4 ms·
I agree with you that encoding yourself in a system is kind of disconcerting. But i disagree with you encoding your judgement. You have your judgement from year
by dkowalski 1mo ago
I agree with you that encoding yourself in a system is kind of disconcerting. But i disagree with you encoding your judgement. You have your judgement from years of work and when you see something stupid I'm sure you stop it. So your judgement is the critical part and AI will not and should not have it outright as it will almost always make the wrong/non-deterministic decision and you can't keep it accountable. I wrote a blog on this if you are interested.
- nharziro 1mo agoI am interested, so please link it. I agree that our judgment is important, but I think these skills are themselves a form of judgment. The agent uses them to make decisions. It will never be perfect, but it is already pretty good. My issue with this observation is that encoding ourselves into a codebase in the way I described is something our employers did not really get in the past. When you built something for an employer, they got the code and the end product. Sometimes that was a lot, but when an engineer left, they still took their skill set, experience, and judgment with them. Replacing that person was never guaranteed to work out. Now, though, we are starting to leave behind much more of what made us capable of doing that job or building that product in a particular way. The code is no longer the only artifact. We are also encoding parts of our decision-making process, standards, patterns, and judgment into the systems surrounding it.
- dkowalski 1mo ago[dead]