is something going on with the environment, I am somewhat more sceptical with regards to the long projections (50+ years), but I can't admit that in public, because the automatic response to issues about greenhouse gasses are that we must cut down and degrade our livestyle, rather than build the necessary dikes and compensate for lost farmland by irregating and better management (most useful in the developed world).
However as there is no political consensus for that plan, I have become forced to support the anti-science guys.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mseebach 14y agoWhen the wheels of politics hit the ground, all science is out the window. Many politicians love to claim that the science overwhelmingly supports their policy prescriptions, when it most often can't be said to either support or oppose any particular policy (which is a central point of the article). If you disagree with the policy, and want your voice to count, sometime you have to hold your nose and join forces with people who are wrong in different ways. If you've ever voted for a politician with a reasonable chance of winning, you've had to make the same tradeoff.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>the automatic response to issues about greenhouse gasses are that we must cut down and degrade our livestyle, rather than build the necessary dikes and compensate for lost farmland by irregating and better management (most useful in the developed world). I kind of wonder how much of that is just idiots talking over each other. I have no doubt that there are some people advocating the position you're ascribing to your opponents, but I think it would be a mischaracterization of your more reasonable opponents. Example: Suppose we implement a revenue-neutral energy cross-subsidy. Tax equivalent of ~$50/barrel only on fossil fuels, distributed back to all forms of energy, including fossil fuels. As long as fossil fuels continue to make up a large proportion of our energy consumption, the result will not be a large immediate increase in the price of fossil fuels, because you'll end up paying ~$50/barrel and then getting, say, $40 of that back (the rest going to subsidize non-fossil energy sources). On the other hand, build a wind turbine and you get the same $40/barrel equivalent without paying into the pool, so the market incentive is to build a ton of wind turbines (and solar arrays and nuclear power stations etc.) We end up with a large market incentive for generating less from fossil sources very quickly, which, when acted upon, naturally reduces the amount of the cross-subsidy because it's funded by a fixed-rate tax on fossil fuel use which is now lower, thereby over time making fossil fuels substantially more expensive but only after the replacements have already been developed, constructed and brought online. The result would be a modest short-term increase in energy costs (because fossil would become somewhat more expensive before renewable construction completes) and most likely a long-term reduction (because maintaining an already-constructed renewable power generating facility is less expensive than maintaining the equivalent fossil fuel facility plus having to buy the ever-scarcer fuel). I don't see how it would result in any unreasonable decrease in quality of life. On the other hand, it still isn't likely to happen before the deleterious effects of climate change are felt -- we're already there -- so we still need to take mitigation measures for that like you're describing. But I can't imagine any sound reason why the two should be mutually exclusive.
- tomjen3 14y agoWhile your suggestion is not as bad as others I have heard, any tax increase will automatically result in a lower standard of living.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThe logic is that the cost of the tax will be less than the cost of the extra mitigation measures that will be needed in the alternative. Plus, you get automatic standard of living improvements by destroying more of the other negative externalities of fossil fuel use, like coal mining deaths, air pollution and dependence on foreign oil.