5 ms·
There seems to be some political calculus where it makes sense to pass unconstitutional but popular laws, then let the courts strike them down. Frequently vs.
by rdl 14y ago
There seems to be some political calculus where it makes sense to pass unconstitutional but popular laws, then let the courts strike them down. Frequently vs. the 1st, now against the 2nd, 4th, and 5th. Of course, the courts never really seem to rule for the 9th or 10th.
- mtgx 14y agoI hope you're not suggesting they are doing this for the people. Because the people weren't even aware they introduced this provision in the NDAA 2012, so it's not like it would've scored them any brownie points with the "kill the muslims" crowd. They tried to do it in secret, but civil libertarians found out about it, and then some backlash started. Now the House passed NDAA 2013 with the same provision as in 2012, and the Senate adopted an amendment that banned that "indefinite detention without trial" provision. But the negotiators for the two bills eliminated that at the last moment. So indefinite detention without trial is back. So now it's up to Obama to reject it, but I hope there are no illusions, like last year, that he will actually reject it. He won't.
- jbooth 14y agoI wonder if these senators are the kinds of people who believe that a cop would never lie on the stand.
- thirdtruck 14y agoHumans as a species are rather more credulous of others than warranted by the inherit limitations of our perception, cognition, and retention abilities, even before factoring in deliberate deception. In short, I can believe that.
- rdl 14y agoIt's done for a variety of reasons -- ignorance, special interests, or pandering -- but the same enabler -- not caring so much about the constitutionality of the laws passed. Congress should have a legal duty to uphold the constitution.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoIt doesn't work like that. The judiciary does that.
- jbooth 14y agoThey actually do typically swear to support the constitution as part of their oath of office.
- jug6ernaut 14y agoAs we all know saying one thing and actually doing it are two totally different things. Sadly.
- BerislavLopac 14y agoIt would be interested to see what would happen if it was upheld that a sworn official who passes (or votes for) a law that is later deemed unconstitutional has to step down. I don't believe such a principle would ever be approved by official bodies, but it would certainly have an interesting effect, one way or another.
- pdonis 14y agos/typically/always/
- quonn 14y agoI agree with the grandparent. It's the same thing here in Germany: The parlament has passed many, many unconstitutional laws throughout the last decade. Courts invalidated them later. There are two main issues: 1. Those laws set expectations to what is acceptable. Constitutional but extreme laws later pass as "moderate" in the opinion of the public. 2. Respect for the constitution gradually erodes. 2. Lots of energy is wasted, because EFF type of organizations need to go to court, collect evidence, testify, etc.
- erichocean 14y ago
- jivatmanx 14y agoSounds like they're spamming knowingly unconstitutional provisions that have already been struck down, in an attempt to overwhelm the supreme court's finite capacity to enforce them.
- enraged_camel 14y agoNot sure if it's intentional, but yes, the effect seems to be a form of denial of service.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThey tried to do it in secret, but civil libertarians found out about it, and then some backlash started. No they didn't. Not putting out a press release doesn't mean you're trying to do stuff in secret. The reality is that most people just don't care much about the intended targets of this legislation.
- rayiner 14y agoThe 9th amendment is merely interpretive guidance, and the 10th amendment is a tautology. Also, what is happening with the NDAA is not Congress passing an unconstitutional law. It's Congress passing a law with a potentially unconstitutional interpretation, and both Congressional and Presidential guidance that such interpretation is not intended. Such guidance carries great weight in the court. It's a non-issue really.
- Strang 14y agoThe Tenth Amendment is only now interpreted as a tautology for political convenience. The text reads: The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people. Just because it is now ignored by our government doesn't make it a tautology. It's still the law of the land; it's just being willfully misinterpreted.
- rayiner 14y agoThat's incorrect. It's actually "only now" that the 10th amendment is being interpreted as an affirmative limitation on federal power. Historically, the 10th amendment was considered a mere truism. U.S. v. Darby (1941). Conceptually, how the Constitution works is as follows. The states inherited the sovereignty and unlimited power of the British parliament. In aggreeing to the Constitution, the states delegated some of that power to the federal government, and agreed to refrain from the exercise of certain other powers. The clauses of the Constitution outline the powers delegated and prohibited. All the 10th amendment says is that anything that hasn't been delegated or prohibited hasn't been delegated or prohibited. Which is tautological. The mere face of the text cannot support an interpretation that the 10th amendment does anything other than state the obvious. If a federal action is otherwise Constitutional, by virtue of falling into one of the delegations, then it is by definition something that has not been reserved to the state.
- Strang 14y agoThe Progressive movement's attempts to circumvent federalism date to the beginning of the 20th century, so you can hardly cite a 1941 case to defend your assertion. That was four years after FDR's court packing scheme and eight years after the formation of the National Recovery Administration. As far as I can tell, you only see the Tenth Amendment as a tautology because you take for granted the makeup and principles of the American government. It was not at all a given at the time that the Federal government would leave sovereignity to the states and only exercise certain defined powers. For example, it has largely ceased to do so today, in violation of the Tenth Amendment.
- sigkill 14y agoYours is neither the first, nor will be the last comment I hear sharing this common theme, but I strongly feel that EAFP holds truer in the real world that contains people than our world that contains electrons and holes.